The applicants were found guilty in 2013 by the Nicosia Permanent Criminal Court, for the premeditated murder of Antis Hadjikostis
No violation of Article 6§1 of the European Convention on Human Rights has occurred with regard to the right to a fair trial of the applicants Gregory Xenophontos, Anastasis Crassopoulis and Elli Crassopoulis-Skordellis, who in 2013 were convicted by the Permanent Criminal Court of Nicosia for the premeditated murder of Antis Hadjikostis, says in its decision, with a majority of 6:1, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) issued today.
The applicants had appealed to the ECtHR claiming that they did not receive a fair trial when in 2016 the Supreme Court dismissed their appeals, fully adopting the first instance decision of the Causal Court to convict them. The applicants' appeal to the ECtHR was made because, they claimed, the only testimony against them came from an accomplice who was not prosecuted. Further, the applicant Grigoris Xenophontos claimed that the duration of the case was prolonged, thus violating Article 6§1 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
As regards the claim of violation of the right to a fair trial due to the admission of testimony from an accomplice who was not prosecuted because he was granted immunity, the ECtHR fully adopted the arguments put forward by the Prosecutor General of the Republic. In particular, the ECtHR accepted the position that Article 6§1 does not impose specific rules regarding the assessment of testimony and that the European Convention on Human Rights does not prohibit national courts from relying on incriminating testimony from an accomplice to the crime, even if that accomplice is known to move in criminal circles.
The ECtHR stated that the decision of the Attorney General of the Republic not to prosecute him and instead to admit him to the witness protection programme was exercised within his discretion, and not in return for his testimony. Although the petitioners claimed that the police acted with ulterior motives, however, they failed to specify what the "ulterior motives" were, nor did they provide any testimony of a barter or agreement between the prosecution and the co-conspirator. In view of this, the ECtHR accepted the circumstances in which the witness confessed and which are recorded in detail in the judgment of the Nicosia Permanent Criminal Court.
In addition to this, the ECtHR took into account that the identity of the witness and the content of his testimony were known, as well as the fact that he would not be prosecuted. And the applicants during the trial thoroughly cross-examined both the accomplice and the police officers who questioned the witness in question during the police investigation. As established by the decision of the Nicosia Permanent Court of Cassation, the Court of Cassation was fully aware of the inherent risks in accepting testimony from an accomplice and in its decision conducted a thorough analysis/evaluation of his testimony, with a detailed explanation and concluded that his testimony was genuine.
As regards the different position between the Attorney General of the Republic and the applicants on the existence or otherwise of incriminating evidence against the applicants, the ECtHR considers that its role in this area is limited. It therefore accepted the conclusion of the Supreme Court and concluded, as argued by the Attorney General of the Republic in the present individual application, that the conviction was not based solely on the accomplice's testimony.
In the light of the above, the ECtHR concluded that the fact that the Nicosia Court of Cassation relied on the accomplice's testimony did not lead to a violation of the applicants' right to a fair trial.
The ECtHR also rejected the claim that the duration of the trial was prolonged after taking into account the circumstances, the complexity of the present case and the testimonial material, as well as the applicants' conduct during the trial.
The National Judge of Cyprus, Mr. George Sergides issued a dissenting opinion disagreeing with the majority on the finding of no violation of Article 6§1 due to the admission of the accomplice's testimony.
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source