"The next President of the Republic should from the very first moment set as his top priority the resumption of negotiations for the resolution of the Cyprus problem and the prevention of the final partition/annexation, which will be disastrous for the future of the whole of Cyprus and its people", former minister and member of the negotiating team, Erato Kozakou Markoullis, tells the Cyprus Times. She believes that the period leading up to the presidential elections in Turkey will be dangerous, "because the Turkish President, who already understands that his political power is being shaken, will do everything possible to achieve his goals, even going to extremes."
Forty-eight years after the invasion and ongoing occupation, we are faced with a prolonged stalemate on the Cyprus problem. How do you see the facts?
It is truly unthinkable that 59 years after the bicommunal riots and 48 years after the Turkish invasion, we have still not reached a solution to the Cyprus problem that ends the Turkish occupation and allows for peaceful coexistence and joint governance of the two communities in a reunited homeland. Dozens of efforts have been made by the seven Secretaries-General of the United Nations since 1963 to date, but unfortunately they have remained ineffective, mainly because of Turkish intransigence, but also because of political expediency and the lack of courage and political will on our side. As a result, occupation and division are becoming ever more entrenched, both on the ground and in the minds of the people. The accession of the Republic of Cyprus to the European Union in 2004 and the discovery of hydrocarbons in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of the Republic of Cyprus, unfortunately, did not act as a catalyst for the resolution of the Cyprus problem, as we had hoped. On the contrary, new problems and complications have arisen, especially on the issue of hydrocarbons, with the continuous violations of the EEZ of the Republic of Cyprus by Turkey and the tensions that have arisen, which aim to call into question and cancel the entire energy programme of the Republic of Cyprus. 48 years later, we are unfortunately in the worst situation on the Cyprus problem that we have ever been in! The fait accompli is now entrenched, new fait accompli is being dangerously created, such as with the opening and continuous violations of the status quo in Varosha, and efforts for a solution have been undermined since the termination of the Crans Montana Conference, unfortunately and through our own fault. Tragically, a unique opportunity to move towards a solution was missed when for the first time we were within a radius of agreement on almost all issues, especially on the land issue, where for the first time the difference in the area to remain under TC administration was reduced to one percentage point and maps were submitted, but also on governance and power-sharing issues, where almost all outstanding issues had been agreed. In the rest, the SG, by submitting his framework on 30 June 2017, managed to propose a balanced compromise that took into account the concerns of all sides.
After the collapse of the negotiations in Crans-Montana, the Cyprus issue started to slide, which contributed to the undermining of the most progressive TC leader, Mustafa Akinci, which led to his not being re-elected. The elevation to the TC leadership of the nationalist Ersin Tatar in October 2020, the Turkish side's complete rejection for the first time of the agreed basis for the solution of a bizonal, bicommunal federation and its insistence on a two-state solution, has led the Cyprus problem to a prolonged stalemate, bringing us ever closer to the realization of the nightmare of partition and the complete Turkification/annexation of the occupied territories to Turkey.
At the informal five-party meeting in Geneva, the Turkish side clearly raised the issue of sovereignty and has been talking openly about a two-state solution ever since. Is it possible to bridge the positions of the two sides?
The decision to convene a Conference with the participation of the guarantor powers at the appropriate time was originally taken at the UN Secretary General's meeting with the two leaders, President Anastasiades and Mustafa Akinci, on 25 November 2019. The same meeting had confirmed the basis for a solution and the parties' commitment to the 11 February 2014 communiqué, the convergences reached up to Crans-Montana and the Secretary-General's Six-Point Framework. Under those circumstances, it was logical to consider convening a Conference with the participation of the guarantor powers. However, the convening of the informal five-party meeting in Geneva in April 2021 took place under completely different circumstances. Both the new Turkish Cypriot leader Ersin Tatar and Turkey shifted their position on the basis for a solution and renounced earlier commitments to a federal solution, insisting on sovereign equality and a two-state solution.
With such a gap separating the positions of the two sides, it was in my view a huge mistake to convene the informal five-party meeting, which enabled the TC leader to present his dichotomous/secessionist proposals before the UN. Above all, it was a tragic mistake to involve the three guarantor powers in issues that do not concern the international aspect of the Cyprus problem, i.e. security and guarantees, as has been the standard practice to date. The gap between the position, on the one hand, of a bizonal bicommunal federation solution with political equality, which is the official position of the Greek Cypriot side and the international community, and, on the other hand, of a two-state solution, which is the position of Turkey and the Turkish Cypriot leadership, is enormous and there is no possibility of bridging it or finding common ground. What needs to be done is to put pressure on the Turkish side to return to the agreed basis of a bizonal bicommunal federation and to resume the talks from where they left off in Crans-Montana, preserving all the workload, the convergences and the SG framework, which are guarantees to move towards the only realistic solution to the Cyprus problem, the federal one.
