"Vladimir we are losing!" Criticism behind Putin's back and inside the Kremlin Extreme bickering among Putin's allies
A member of Vladimir Putin's inner circle has in recent weeks voiced his disagreement directly to the Russian president over his handling of the war in Ukraine, according to information obtained by U.S. intelligence agencies, The Washington Post reveals
The criticism marks the clearest indication of turmoil within the Russian leadership over its handling of a war that has gone disastrously wrong for Moscow, forcing Putin last month to order the recruitment of hundreds of thousands of troops in a desperate attempt to reverse recent losses on the battlefield.
It is worth noting that the specific information was deemed so important that it was included in US President Joe Biden's daily intelligence briefing and discussed with other US officials, according to people familiar with the matter who spoke on condition of anonymity.
Mismanagement and mistakes
The dissatisfaction expressed by the member of Putin's inner circle related to what he saw as mismanagement of the war effort, as well as mistakes made by those running the military campaign.
The identity of the "insider" could not be confirmed, though the name has been included in U.S. intelligence reports.
The new information, combined with comments by Russian officials, underscore the divisions within Putin's upper echelon, where officials have long been loathe to bring bad news to an authoritarian leader who is seen as more isolated than at any time during his 22-year rule.
A spokesman for the National Security Council declined to comment on the information.
The number of people Putin counts as close or trusted associates and advisers is small, consisting mostly of former colleagues from his time as a KGB officer and those he met when he was deputy mayor of St. Petersburg in the 1990s after the collapse of the Soviet Union.
The draft caused internal unrest, prompted hundreds of thousands of Russians of draft age to flee the country, and many people were plagued by bureaucratic incompetence after being asked to report to the military and not being eligible.
"Putin is not on the brink"
As the war enters its eighth month and Russian victory remains elusive and unclear, the unquestioned faith Putin enjoyed may be slipping, intelligence officials said, but cautioned that there is no indication that the Russian leader is on the brink.
"Since the start of the occupation in Ukraine, we have witnessed a growing concern among some in Putin's inner circle," a Western intelligence official said. "Our assessments suggest that this concern has been triggered primarily by recent Russian casualties, the misdirection of the war and widespread military shortfalls."
A second senior Western official said the internal tensions "are consistent with the way the campaign for the Russians has unfolded and the atmosphere in the Kremlin. There are a lot of people who are convinced that this is not going well or that this is not the right course of action."
Peskov: "Absolutely untrue"
Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov acknowledged that there were disagreements and discussions among senior Russian officials as Putin faced critical decisions like the draft.
"There are disagreements at such times. Some people think we should act differently," Peskov told The Washington Post. "But this is all part of the normal process."
Asked about disagreements within Putin's inner circle, Peskov said: "There are working arguments about the economy, about the conduct of the military operation. There are arguments about the education system. This is part of the normal process and is not an indication of a split."
However, Peskov said reports by US intelligence agencies about a person in Putin's inner circle directly challenging the Russian leader are "absolutely untrue."
However, Peskov said reports by US intelligence agencies about a person in Putin's inner circle directly challenging the Russian leader are "absolutely untrue.
Armed with US and European weapons, Ukrainian forces have recaptured thousands of square miles of territory in recent weeks from a Russian army suffering from personnel shortages.
The losses have prompted the Kremlin to hastily stage staged referendums and announce formal annexations of occupied territory, widely condemned as illegal, while it has begun recruiting hundreds of thousands of military reservists despite the risk of domestic backlash and protests.
Putin has also threatened to take extreme measures to protect Russian territory, including the use of nuclear weapons, hoping the threat will make Ukraine's supporters think twice about how far Kiev should be allowed to go.
Extreme bickering among Putin's allies
The situation has led to public criticism of Putin's defense minister and his top generals in a rare outburst of discontent.
Ramzan Kadyrov, head of Russia's Chechen Republic, who has sent Chechen militias to fight against Ukraine, attacked a top general in recent days and said he should be demoted to private.
Following these comments, Kadyrov announced that Putin had promoted the Chechen to the rank of general colonel.
Yevgeny Prigozhin, a longtime Putin ally whose Wagner mercenaries are also fighting for Moscow in Ukraine, agreed with Kadyrov, describing Russian military leaders as... "trash" in a statement.
One official, posted by Moscow in occupied Kherson, described the retreat of Russian forces in recent days northeast of the city as a "regrouping" and claimed the area was "locked down", but also called top Russian military leaders "traitors and incompetents"!
"Indeed, many people say that if it was the defense minister who brought things to this situation, they would shoot themselves if they were real officers," Kirill Stremousov, deputy head of the Russian-installed Kherson command, said Thursday in a Telegram video.
"Putin's position is fragile."
Putin's problems on the battlefield are exacerbated by an accidental draft in Russia.
"It seems to me that his position is fragile," a Russian official said of Putin in an interview the day the draft was announced."
"All these months, we've been hearing that half the world is on our side. But neither Modi nor Xi support it now," the Russian official said, referring to Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Chinese leader Xi Jinping, who appeared to distance themselves from Putin's war effort during a summit last month in Uzbekistan.
In another conversation this week, the official said he had not heard of any immediate reactions to Putin from his inner circle. But "there are complaints" from the heads of parliamentary committees about how the president and the military are conducting the war - "about why the military is not being properly supplied, about why the campaign is not going as it should," the same Russian official explained.
Senior security officials in Europe said they were unaware that anyone had dared to directly challenge Putin on the course of events in Ukraine and added that they had not seen U.S. intelligence reports criticizing Putin.
Even so, some of these officials said that cracks are becoming increasingly apparent in many layers of the Russian system, citing instances of criticism and recriminations throughout the Russian military, security services and regional governments that are now forcing men of draft age to serve.
"Criticism behind his back and inside the Kremlin"
A senior European security official described a growing "criticism of Putin behind his back", including from within the Kremlin ranks. "They think he's stubborn," the official said, and "obsessed with Ukraine" - an "obsession they don't necessarily agree with."
A second security official in Europe said: "There are scapegoats. They are being pointed fingers. This is all happening."
Two Russian business executives who maintain contacts with political officials echoed these sentiments that dominate Putin's circle, and said the coming weeks could be critical for the Russian leader's future and the decisions he will make about the war.
If the Russian military does not stem the losses, then internal strife will erupt, said one of these people, a member of Russia's business elite. "This is a breaking point."
The draft has proved widely unpopular in Russia and may signal that Putin, feeling pressure, may take extreme measures.
For months, Putin resisted the call for additional troops, even as battlefield casualties suggested he had not deployed sufficient forces at the start of the war.
As early as the spring of this year, when Putin's plan for a rapid invasion and occupation of Ukraine had clearly expired, U.S. intelligence analysts estimated that he would have to announce a widespread draft - amounting to hundreds of thousands of additional troops - if he hoped to achieve his goals, which at the time Putin believed he could still do, according to a senior U.S. official familiar with the matter.
The most dangerous move of his career
Putin's decision to draft 300,000 extra troops, according to Russian officials, ranks among the most destabilizing and politically dangerous moves of his career and "could lead to regime instability," a European security official said.
Others, however, said that despite the mass exodus of military-age men from Russia, Putin has crossed an important threshold without causing any substantial internal challenge to his authority.
Even regional officials, angered by the draft, are overwhelmingly complying, providing tens of thousands of recruits.
"Everyone is eager to look for signs of Russia folding, and you do see internal tensions," a senior Baltic official said. "But Russia is now in a war phase and it's still moving forward. We have seen nothing to suggest otherwise," he added.
Source: in.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source