What's new

[PIO] Statements of the Attorney General of the Republic in relation to the case of National Guardsman Thanassis Nikolaos

30452.jpg





The Attorney General of the Republic, Mr.George Savvidis, held a press conference today in connection with the case of National Guardsman Thanasis Nikolaou and the further actions of the Legal Service following the study of the findings of the independent criminal investigators.

During his opening statement, Mr.

"Recognizing the family's right to be informed in relation to the investigation into the circumstances of Thanasis Nikolaos' death, we had extended an invitation to both the lawyer Mr. Loukaidis and the family of the deceased to attend the Legal Service today in order to be informed in relation to the report of the criminal investigators and the next steps to be taken."

"Recognizing the right of the family to be informed in relation to the investigation into the circumstances of Thanasis Nikolaos' death, we had extended an invitation to both the lawyer Mr. Loukaidis and the family of the deceased to attend the Legal Service today in order to be informed in relation to the report of the criminal investigators and the next steps to be taken. The interested parties, for their own reasons, which they explained in their statements to the media, did not attend.

We note that the right to information in relation to the investigation of the circumstances of the death of National Guardsman Thanassis Nikolaou is indisputable and is covered by Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), as well as by the relevant case law of the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR). Similarly, the obligation of the state to provide sufficient information to relatives to investigate the circumstances of a death, particularly where there are suspicions of criminal activity, is indisputable.

Under normal circumstances, the reports of criminal investigators are not made public, not even to interested parties. If you look back in the past, you will see that this has been the long-standing position of the Legal Service. However, since it is a report concerning a provocation of death, legal principles apply, also in accordance with ECHR case law, as to what should be disclosed to the relatives of the victims in the context of information.

The ECHR guidelines on Article 2 of the Convention on the Right to Life record that relatives must be involved in the proceedings to the extent necessary to safeguard their legitimate rights. It is further recorded that the investigating authorities are not obliged in the course of their investigations to comply with every request by relatives for specific investigative measures.

This is stated in Ramsahai and others v. The Netherlands, Application no.52391/99, Grand Chamber, dd. 15.5.07.

With regard to the merits of the case, having studied the Report, based on the findings of the criminal investigators which point to a criminal act against Thanasis Nikolaou, we consider that it should be sent to the Police for further investigations, which were not carried out by the criminal investigators appointed. Despite the difficulties arising from the fact that 17 years have passed, we are making this effort in the hope that there will be a full resolution of the case.

In view of the above, the decision of the Legal Service in relation to the possible prosecution of persons for matters relating to possible defective investigation will not be taken now, but after all investigations have been completed by the Police, so that there is a complete picture and no risk of abuse or multiplicity of proceedings.

We will propose that Mr Alexopoulos, one of the two criminal investigators who prepared the Report, assist in the Police investigations.

We have repeatedly indicated to Mr Savvas Matsas that as a criminal investigator he was and continues to be bound by the obligation to maintain complete confidentiality in relation to the contents of the Report and all the evidence leading up to it. Unfortunately, we have witnessed a systematic and ongoing breach of this obligation, both before and after our warnings. His actions do not allow us to recommend to him as well to participate in further investigations.

Therefore, bearing in mind that the investigations will continue, the Legal Service is ready to hand over the Report to the family, having deleted only certain names which is intended to safeguard further investigation and possible criminal and judicial proceedings from possible disclosure of evidence, as well as the presumption of innocence of persons against whom suspicions may be raised or responsibility may be attributed. The 33 Annexes accompanying the Report and the statement of the deceased's mother are also provided in full.

However, 15 of the 16 statements will not be provided in full, but a summary of their substance is included in the main body of the Report.

This position of non-disclosure is supported by the jurisprudence of the ECtHR in Ramsahai and others v. The Netherlands, Giuliani and Gaggio v. Italy, GÜRTEKİN and others v. Cyprus Decision[/I],[/I] in which, inter alia, it is recognised that the disclosure or publication of police reports and material from an investigation may involve sensitive matters which may give rise to prejudice and or affect persons or investigations.

In view of the time that has elapsed, I will ask the Chief of Police to give the highest priority to completing the investigations.

We once again express our respect to Thanasis' family and our support which we have shown in practice and will continue to translate into action, always within the framework of legality, professionalism and the safeguarding of the principles governing both criminal investigations and possible future proceedings and human rights."

Responding to a reporter's question as to whether certain criminal charges could be brought independently of the police investigation, Mr. Savvidis noted "Without going into the substance of the conclusion, but unfortunately much has already been said about the report of the criminal investigators, because in some cases it is mentioned that possibly the non-performance of certain actions may not be limited to mere negligence, and because it may be necessary to fully investigate the case to know exactly what the actual involvement of any of the parties involved is, we felt that, once we do further investigation, we should wait for the Police investigation to be completed.

At the same time, asked whether there is a specific timetable for the Police to complete the investigation, the Attorney General reiterated that the Chief of Police will be asked to do so as soon as possible, noting: "You understand that both the peculiar circumstances of the case and the passage of a long period of time and the necessity for those who will study the case to be fully informed of the large testimonial material, which consists of the many investigations that have been conducted to date, which unfortunately have not led anywhere, I cannot determine when the Police will finish, but we certainly want it to be finished as soon as possible."

Also responding to a question from a reporter, he said, "This is not a truncated report, we are just going to cross out some names because we think that is what should be done. Every criminal investigation is done on the instructions of our office either by the police, which is the norm, or by the criminal investigators. In every criminal case a completed report comes to our Office, which includes the witness material. This is how it is done in cases where criminal investigators are appointed. This material cannot be the subject of public discussion, nor is it something which, to the extent that it is the assessment of either the police examiner or the criminal investigator, is of any particular significance, because it is simply guidance to those who make the final decisions, which under the Constitution is the Attorney General. Here the report will be given as an exception to the rule, which stems from the judgments of the ECHR. And you should know that the Republic of Cyprus has already been convicted in this case for defective investigation, by a decision of the European Court of Justice in 2020. The family had an appointment to come here today at 11am but did not show up. There have been some postings on the MSM, some letters have been sent by her lawyers, but we felt it was right, as part of our obligation to inform the public of our own actions, that we had to inform this conference, and then we will inform the family."

(MB)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO

Source

 
Back
Top