Do you see any prospects for a resumption of any effort before the 2023 presidential elections in Cyprus and Turkey?
We should not forget that in other periods, negotiations continued to take place up to a few months before the presidential elections. For example, under the Presidency of George Vassiliou, negotiations on the Gali Ideas Package with the then Turkish Cypriot leader Rauf Denktash were conducted intensively until 11 November 1992, three months before the February 1993 presidential elections. When there is political will, as well as credibility for a solution to the Cyprus problem, and there certainly was on the part of President Vassiliou, anything is possible. At the present juncture, however, we are faced, on the one hand, with the totally intransigent attitude of the Turkish side to sovereign equality and a two-state solution and, on the other hand, with the President of the Republic, who for the last five years, following the collapse of the Crans Montana Conference, has done nothing decisive towards the resumption of negotiations.
The United Nations Secretary-General and the international community, faced with this impasse, have made no effort, particularly since Mr Tatar took over the leadership of the Turkish Cypriot community, to bring the Turkish side back to the agreed basis for a solution. If there was real political will on our side, we would have moved heaven and earth to activate the international community in this direction. But it seems that, unfortunately, the intransigence of the Turkish side suits all those who do not want things to move forward. Under these tragic circumstances, I do not see any realistic prospects for the resumption of efforts to find a solution to the Cyprus problem before the 2023 presidential elections in Cyprus. The same applies to the presidential elections in Turkey, where President Erdogan is already facing problems with his candidacy and his alliance with the nationalist leader of the Grey Wolves, Devlet Bahceli, would not allow him to make any concessions from the intransigent position of the two-state solution, which is a common program of the Justice and Development Party and Bahceli's Nationalist Action Party.
The first pre-election debate of the main contenders for the presidency of the republic was reduced to what happened in the past, rather than how to move forward in the future. In your opinion, what should we do to get out of the quagmire?
In cases of pre-election debates, it is both natural and necessary to put on the table issues concerning the positions taken in the past by the candidates currently running for the supreme office of the Republic of Cyprus. In this way, citizens, through the presentation and analysis of actions and data, will be able to correctly evaluate and conclude who emerges in their consciousness as consistent and honest and who is judged as unreliable and co-responsible for committing mistakes, with their actions or omissions, which inevitably led us to the current tragic situation, a breath away from partition/annexation. In addition, the debate on the past is inevitable in order to see whether the candidates have, through their course and actions, those characteristics of a leader that will ensure to the Cypriot citizen that his/her future will be better. Such characteristics are timelessness and consistency in integrity of character, ethos, virtue, virtue, acumen, experience, maturity, knowledge, wisdom, wisdom, honesty, integrity, humility, restraint, self-discipline, rectitude, honesty, humanity, courage, determination, judgement and sound and prompt decision-making at times of crisis, insight, respect for the law and organisational skills. By their personality, the candidates for the Presidency should inspire confidence and respect, and this perception can only be formed when citizens have the opportunity to thoroughly examine all the candidates' characteristics and long-standing positions.
It is equally important and necessary that the candidates present detailed and comprehensive programmes, aimed at the progress and prosperity of all Cypriots, on all issues related to internal governance, the economy, justice and the fight against corruption, broader social and labour policy, culture, foreign policy, health, education, security and defence, sustainable development, combating climate change, innovation, support for young people and gender equality. The specific and detailed strategy to be implemented to resolve the Cyprus problem, which remains a bleeding wound and a huge obstacle preventing the Republic of Cyprus from functioning and developing as a normal state, should play a primary role in the presentation of the programmes. Generalisations and vague statements have no place at such a critical juncture.
What would you advise the next President of the Republic to do in order to get the Cyprus problem moving?
The next President of the Republic should from the very first moment set as his highest priority the resumption of negotiations for the resolution of the Cyprus problem and the prevention of the final partition/annexation, which would be disastrous for the future of the whole of Cyprus and its people, Greek Cypriots and Turkish Cypriots. To this end, it should seek the assistance of the international community towards the Turkish side to return to the agreed basis for a solution of a bizonal bicommunal federation with political equality, so as to enable the resumption of negotiations from where they ended in Crans-Montana, ensuring a) the six-point framework presented by the Secretary General on 30 June 2017, on the basis of which a strategic agreement will be sought through negotiations, b) all the progress achieved so far Coordinated action should also be taken to prevent the creation of new tragic facts in Famagusta, through a formal appeal to the Security Council (and not through statements by the President of the Security Council, as to date), demanding an end to illegal actions and the immediate implementation of resolutions 550 and 789, which requires the immediate inclusion of the fenced area of Famagusta under UN administration to allow for the return of its legitimate inhabitants.
