What's new

[Cyprus Times] What the PEGA committee focuses on during its contacts in Cyprus

pegasus-1.jpg

Export licenses and links between companies and individuals in Cyprus and Greece on the agenda of contacts, says PEGA president

Practices regarding the possible export of surveillance technologies from Cyprus, as well as links between companies and individuals in Greece and Cyprus will be among the issues expected to be raised by MEPs during their contacts in Nicosia on Tuesday and Wednesday, MEP Geroun Lennaers, chairman of the European Parliament's committee of inquiry into the use of Pegasus and related surveillance software (PEGA), told the Cyprus News Agency.

The visit, which is part of an investigation into the use of spyware in Greece, will continue with a series of meetings in Athens until Friday.

Mr Lennaers told CBC that during its visit to Cyprus, the PEGA delegation will focus particularly on the legal framework for the export of spyware and related technologies and software and will seek clarification on whether NSO Group has exported products from the country.

He also said that the spy van case is not directly related to the PEGA investigation, as it predates the Pegasus allegations, but that he expects MEPs to raise questions about the way surveillance issues are handled in Cyprus.

Mr Lennaers also said he did not know more about reports of links between the companies involved that were or are active in the two countries, but that PEGA would seek clarification.

PEGA's president also told the CBC that he was pleased to see the European Commission addressing the issue of surveillance at the EU level, and called for minimum standards for e-safety to be established across the EU, also noting the need for Europe to become a leader in global efforts to regulate the sector.

Emphasis on export licences and links with Greece and Israel



Asked about the agenda of the delegation's meetings in Cyprus, Mr Lennaers pointed out that the visit combines contacts in Greece and Cyprus and lasts longer than usual after approval by the European Parliament. He noted that the investigation is set in a different context in each country, as in Greece there are media reports "about the use of spy software against journalists and politicians", while in Cyprus the issue is more about "the issuing of export licenses" and how the process works.

"There are some companies whose names have come up in the investigation that have links to Cyprus," he added, referring to the NSO Group and the question of whether export licenses were granted.

In this context, Mr. Lenaers, the MEPs will meet on Wednesday with Trade Minister Natasha Pilidou and Deputy Minister of Digital Policy Kyriakos Kokkinos, as they are "responsible for parts of this legislation", adding that he believes this will be the "most important, most effective part of the visit".

Asked to comment on conflicting reports from NSO Group and the Cypriot government on the issue of export licenses, the head of the delegation said that during PEGA's visit to Israel, MEPs asked the company to comment on what it said about exports from Cyprus and Bulgaria. Their response, he continued, was that Pegasus is not the only product they sell and that "they have a range of products."

As he understood the response, he added, the company "may be limited to the Israeli export license system, but for other products other than Pegasus they may have used Bulgaria or Cyprus."

"If the Cyprus Government says that no export license was granted for any NSO Group product at all, then I think there is an inconsistency between what the NSO Group says and what the Cyprus Government says. If they say there was never an export licence for something like Pegasus, then that would be consistent with what the NSO Group is telling us," he added.

On surveillance in Cyprus and the spy van case

Regarding the allegations of surveillance in Cyprus itself and whether these have been brought to the attention of the committee, the PEGA chairman said he expects these issues to be raised, but added that as far as he knows, these allegations fall in a different context from those concerning Greece, Spain, Poland or Hungary.

He added that the committee has also been informed through MEPs from various political parties about the possible use of spying software in prisons, and said that the government has "publicly already provided a lot of information about this", noting that he expects this issue to be raised with government representatives by members of PEGA. He also noted that the delegation is due to meet with the Attorney General on Wednesday, and that he expects the issue to be raised at that meeting as well.

Asked to comment specifically on whether the delegation would also be concerned about the spy van case that was made public in 2019, Mr. Lenaers noted that this case "far predates the mandate to investigate Pegasus" and that it "does not directly concern our committee."

However, he continued, he is confident that there will be MEPs who will raise this issue "also from a historical perspective" in terms of "the way these issues are dealt with in Cyprus".

More broadly, he continued, given that PEGA is investigating the use of spying software across the EU and not just in the countries it visits, this also means that it could also look at what has happened in the past, citing the use of FinFisher in Germany as an example.

