What's new

[PIO] Announcement of the Legal Service in relation to judgments of the Supreme Court, delivered on 20 July 2022

29270.jpg





On 20 July 2022, the Plenary Session of the Supreme Court examined three Petitions of the President of the Republic, which concern Social Security Laws passed by the House of Representatives, an Appeal of the President of the Republic concerning a conflict or challenge to powers under Article 139 of the Constitution and, under its composition as an Electoral Court, an Electoral Petition concerning the annulment of the election and declaration of political leaders as Members of Parliament during the 2021 parliamentary elections.

Specifically:

(i) "the Social Security (Amendment) Act, 2021"

(ii) "the Social Security (Amendment) (No. 4) Act, 2021"

(iii) "the Social Security (Amendment) (No. 5) Law of 2021"

for which the Supreme Court, in its decisions, held that they are contrary and inconsistent with the provisions of Article 80.2 of the Constitution and, by extension, contrary to Article 179 of the Constitution. They also destroy the constitutional Principle of Separation of Powers. Further, the Supreme Court held that the Referred Laws interfere with the powers of the executive to assess the conditions for the provision of allowances in the exercise of its administrative function and its power to assess the financial consequences that such provision will have on the Social Security Fund.

According to the Supreme Court, the finding of unconstitutionality for the Referred Law (i) is based on the fact that it broadens the category of persons who will be entitled to an invalidity pension In Appeal 1/2022 President of the Republic n. House of Representatives, registered under Article 139 of the Constitution, the President of the Republic - Petitioner appealed to the Supreme Court against certain provisions of the 2022 Budget Act, 2021, which, according to the Appeal, were contrary to the Constitution and EU law. In particular, the Appeal sought the annulment of an amendment to the approved Budget of 2022, under which the employment of advisers and associates of the President of the Republic, ministers and other officials is terminated upon the expiry of the government's term of office or the departure of the officials.

In its majority decision, the Supreme Court dismissed the Appeal, accepting the preliminary objection of the lawyers of the House of Representatives that the President of the Republic-Petitioner could not, under Article 139 of the Constitution, challenge certain provisions of the said Law, after he had signed and published it, thus confirming, by that act, its constitutionality. In the present case, the Supreme Court did not examine the merits of the case, but rather focused on the fact that, ex post facto, the partial challenge to the said Law exceeds the limits of the President's power and assumes "a form of repressive control of unconstitutionality", which it does not possess.

The application was handled on behalf of the Attorney General of the Republic by Mr Dimitris Lysandrou and Ms Elena Simeonidou, Senior Advocates of the Republic, and Ms Zina Charalambous, Advocate of the Republic.


3. In relation to an Election Petition concerning the annulment of the election and proclamation of political leaders in the parliamentary elections of 2021, the petitioner claimed the annulment of the election and proclamation of Mr. Averov Neophytou, Andros Kyprianou, Nikola Papadopoulos and Christos Christou as successful and duly elected to the House of Representatives, considering it as unconstitutional, because no preference cross was given in favour of any of them, despite what the electoral law stipulates which, among other things, provides that no preference cross is given to a party leader.

The Electoral Court, by a majority decision, accepted the preliminary objection raised by the Attorney General of the Republic, representing the General Election Supervisor and the Supervisor of the Electoral District of Nicosia, and finding the petition filed by the petitioner to be inadmissible and irregular, ruled that the petitioner failed to establish any form of interest or detrimental effect on his electoral right so as to merit protection and justify the intervention of the Election Court.

The case, on behalf of the Attorney General of the Republic, was handled by Ms. Gianna Hadjihanna, Senior Advocate of the Republic and Mr. Simos Platis, Advocate of the Republic.


Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO

Source

 
Back
Top