The realisation of these objectives requires an intensive and targeted international campaign to reach international protagonists in the most important decision-making centres of governments and international organisations. But to be effective, we need to convince the international community of our political will for a solution, which has been in doubt for at least the last 5 years, due to our policies and attitude in Crans-Montana and beyond, in order to regain our international credibility. This will be achieved not by statements and speeches at anniversaries and memorials, which are usually made for internal consumption, but by initiatives and projects aimed at improving the climate between Greek Cypriots and Turkish Cypriots and confirming our will for a solution based on the agreed framework and convergences, as achieved until Crans-Montana.
The new President of the Republic should make the right choice of his partners, not only in the Council of Ministers, but especially in the negotiations for a solution They should have the political courage to express their views, even if they are not liked, and to resign if their principles conflict with the policies being pursued.The President should also pursue a targeted policy of reaching out to the Turkish Cypriot community, with substantial and effective confidence-building measures that build real bridges and prepare citizens for living together and governing the country.
The President should also pursue a targeted policy of reaching out to the Turkish Cypriot community, with substantial and effective confidence-building measures that build real bridges and prepare citizens for living together and governing the country. Finally, the President of the Republic should inform the people transparently about what has been discussed up to Crans Montana and what convergences we have reached (by making public all our convergences and documentary proposals and not by selectively leaking documents, as is the case today), as well as to start a public dialogue on the advantages of a federal solution for all Cypriots, something that has never been done systematically. The future of our state and our people should not be kept secret and become the subject of political games and electoral intrigues. Is there the incentive for all sides to try again, or is there not? For example, could energy act as a catalyst, as was the European perspective in 2004?
There is no doubt that after 48 years there is enormous fatigue and frustration, both among Cypriots and in the international community, to the point that there are already voices behind closed doors and in public rhetoric for other solutions to the Cyprus problem. Tatar and Turkey, since October 2020, already demand a two-state solution and sovereign equality as a precondition for attending talks, while on our side, even the President of the Republic himself, "in a storm of ideas", discussed several times behind closed doors a two-state solution, even with the Turkish Foreign Minister himself. For me, this is unacceptable and disastrous, because partition, because that is what the two-state solution is all about, will lead to the loss forever of our occupied territories, which will eventually be incorporated into Turkey, with all the dangers that such a tragic eventuality entails for the whole of Cyprus and the Cypriot people.
It is for this reason that it is necessary for the new leader of Cyprus to have as his major vision the reunification of our homeland, not as a long-term perspective, but with a sense of urgency, and to fight with passion and determination for its realization. We cannot afford experimentation, new adventures and tragic mistakes that will be disastrous for the historical course of our country. We must create and revitalize the motivation for the solution. The people need a leader who will inspire and guide them on a realistic path, with the prospect of a better future for both communities in Cyprus. Therefore, much should be done in the direction of activating civil society and involving them in the solution process, so that they do not feel alienated and distanced.
Regarding the energy issue, unfortunately, so far it has not acted as a catalyst, but on the contrary, it has acted as a factor of conflict and confrontation, complicating the already existing problems. What needs to be done is to be consistent and send systematic messages that, with the solution of the Cyprus problem, the exploitation of hydrocarbons will benefit both communities and the federal state of Cyprus and that Turkey, no longer as an occupying power and aggressor, but as a close partner and collaborator, will be able to play a substantial role, together with other countries of the Eastern Mediterranean, in the phase of exploitation and transfer of hydrocarbon resources in the region. These messages are heard from time to time, but they are not systematic and targeted. More effort is needed to convince of our intentions, but above all of our expectations and our vision for a Cyprus and an Eastern Mediterranean of peace, progress and prosperity."
Developments following the Russian invasion of Ukraine highlight the role of Turkey, which defiantly disregards Western sanctions against Moscow, but at the same time remains its favourite ally. How negative is this for our side?
Turkey has always had and still has an agile and flexible foreign policy, which it has always used as a tool to promote its national and strategic interests. It has done so at the present juncture as well. Through subtle and skilful manipulations, it has turned a tragedy such as the Russian invasion and the merciless war in Ukraine to its advantage by projecting the necessity of its intervention as a venue for negotiations and as a mediator for the transfer of messages and proposals on both sides. In this way, it has so far avoided the application of Western sanctions against Russia, under the pretext of the need to maintain 'neutrality' in order to be able to continue its 'mediating' role. Unfortunately, this has been tolerated both by NATO itself, to which Turkey belongs, and by the EU and the United States, which are at the helm of the sanctions against Russia. Through these manipulations, Turkey has made itself one of the main protagonists in solving this tragic problem and its role has been significantly upgraded in the region.
