Open trauma of the coup and the Turkish invasion, says Dr Papapolyviou, former professor of History at the University of Cyprus Interview with the Cyprus News Agency
Closed files and destroyed archives on the one hand, a wealth of new primary and secondary sources on the other.
Old history books, political exploitation, a society that is tired and a society that hopes. On the obstacles that the research historian encounters in his attempt to record the history of Cyprus in 1974, on sources, oral testimonies and the relationship between politics and history, CNA spoke to Dr Petros Papapolyviou, Associate Professor of History at the University of Cyprus.
The first and most important obstacle that the historical researcher encounters is the closed archives, says Dr Papapolyviou.
The first and most important obstacle that the historical researcher encounters is the closed archives, says Dr Papapolyviou. "It is the researchers' belief that 95% of the documents for 1974 from the US or the UK are open, they have been given to researchers. This percentage is inversely proportional for Greek, Greek and Cypriot, records. This is completely unnatural," he notes.
The Cyprus File
Referring to the Cyprus File, he says some small but bold steps have been taken. "Eight volumes have been published in 2018-2019 by the Hellenic Parliament and the House of Representatives with testimonies from the government of Andreas Papandreou in 1986 to the Special Investigative Committee on the Cyprus File. It remains to be continued for the next 20 or so volumes," he says, noting that the effort has been halted since 2019 for incomprehensible reasons.
As he notes, under the Karamanlis government, in March 1975, Greece ordered the lifting of prosecutions against officers for what happened in Cyprus in the summer of 1974. "They hid the issue under the carpet, and as a result, over the years, it went badly wrong," he says. "Today no one is in danger of going to court, except those who are proven to be guilty of war crimes," he notes, adding that "it is completely incomprehensible, especially in Athens, that the contemporary political and military leadership does not have a full picture, when the protagonists of the dictatorship have been tried and convicted for other crimes."
The lack of access to the historical archive leads to a lack of archival documentation that would help provide answers to historical revisionism. "It is outrageous to read books that 'exonerate', for example, the dictator Demetrios Ioannidis for his tragic choices in Cyprus in July 1974 and lack the necessary archival documentation that would provide the appropriate answers and fully illuminate the events," the professor says.
Secondary sources
Apart from the British and American archives, which, according to the professor, the majority of them are believed to be accessible, there are secondary sources from which material can be found. Such are the archives of the Red Cross in Geneva, or those of the United Nations in New York, where there is material on humanitarian issues, on the talks, etc. "Soviet documents are also an unexplored treasure trove for studying Soviet attitudes," adds Dr Papapolyvios. Moreover, he says there are countries that played a minor role, such as France, Yugoslavia, Romania, and others. There are books in circulation, either by historians or diplomats who had a Cypriot involvement, that have produced important documents and testimonies that contribute and can help us complete the picture.
Oral testimonies
As the professor explains, in recent years, when the men who fought with the National Guard or ELDYK passed the age of 60-65, "these people, who until now had kept their mouths shut, began to change their attitude. They are now at an age where they feel they want to leave a testimony for their family or the general public." He notes that this is an interesting aspect of historiography, as there is now a wealth of testimony and younger historians recording these oral testimonies.
"Also, what has been thickening in recent years is the writing activity of the Associations of Warrior Reservists of the battalions that fought in '74. For example, the 'Association of the Surviving Soldiers of the 361st Infantry Battalion' has published a massive book, authored by an excellent young colleague, Charalambos Alexandrou. He had access to some of the military records from the National Guard History Directorate, but most of his primary material was oral testimony, from soldiers and officers. And of course, there is an ongoing production of similar books, based largely on the oral testimony of the warriors."
However, he stresses that while this is very important, "it is not everything. If the historian does not have simultaneous access to the daily orders, the unit war diary or the corresponding orders of the General Staff, he does not have the full picture. Ideally, the two should be combined."
The summer of 1974 is still an open trauma
Dr. Papapolyviou described the Coup and the Invasion as an open trauma. And as such, it is difficult to overcome.
Bringing to mind Seferis' "Last Station", he recites "but the thought of the refugee, the thought of the prisoner, the thought of man as if he too had become a commodity, try to change it, you cannot", demonstrating that there is a significant portion of the population who have lived through the events, who find it difficult to accept that the scientist, the professional historian, will bring to light a different view from the one enshrined in memory.
He adds, however, that there are also those who want to revive the climate of discord and division that prevailed just before the coup in the summer of 1974. "They don't understand or care about what was lost in Cyprus in '74. They are a tiny portion, but, especially with the MDCs, they write uncontrollably, pouring salt on the wounds of the rest," he says, adding further that there are also "political forces on the island who are building policies on this trauma and conflict over history."
Can politics impose itself on history?
Dr Papapolyvios believes that politics exploits history for its own purposes, "clearly, however, it cannot change scientific history. But it can delay it."
He disagrees with the creation of a "Truth Commission" on the model of South Africa. "The 'I did crimes, you did crimes, let's move on' is something a politician can say. The purpose of the historian is to answer the basic questions. If we say beforehand that the purpose is 'to show that we also did crimes, others did too', it is like adopting a prefabricated history from before," he explained."
He went on to say that he considers the submission hypocritical. "In Cyprus, colonialism ended in 1960. No one ever said that a 'Truth Commission' from the erstwhile Great Empire of Britain and the Greek Cypriots should come together and come up with a joint book on what happened in 55-59 between EOKA and colonialism," even though for 62 years "not a single British official has set foot in the Prisoner's Memorials", he said, adding that "I feel particularly aggrieved as a historian to have someone from abroad come to me and say 'there were Truth Commissions in South Africa, so you and the Turkish Cypriots ought to go ahead with something like this'. This will happen, but it will be done in the way of scientific communication and dialogue, as in every other case."
Historical memory and educational policy
"I do not believe that a person who fled his home, his village, his town as a refugee can forget and erase his property, the graves of his parents. But as a group of citizens, a third party can observe phenomena that show just the opposite," he comments, answering whether the fighting spirit has diminished over the years.
Clearly there is a disappointment, whereas in the early years there was a much more vibrant hope of return, he adds. "There are, for example, testimonies of refugees who refused to leave the tents, because they thought they would return to their homes in the first winter," he says.
"Obviously all refugees have taken root in the free areas, we have acquired a new home, new social relations and habits, while older generations are constantly leaving. But it is up to each of us what we will pass on to our children. It is possible that the next generation will have a stronger refugee identity. We have similar phenomena with the Asia Minor and Pontian refugees in Greece," he adds.
Regarding the educational policy around the historical events in question, Dr Papapolyviou concludes that children do not learn exclusively from school about what happened in Cyprus. "There is the internet, there are the stadiums, where in football derbies there is a distortion by the passions between the main political factions in Cyprus that determine young children, much more than what they will hear from their teacher at school. And everything he hears at home, in the street."
However, he adds that it is time, he says, to change the school textbooks. "It is sad that our history textbooks have not been changed since the end of the last century. They have an average age of 25-35 years, they are of the previous generation. It is unacceptable as they are anachronistic and have historical errors."
In conclusion, we kept his exhortation. "Talk about history without fear of the lesson or the historical period. Make children love history and help them provide the answers themselves. We will not pass on our own truths and beliefs to them."
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source[/URL]