In connection with the publication of the newspaper 'Politis' by Mr. Manolis Kalatzis dated 17 November 2022, regarding the rental of two helicopters for aerial firefighting, the Forestry Department of the Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Development and Environment, to restore the truth, informs the public as follows.
1. What is the basis of comparison, by what evidence and in any case by what logic is the cost deemed outrageous. Hence the title of the article "'The cuckoo nightingale' cost us two Kamov firefighting helicopters" is unfounded, unsubstantiated and misleading in terms of impressions.
2. a) We have answered and are answering now. For the lease of aerial firefighting services, one procedure, one way exists, the holding of an open tender (with bids). That's what we did, following all the procedures under the Public Procurement Act and Regulations and that was the result. And the price that we have secured is 35% lower than the price that this particular company informed the European Commission that it can make available its helicopters, which even carry 2500 litres of water instead of 4000 litres that the Kamov helicopters carry. [BR] (b) In view of these facts and figures, it is possible that the publications are intended to serve the interests of a particular economic operator who took part in the tender.
3. The publication states "Based on information obtained by P from Forestry Department sources", but the forms presented in the publication are from the Fire Department. At another point the publication states that it is the Forestry Department that used the helicopters. We have stated and indicated that it is the Fire Department, not the Forestry Department, that has operational control of the helicopters. If a distinction cannot be made between the Fire Department and the Forestry Department, if such simple issues are not presented correctly, one has to question the correctness of the other issues.
4. The publication refers to "costs of €47,000 per hour". A cost per flight hour exists and is specified in the Contract and amounts to €3600/hour/helicopter (excluding VAT). This calculation makes no sense whatsoever. The cost of availability is one thing and the cost of the flight is another. Yes, it is reasonable to see what the total cost was for the year, but not to reduce it to per flight hour. This calculation was done to present the cost per flight hour as high, to create an impression. The helicopters flew the hours they needed to fly. And it is to our credit that, following international practice, from this year the contract has been amended to pay a cost per day for availability and a cost per flight hour. Thus, the 10 days of November that were extended will be paid for availability but not one cent per flight since they did not have to fly.
5. Precisely because there was no logic to this calculation they messed up and the calculations they made are wrong. The publication refers to €47,000 per flight hour per helicopter. Two errors. The cost is €36,047 (excluding VAT) per hour and it is for both helicopters. But the calculation of the cost per month is also wrong. The publication mentions that they cost us €1 600 000 per month when the actual cost is €767 500 per month. In the end, the simple mathematical operations, as the publication called them, turned out not to be simple.
6. The fact that the helicopters stayed in Cyprus can only be seen as a positive thing. The issue of maintenance is a matter for the company and it is their responsibility to maintain them and have them ready for the coming summer season when they will again be inspected upon delivery. The helicopters can be maintained anywhere provided that the maintenance centre has the capability for the specific type of helicopter and will obtain the relevant certification from the Civil Aviation of Ukraine.
7. (a) There is an issue of "fair" treatment. An over-effort that lasted 8 months following, as has been said many times, the procedures according to the Public Procurement Law and Regulations, when the Contracting Authority, i.e. the Forestry Department, all this time was acting in cooperation with all parties involved, i.e. the Public Procurement Authority and the Tender Council of the Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Development and Environment, and there was also a case where the assistance and contribution of the Auditor General himself was sought, cannot be treated in this way. Officials who overreached themselves cannot be victimized. There should be an investigation and the Attorney General should be involved to establish the truth. However, the investigation should also include the possibility that the publication may have served the interests of a particular economic operator who took part in the tenders.
(b) It has been and is again stated that the operational control of the helicopters is the responsibility of the Fire Service and not of the Forestry Department. Of the 68 hours and 46 minutes, the Fire Service used them for 51 hours and 16 minutes, they were used in the British Bases for 14 hours and 52 minutes and the Forestry Department for only 2 hours and 38 minutes. It goes without saying that the Fire Service should have managed this Contract. The Forestry Department has been awarded the management of the Contract in 2018 despite our disagreement. Why was it not assigned to the Police which had an Air Operations Unit (AOCU) with helicopters and to which the Fire Service was attached? Justifiably again the Forest Department is asking for "fair" treatment
8. With regard to the report in the publication that the tender was tailor-made for Kamov, we repeat that it was an open tender in which any type of helicopter capable of carrying more than 3500 litres of water could participate. There were other types and in fact there was successful participation in the tender of another type and the award was finally decided on price. So how was it tailored to Kamov's measurements?
(MB/SX)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source