There is no doubt that this upgrade creates problems for Greece and Cyprus, because Greece's NATO allies and our EU partners will not be willing to take any measures against Turkey, beyond the verbal condemnation that we have enjoyed lavishly in recent years, in case of new provocations and illegal actions by Turkey in the Eastern Mediterranean. The only safety net, for Greece at least, is the strong desire of NATO and especially the US to avoid any Greek-Turkish conflict, which would irreparably damage the cohesion of NATO's southeastern wing, with unpredictable consequences for the alliance.
How do you interpret the extreme rhetoric of the Turkish President, who came to power in the early 2000s with a completely different pro-European political agenda, with the support of major power centres in the US, EU, UN and elsewhere? To what do you attribute this political transformation, if I may use the term?
It is a fact that when he was elected Mayor of Istanbul at the age of 40 in 1994 and later when he took over the leadership of the Justice and Development Party and ascended to the Prime Ministry of the country in 2003, Tayyip Erdogan put forward a pro-European policy because he aimed to tame the power of the military and the deep state and relied on the support of the EU and the US to get rid of the military's monopolization of national issues. His relationship with Greece in the first decade was cautious and no serious tensions were observed, because he needed it in this effort.
Tayyip Erdogan's transformation became more evident after the failed military coup on 15 July 2016, from which he emerged victorious and absolute ruler, managing to remove all his opponents in the military, academia, the civil service, the media, the judiciary and the intellectual world. It was then that he began his rapprochement with Moscow, believing that the West had betrayed him. No longer having the European perspective to guide his policies, he did not need Greece and the EU to support him. This led to extreme revisionism and the creation of tensions with Greece and Cyprus, with positions that the revision of the Lausanne Treaty was necessary and with illegal actions aimed at challenging Greece's sovereignty and sovereign rights in the Aegean and the Greek continental shelf, violations of Cyprus' sovereign rights in its EEZ and serious violations of the status quo in Varosha. His ascension to the Presidency of the Republic with enhanced powers in 2017 and his alliance with the nationalist Nationalist Action Party president, Devlet Bahceli, in 2018, helped to concentrate all the powers in his hands to achieve his goals, which is to emerge in the 2023 presidential elections, marking 100 years since the founding of the newest Turkish state, as the new Kemal and savior of the nation. The period until the presidential elections in Turkey will be a dangerous period, because the Turkish President, who already realizes that his political power is being shaken by inflation, corruption and the impoverishment of the Turkish people, will do everything possible to achieve his goals, even going to extremes.
The war in Ukraine has also changed the priorities at the global level.
The war in Ukraine has also changed the priorities at the global level. The food crisis, precision, the caravans of refugees, de facto displace other problems, such as the Cyprus problem. How dangerous is this issue for us, knowing first-hand how the global governance system works?
There is no doubt that after Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the devastating war that has been going on relentlessly for more than five months, with the dramatic consequences you mentioned and many others that have affected primarily the Ukrainian people, but also millions of people across Europe and other continents, we are faced with an emerging new world order that is not yet fully formed. The main axes of this new order will be, on the one hand, the West and countries that support its positions and, on the other, Russia and China, together with other countries that continue to cooperate with them because of economic and other strategic interests. The focus of all initiatives and efforts on the part of the West is to address the Ukrainian issue and punish Russia, either through a series of unprecedented sweeping sanctions already imposed, or through unprecedented military and economic assistance to Ukraine to cope with Russia's ongoing attacks. The Cyprus problem and many other international problems have taken a back seat to the priorities of the international community, especially problems such as the Cyprus problem which are perpetuated with no apparent prospect of a solution. However, despite the new global climate, this is an 'opportunity' to remind our partners in the European Union and the wider international community that the same provisions and principles of international law that are currently being flagrantly violated by Russia in the case of Ukraine have been systematically violated over the past 48 years by Turkey in the case of Cyprus, without Turkey having suffered any consequences to date for its systematic and ongoing violations and for its disregard for the rule of law and the rule of law. We should of course be realistic that the international community is not going to suddenly impose sanctions against Turkey, especially for events that have occurred and continued for almost half a century, (we have tragically seen this over the last four years with the EU's reluctance to impose meaningful sanctions in cases of Turkish violations in the EEZ and Famagusta). However, the invocation of this parallel should be aimed at taking new initiatives by the international community to resolve the Cyprus problem, before we are faced with new fait accompli and complications that will make the resolution of this long-standing problem definitively unfeasible. I believe, therefore, that there is a window of opportunity which should not be missed.
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source