The decision of the Supreme Court in the action brought by the President of the Republic against the House of Representatives under Article 139.1 of the Constitution, concerning a conflict or contestation of power or competence between the House and an organ or authority of the Republic (Appeal 1/2022) was issued today.
The aforementioned appeal had as its contentious issue the addition by the Legislature of regulations to the law approving the state budget for the fiscal year 2022, which were based on relevant amendments, submitted at the stage of the adoption of the disputed Law and approval of the relevant budget by the deputies of the parliamentary groups AKEL-Left-New Forces, the Democratic Party, the Social Democrats' Movement EDEK and the Ecologists' Movement-Civic Co-operation. According to these amendments, the employment of advisers/associates of the President of the Republic, Ministers, Deputy Ministers, the Government Spokesperson and the Speaker of the House of Representatives (political appointments), who were converted into permanent or fixed-term employees and irrespective of the provisions of the relevant legislation (No. Law No. 70(I) of 2016) or any other law, shall be terminated upon the expiration of the term of office of the Government or the departure of the aforementioned officials.
In the petition in question, the annulment of the relevant legislative provisions had been sought, since, according to the grounds invoked, the said provisions had been enacted without authority and/or competence, as well as in violation of the applicable constitutional principle of separation of powers. Moreover, they were adopted in breach of European Union law and, in particular, of Directive 1999-70/EC of 28 June 1999.
According to the judgment of the majority of the members of the Supreme Court, the fact that the President of the Republic had signed the law in question, which was adopted and published in the Official Gazette of the Republic, even though he disagreed with the provisions in question, confirms that he had exercised his constitutional powers and the appropriate prudential control of constitutionality, confirming the constitutionality of the
As the Supreme Court's decision emphasizes in this regard, ex post facto and selectively, there is no question of challenging the specific legislative provisions, and the invocation of Article 139.1 of the Constitution does not alter the whole issue, since the alleged conflict of powers is based on the challenge of the contested provisions as unconstitutional. The ex post facto challenge ultimately takes the form of a repressive review of constitutionality, which presupposes the resolution of the dispute raised in the context of judicial proceedings, a matter which is not within the competence of the President of the Republic.
The House of Representatives was represented before the Supreme Court by the law firm Chryssafinis & Polyviou LLC.
(Text as sent by the House of Representatives)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source