In connection with the publications of the newspaper POLITIS ("P") of Mr. Manolis Kalatzis, dated 1 and 2 October 2022, regarding the rental of two helicopters for aerial firefighting, the Forestry Department of the Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Development and Environment, in order to restore the truth, informs the public as follows:
1. The Department of Forests, following the Law and Regulations on Public Procurement and the established procedures, made an over-effort, which is confirmed by the mere fact that it took eight months, to rent two helicopters for aerial firefighting for the years 2022 and 2023 with the right to renew for the year 2024 and the year 2025. The key stages of this effort were. Sending the Tender documents to the Public Procurement Authority for approval, on 28 December 2021.
(b) Announcement of the first relevant Tender (TOR 03/2022) on 25 January 2022. The tender was cancelled because the only company that submitted a bid did not meet the conditions for participation.
(c) Announcement of the second Call for Tenders (TOR 40/2022) on 15 March 2022, which was again cancelled because the only company that submitted a bid, which was the same company that participated in the first Call for Tenders, did not meet the conditions for participation.
(d) Announcement of the third Call for Tenders (TOR 48/2022) on 29 April 2022, using the negotiated procedure. 26 entities showed interest, 7 participated and 2 were found to meet the technical part.
2. The publication states "P has taken note of the contents of the report (of the committee member who refused to put his signature) .... while awaiting the actions of the Attorney General, the Auditor General and the Ministry of Agriculture."
The Department of Forestry reports that the Auditor General has requested all of the Department of Forestry's tender documents to review them and, if he deems it appropriate, to conduct an audit, and that he hand-delivered the documents to the Auditor General on Wednesday, September 28. There is also an interest in whether there is a question of order as to how "P" came to know.
3. The paper states that "the Committee Coordinator" was "attempting to persuade the other members (who are his subordinates) apparently implying that as his subordinates he could impose on them and do as he pleased.
The Department of Forestry states that there was no designated Committee Coordinator and that the Committee members were:
- Stelios Kotsiekas, Head of the Landing Gear Unit, Member
- Alexis Kourtellas, Landing Gear Operator, Member
- Stavros Kyriakou, Police MAP , Member
- Dimitris Tuvannas, Fire Service, Member
- Kostas Skordis, Flight Engineer, Member
It is documented that the reference is incorrectly made to the "Coordinator of the Committee". Further, only one of the members of the Commission is directly supervised by Mr. Kotsiekas. Mr Kostas Skordis, who belongs to the Aircraft Unit, does not have Mr Kotziikas as his immediate superior. Not only that, the Committee could have had three members, but it was chosen to be a five-member Committee in order to have the participation of more specialists and experts from other Services to ensure transparency.
The report that the other members of the Committee are subordinate to the Coordinator is undoubtedly a distortion of the truth.
The report that the other members of the Committee are subordinate to the Coordinator is undoubtedly a distortion of the truth. When even the composition of the Commission has been distorted, a matter which is not normally open to different interpretations, it is reasonable to doubt the accuracy of the content of the publications, especially on technical matters. Among other things, we recall that in an earlier publication of "P", again by Mr. Kalatzis, the Court's Order for the disclosure of documents was presented as a Judgment of the Court condemning Rossavia, the owner of the helicopters.
4. The dissenting member had every right to do so. He was never instructed to sign against his will, instead he was instructed on the procedure which he appears to have been unaware of. This even delayed the submission of the report. The Committee, which consisted of five members, took its decision by recording the dissenting member's views. Written replies were given by Mr Kotziikas, point by point. It is therefore reasonable to ask why the publication did not counter the answers given. Is this not what ethics dictated? It was not even mentioned that answers were given. Answers to all the questions will be given later when answers are given to the issues raised in the publications. However, in order to ensure complete transparency and to put an end to the privileged possession of information by the 'Citizen' and to prevent issues from being presented as they see fit, the correspondence between Mr Kotziikas and the dissenting party is being made public in its entirety, so that experts in particular, who are in a position to understand things better, can form their own opinion. Due to the volume, it cannot be provided as an attachment and will therefore be posted on the Department's website.
