Regarding today's publication of the newspaper "Politis", which shows the Audit Service agreeing with the direct award of the management of the new Limassol stadium to the three football clubs, with allegedly its only reservation concerning the amount of the rent, the Audit Service states the following:
1. We have repeatedly stressed our commitment to the principled position that if state property (state land, state forest land, public buildings, stadiums, etc.) is to be allocated to private parties (this is primarily a policy decision), the award should be made through open and transparent procedures since only these, firstly, ensure the principles of equal treatment and non-discrimination and, secondly, maximise the benefits for the public. Since 2014, this has been provided for as a legal obligation under Law 38(I)/2014 and since 1998 this has been decided by the Court of Justice of the European Union.
2. Especially for the new Limassol stadium, the obligation to award the management of the stadium through open and transparent procedures takes a specific form if it is deemed to be a service concession contract which falls under public procurement legislation. We recall that the project serves purposes of general interest and that the stadium should be granted for use to other teams, clubs, organized groups, etc. at the suggestion of the Cyprus Sports Organization (CSO), elements which refer to a service concession contract.
3. In addition to the issues relating to the award of public contracts, serious issues arise concerning the obligation of the CIO if the award is found to constitute State aid:
- first, not to approve the measure without a positive opinion of the State Aid Control Authority (SAI) on the compatibility of the measure with State aid rules; and
- second, not to put the measure into effect unless it has been previously notified to and approved by the European Commission.
In this regard, on 29.9.2022, we forwarded our views and concerns to the SCC, which has the statutory responsibility for monitoring the implementation of the above, and indeed has drastic enforcement powers, including the suspension of the implementation of the State aid measure and the termination of the illegality.
4. With regard to the amount of the rent referred to in the publication in question, we note that the image that this will be determined on the basis of political interventions and negotiations reinforces the arguments that the award constitutes State aid. In this respect we note in particular the following:
- The study carried out by the CBA's consultants came up with three charging scenarios, very different from each other, which indicate the impossibility of reliably determining the market rent.
- By nature, the calculation of the market rent of such activities is difficult and unreliable, unlike, for example, the estimation of the market value of land.
We consider it important that the European Commission itself, in its interpretative communication (97/C 209/03) on State aid elements in sales of land and buildings by public authorities, referred to in a circular of the SCC dated 10.10.2003, has stated that 'the Commission itself, in its interpretative communication (97/C 209/03) on State aid elements in sales of land and buildings by public authorities, referred to in a circular of the SCC dated 10.10.2003, has stated that the State aid elements in sales of land and buildings by public authorities by public authorities, referred to in a circular of the SCC dated 10.10.2003, are not in fact State aid elements. 26.2.2014, explaining that it applies by analogy to cases of leasing, explicitly states that in cases of sales without a tender, 'the initial cost of the acquisition of land and buildings by the public authorities is an indicator of market value, unless a long period of time has elapsed between the purchase and the sale of the land. For this reason, n principle, the market value should not be set below the original cost for at least three years after the acquisition, unless the independent valuer finds a general fall in market prices for property in the relevant market."
In the present case, the CMA's consultants,
- first, instead of using the original cost (approximately €40 million), they used a lower amount (€28,4 million).) because they concluded that this is what the stadium should have cost (a position for which, if they are right, the CTO will have to explain to taxpayers why they built a stadium that cost €11.6m. more than it should have based on its number of seats);
- secondly, they used a rate of return on use of only 3% which is appropriate for land leases but not for structures with a finite life;
- thirdly, even with the above, they arrived at the figure of €851,000 per annum, for which, it seems, the CAA is prepared to accept a figure much lower than even that.
5. We recall that at a meeting of the Parliamentary Committee for the Monitoring of Development Plans and Control of Public Expenditure on 19.5.2022, the CMO had pledged that it would immediately forward the matter, through the SCC Office, to the European Commission, and that receipt of the Commission's approval would precede the concession of the land to any private party.
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source