Asked to comment on reports of links between the activities of companies providing spyware in Greece and Cyprus, the MEP pointed out that there is a reason why the committee is visiting both countries, as it is known that there are links between companies such as Intellexa and individuals such as Tal Dillian with both Cyprus and Greece and Israel.

"We will ask questions, we will ask for information about these companies and these individuals who are or have been active in both countries," he added.

Mr. Lennaers recalled that PEGA has so far made visits to Israel and Poland and added that "the cooperation we have had from both the Cypriot and Greek governments in organizing our mission and our talks with representatives of member states at the ministerial level is really in stark contrast to the way we were received in Poland and even in Israel." He added that of course "we will have to look at the atmosphere in which the meetings will take place, the questions that will be asked, the answers that will be given and the willingness to have a proper democratic dialogue".

Asked about the reports in Greece referring to links between political figures and companies involved in surveillance, Mr. Lennaers said he has read the same reports and can only raise questions about them without additional information.

"We will raise questions on this issue. We will of course call the journalists in Greece who have written about certain stories, we will ask them for further clarifications, we will ask the government representatives to answer," he said, adding that it is impossible to definitively assess these reports from Brussels.

Commenting on the delegation's upcoming visit to Athens, the PEGA president said that journalists who wrote the most recent reports have been added to the delegation's contacts and that he believes they will have an interesting exchange of views with the Greek Minister of State, as well as with the members of the special investigative committee of the Hellenic Parliament on how it operates and the results of its investigation.

Need to examine the European framework for surveillance

Asked what gaps the Committee of Inquiry has identified with regard to the regulation of surveillance practices across the EU, Mr. Lenaers said that the first draft report by MEP Sophie in Weld which will be published next week is expected to focus on "the export import regulations, the dual-use regulations, whether they need updating to provide for spyware like Pegasus."

"We also need to look at the European framework that allows the use of this kind of spyware," he added, citing the case of Hungary where PEGA will travel in February. In Hungary, he added, "the Hungarian government's data protection authority investigated more than 200 such cases and concluded that everything was done according to the law."

"If in Hungary one can, according to the law, spy on 200 journalists, activists and so on, then something about the law is not completely functional," he added.

As for the situation at the European level, he referred to concerns expressed by experts during committee hearings about "zero-day vulnerabilities, security holes in software and mechanisms" and the "thriving market" that also exists in Europe and makes money from these vulnerabilities. He added that it is well known that member states do not report these vulnerabilities when they identify them so they can be patched, and that "instead they store them, wanting the member states themselves to use them when it suits them."

There should also be transparency to protect victims of surveillance, as well as measures to ensure they have access to justice, he said.

He also pointed out that although the European Parliament's remit is only for the EU, the bigger picture must be taken into account because "if we start regulating really tightly in the EU but these companies move abroad and continue to provide the same services to the rest of the world and to many undemocratic regimes outside the EU, then in the end we will have made no progress."

For this reason, he continued, MEPs are also considering whether the EU "can play a leading role in a global agreement to regulate the spyware sector".

In response to a question about what journalists, politicians and individuals who could be affected by such practices could do, Lenais said that "as sad as it sounds, if you are talking about spyware on the level of Pegasus, all the digital savvy in the world will not save you." As he pointed out, this is such an advanced and expensive technology that there is not much a consumer can do.

"At the same time we know that there are many other types of spyware, from very sophisticated to very basic," he added, suggesting that issues need to be addressed regarding mandatory updates for mobile devices, apps or software for longer periods of time, especially on cheaper android phones which are no longer updated when new models enter the market. He stressed the need to promote public awareness and the development of minimum standards for technology development.

He also welcomed the fact that the European Commission has realised that this issue does not only concern member states, but that it is important to take action at EU level. Referring to the new European Media Freedom Act promoted by the Commission, Lennaers pointed out that "the use of spyware against journalists is still not completely banned, because there are some exceptions, but it is largely stamped out."

He stressed that this is the right approach which should be followed up to protect not only journalists but also other groups such as lawyers and individuals.

Source: CNA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top