5. The newspaper states "so that they (i.e. the helicopters) can be utilized by the Forestry Department."
The Forestry Department states that the "P" should have known that the operational responsibility for the helicopters lies with the Fire Department, not the Forestry Department. What difference does this make? Everything has its importance. It shows how well the reporter knew the subject. Just as he did not know this subject, he does not know the other subjects either.
6. The newspaper reports "as it had for many months raised questions about the Forestry Department's insistence on hiring Russian firefighting helicopters again this year."
The Forestry Department says it had no insistence on Russian helicopters. Since open tenders were held, any economic operator could submit its proposal with the helicopters it wanted. An open tender is "open" to any proposal which is why it is called open. In our effort to carry out our mission to respond to forest fires, serving the national interest and doing our duty and with a high sense of responsibility it was our position in cooperation with our Ministry, in the event that it is not possible to meet the need in any other way to make every effort and exhaust every possibility at the political level to waive the ban on companies and helicopters of Russian interests. This position has been reduced to an insistence and a major issue. They should tell us where and how our persistence was shown and not just say that we were persistent.
We had two unsuccessful tenders, and in the third there were two economic operators who met the technical part, one of them not with Russian helicopters, but for the years 2022 and 2023 it was more expensive by €818 000. Based on the award criterion set out in the tender, which was the lowest price, it was awarded to the tenderer with the lowest price. So what were we supposed to do? The publication states "despite the fact that there were helicopters available from other western countries, much more modern" and "despite the fact that cheaper options were available". We have reported and it has been pointed out that it took eight months of effort to get helicopters. We don't know the amount of time P allocated. It was expected and is expected to provide more data and information: Did the economic operators who had helicopters from other western countries, much more modern, take part in the tender or not? If not, why did they not take part? If they did take part, it means that they were excluded. Tell us the economic operators, if any, who feel wronged, so that we can publicly give the reasons why they were excluded.
7. The newspaper states "the two KAMOV-32s were leased by the Forestry Department and will cost us almost €17.5 million by 2025 despite the fact that there were much cheaper options within the specifications set."
The Forestry Department on this matter states that the price offered was the result of three tenders and that this was the market price. There are several factors that determined the price. If "P" knows of ways to secure better prices we are ready to listen to them. We had reported and we repeat now that the price offered is 35% lower than the price offered by a company that expressed its interest to the European Commission to offer its services and even with helicopters carrying 2500 litres instead of 4000 litres carried by the helicopters leased by the CP. It is not the Forestry Department that made the decisions. The Forestry Department made recommendations which received the approval of the competent bodies, namely the Ministry of Finance and the Tender Board of the Ministry of Agriculture, Rural Development and Environment
It must be said that 2024 and 2025 are options. When the decision to exercise or not to exercise the option is taken, the data will be evaluated and we will act accordingly. It cannot be ruled out that with the lack of flight assets and the uncertainty that exists the prices will go up even more.
8. The publication states "Amidst the many paradoxes..., there is a March 18th directive from the EASA ..... for a no-fly directive .... Among them are Kamov-32s leased by the Forestry Department."
The Forestry Department reports that the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) has not banned Kamov 32 helicopters from flying in the EU. The ban refers to the type certificate and has nothing to do with permits to fly Kamov 32 helicopters and even includes specific models of the KAMOV 32 manufacturer which does not include the type of helicopters leased by the RS
9. The publication refers to "alchemy and illegality" in relation to three issues: the operator's licence, the helicopters' insurance certificate and whether helicopters should be checked by the Civil Aviation Department. There is ignorance, hence the confusion surrounding these issues.
The Forestry Department reports that Rossavia's Air Operator's Licence originally did not include the area of Cyprus. No bid was submitted by a company whose air carrier licence included Cyprus in advance in the areas where it could carry out aerial firefighting. This is to be expected because Air Operator's Licences are issued by the Civil Aviation Authority of each country which has registered the aircraft on its register and includes the area of that country. Should an airline wish to operate for aerial firefighting in another country then the consent of the other country is also required. This was the case in this instance, and would have been the case for any company winning the Tender. The Commission was right to ask the company to amend its air operator's licence. The Air Operator's Certificate was amended by the Civil Aviation of Ukraine which also issued the Air Operator's Certificate. This example illustrated the role and work of the Commission.
