What's new

[PIO] Position of the Cyprus Fiscal Council before the preparation of the Budget for 2023

30187.jpg





As the Republic enters the phase of finalizing the Budget for 2023 and the Medium Term Fiscal Framework 2024-2025, many of the stakeholders are at the peak of quantitative analyses and final estimates of the figures. The process is particularly difficult this year, not because the calculation methods have changed, but mainly because it requires much careful information, discussion and analysis of the assumptions and working assumptions on which the subsequent quantitative analyses will be based.

However, before the final analyses of the figures - before the numbers - a number of observations have already started to become clear.

The Cypriot economy continues to show resilience and robustness in the face of the ongoing difficulties recorded through 2022, even though these followed two otherwise difficult years of reduced growth. Both real growth and employment continue to move at a satisfactory pace, with the Cypriot economy continuing to perform very respectably compared to our other partners in Europe and the Eurozone, despite continuing difficulties due to inflationary trends and supply chain turbulence.

Moreover, public finances continue to inspire credibility and stability, with no serious fiscal developments, despite the circumstances of the last 36 months and increased spending to address the health and subsequently the inflationary crisis.

However, the current picture should be treated as temporary, as the international economy is sounding serious warnings that the immediate years ahead will bring greater and broader challenges.

Even though unemployment rates remain low, in part due to high corporate earnings in recent months, the US is already under increased pressure and is likely to be in recession already. The resilience of stock markets, based mainly on corporate earnings, has already begun to show the first serious cracks.

Similarly, the EU and the Eurozone are under high pressure, with the possibility of recession now clearly visible, even if, in this case too, some individual fundamentals, such as employment, have not yet reflected the pressures on the economies.

At the same time, monetary authorities are expected to continue to move towards monetary tightening policies under the burden of continued inflation - and qualitative evidence that this burden will not ease in the near future. A race between the US and Frankfurt is now very likely, with continued recessionary interest rate increases to counter inflation.

Apart from the ongoing inflation, and the ECB's need to keep the euro's exchange rate against the dollar - the currency in which a number of important production resources are priced - the situation in international trade, where we are already seeing a decline in exports from China, remains a major problem. This is a sign that, if it continues, portends a further deterioration in the already troubled and problematic picture in shipping, with all that this obviously entails for our economy. Already the pressures on shipping are increasing, with qualitative signs (e.g. insurance premiums and delays) foreshadowing continued difficulties in the coming months.

Although at this stage initial estimates of a deceleration in inflation (but not a fall in prices) from the autumn are not being revised upwards, at the same time pressures on aggregate supply in our economies remain, with increased costs and increased delays in the production of a range of goods. The fact that the rating agencies have started to factor these risks into their ratings of the Cypriot economy is a natural consequence of the exogenous pressures.

It is now clear that the situation in Europe in terms of securing gas reserves is difficult, and OPEC has sent clear signals that it will not allow oil price reductions to continue.

One of the issues that remains, particularly for Cyprus, is that inflation rates are inherently lower in services than in industrial and manufacturing goods. Thus, as increases in producer and consumer prices continue, our main exports cannot offset the cost of imports in the national accounts. Therefore, our main exports of services, including tourism, will continue to become competitive, but profit margins will erode, partially offsetting any gains from a possible increase in volumes.

As the costs of our imports will therefore rise, our export prices will not be able to rise equally, taking advantage of repricing to cover the increased costs. At the same time, growth rates in services cannot easily keep pace with those of industry and manufacturing. Therefore, the potential increase in activity volumes will probably not be enough to reverse the pressures on our national economy.

This picture, of a resilient Cyprus economy, currently performing well, but surrounded by worrying developments in the international economy, should be the central pillar of our approach to the 2023 State Budget.

This picture, of a resilient Cyprus economy, currently performing well, but surrounded by worrying developments in the international economy, should be the central pillar of our approach to the 2023 State Budget.

As we have insisted since the beginning of the year, any promise that the legislature or the executive can take action against inflation is a fallacy. As fiscal authorities without monetary tools, they do not have the tools at their disposal to deal with inflation. Even if many of the proposals sound reasonable at first sight, it must be clear that neither the relevant theory nor the relevant experience can justify the hope that measures involving fiscal expansion (increased spending or reduced taxes) will reduce inflation. They never have, and they won't now. This is one of the few certainties of the present circumstance.

Given these facts, it is clear that the approach to the government budget must be governed by caution and prudence, and that it would be wiser to avoid over-optimistic estimates, including theoretical increases in government revenues. The Republic has increased revenues this year, but it will need them, and this is certain, over the next 24 months.

There is a surplus, but, given the clouds on the horizon of the global economy, there is no cushion.

Instead, fiscal policy should focus on growth, targeted protection and employment, with primary surpluses underpinned by investment in the real economy. A conservative fiscal policy is also in line with the recommendations of the European Fiscal Council.

Finally, it is necessary to reiterate that the horizontal measures are socially unfair, contrary to the objectives of the Green Transition, ineffective in their stated objective and wasteful. The taxpayer is paying to serve a socially and environmentally unjust policy, and the economic stability of the country in the coming years is also at risk. Policy support for low-income households and small and medium-sized enterprises is economically wiser and socially and morally fairer and should be preferred. The implementation of the 2022 and 2023 recommendations, as resulting from the Stability Programme implementation framework, should be reflected in the 2023 budget

(MB/SX)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO

Source

 
Back
Top