As regards the helicopter insurance certificate that has been filed, it includes the area of Cyprus as a general area of operations which then, by amending the Air Operator's Certificate and adding aerial firefighting in Cyprus, confirmed full compliance with the conditions. The helicopter insurance is under the reinsurers of UK based Lloyds, a company with extensive experience and expertise in aviation insurance (Aviation Insurance).
Air firefighting operations in Cyprus are carried out on behalf of State Agencies and as such the helicopters are considered State owned and do not fall under the control of the Civil Aviation Department
When on these matters the publication sees "Alchemy and illegality" then comments are unnecessary.
10. The publication refers to "Crooked eyes on deviations". It is the specific reference that is "squinty-eyed". First of all, there were no material deviations from the Tender. It was known that some equipment not affecting the flight capabilities of the helicopters was not installed, and there is an agreed installation schedule and it is included in the Contract. This was included in the Evaluation Committee Report and received the approval of the Tender Board and the Acceptance Committee did not have to deal with these deviations at this particular time The members of the Committee should have been aware of this
11. The publication makes reference to "fake certificates". All certificates submitted by the company that won the tender and their subcontractors were signed and stamped by the relevant departments of the state agencies of Greece and Ukraine. If there is evidence of forgery, the matter is very serious and the evidence should either be provided to us or submitted to the competent authorities for further investigation.
12. In conclusion, the dissent of one member of the Commission, ignoring the opinion of the other four members of the Commission and without any investigation by a competent body or the opinion of an expert, has become a major issue. Having made it a major issue, they are now trying to make it even more so with their references to 'suspected scandal' and 'suspected corruption'. Our response is a one-word answer, "ELEOS."
13. But the best answer to these reports comes from the excellent results on the battlefield. The results are not just good or excellent, t are the best results ever achieved and even while the entire Mediterranean was on fire[/B] By the end of September, only 29 hectares of forest area and only 0.4 hectares of state forest had been lost in the Department's zone of responsibility. We simply and humbly say that, with exactly the same dedication and zeal that we worked on the battlefield, we have worked on this lease
14. The response through projects is not limited to the work of responding to fires. Some of them are noted below.
(a) The Department of Forestry has protected and managed state forests in such a way that we are justifiably proud. This is not a figure of speech, it is a conclusion that can be drawn if one takes a look at the basic facts:
i. the state forests are home to
- 1400 of the 1649 plant species of the Cypriot flora
- 110 of 141 endemic plant species
- 20% of birds live exclusively in the forests while another 20% depend on the forest for their lives
ii. 80% of the Natura 2000 network is forest areas
iii. 60% of the Natura 2000 network is state forests
(b) Enforcing order in land issues concerning state forests. Zero tolerance for new and removal of old interventions. Target June 2023 to have removed or promoted the removal of all encroachments, not one square meter of state forest land encroached upon. Unfinished business of the 1940s declaration of state forests is completed. Enforce order and modernize management of annual use permits and leases of state forest land.
(c) Reduce arrears from 6 million to 1 million.
(d) Currently, the Department of Forestry is implementing projects worth more than 50 million. The usual amount was in the range of 7 million. This means a workload, but the Department is coping. Just a few of them are noted:
i. Better organization and strengthening of the forest fire response system. The completion of the projects in this phase will not bring it to the desired levels, but it will bring it to another level compared to today.
ii. the implementation of the Plan for the operation of the Akamas National Forest Park. We are only one step before its official launch.
iii. the upgrading of the Urban Forest Parks, namely the Pedagogical Academy, Athalassa and Polemidia.
iv. the restructuring of production in forest nurseries to improve and expand greenery and maintain biodiversity.
(NΓ/IK)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source