The Turkish Cypriot community from 1974 to today and relations with Turkey What internationalist A. Sozen says The violation of the territorial integrity of the Republic of Cyprus has been condemned and therefore the partition is not realistic, says internationalist A.In an interview with the Cyprus News Agency
"A partnership structure based on citizenship (federation), respect for each other, respect for each other's identity, culture and language."[/QUOTE]
"A partnership structure based on citizenship (federation), respect for each other, respect for each other's identity, culture and language. This is what I want for Cyprus," says Turkish Cypriot internationalist Ahmet Sozen on the 48th anniversary of the brutal Turkish invasion of Cyprus.
In an interview with the Cyprus News Agency (KYPE), Sozen explains the reasons why the two-state solution promoted by Ersin Tatar's leadership is not feasible. At the same time, he refers to the impasse facing the modern Turkish Cypriot community, the importance of a bizonal, bicommunal federation and focuses on his community's relations with Turkey.
The violation of the territorial integrity of the Republic of Cyprus has been condemned.
The violation of the territorial integrity of the Republic of Cyprus has been condemned. Therefore, I do not consider the division of Cyprus to be realistic.
The Turkish Cypriot community from 1974 to the present
How does the T/C internationalist assess the efforts of the Turkish Cypriot side to build an alternative "state structure" in the occupied part of the island after 1974? "You asked a very difficult question. In 1974, it was not clear what exactly the Turkish side wanted. At that time, the Turkish deep state was dreaming of two states in Cyprus. This view was also widespread among some members of the political elite. Dr Fazil Kiouchuk and Rauf Denktash began their political activities with the position that Cyprus is Turkish and with Taksim. However, this position was not dominant among the majority of Turkish Cypriots," Professor Sozen said in response to the specific question of CNA.
Then, Professor Sozen adds the following: "The aim of the TCs was to get rid of the political pressure of the Greek Cypriot elites, he says. To achieve this goal, many positions were put on the table. In this context, formulas such as federation, a return to the 1960s democracy by agreement or annexation to Turkey were put on the table. On the other hand, before 1974, the dream of creating a separate administration had begun to materialise in practice as early as 1963. In 1974, this position was further strengthened by geographical partition. Today, despite the search for a federation which had started three years after 1974, the idea of a separate state has gained ground in practice."
Returning to today and answering the question "to what extent has the concept of a 'separate administration' become entrenched in the Turkish Cypriot community?", Mr. Sozen reminds us that the majority of society was born after 1974 and states the following: "People were born in the midst of de facto partition. Therefore, regardless of what they like or dislike, the idea of a separate administration is much more developed than it was in the 1970s. As an expert in international relations, I would like to stress that the concept of 'territorial integrity' is a very important and almost sacred concept in international relations and international law. In the case of Cyprus, the 1960 agreements and guarantee agreements prohibit the violation of this principle. This is also reflected in all the United Nations resolutions on Cyprus. The violation of the territorial integrity of the Republic of Cyprus has been condemned. Therefore, I do not consider the partition of Cyprus to be realistic. Maybe some may wish it, but it is impossible to happen in reality."
T/C-Turkish relations as problematic as ever
In response to a question from CNA on the evolution of the T/C community's relations with Turkey since 1974 until today, the T/C internationalist shares his pessimism about the course of developments in this field and stresses that "Relations depend on developments in Turkey. Ankara suggests the following: 'You don't need to produce anything. You are a small community, we will feed you.' It also enlists wrong approaches such as 'Turkish Cypriots are not Turkish or Muslim enough'. Because of these policies, problems in relations are created."
Mr. Sozen goes on to point out the following: "My view is that today we are experiencing one of the most problematic periods. Because Turkey is increasingly imposing its policies on the TCs and this inevitably provokes the reactions of the majority of Turkish Cypriots. Even those who do not react are (silently) concerned. In reality, Turkish Cypriots have no problem with Turkey and the Turkish people. On the contrary, there has always been a bond of love and closeness. I studied in Turkey, I lived the best years of my life in Turkey. But despite all that (I acknowledge that), there are serious problems in the relations between Turkey and the Turkish Cypriot community because of the assimilation policies. For example, President (Recep Tayyip) Erdoğan's interference in the Constitutional Court decisions, the previous characterization of Turkish Cypriots as 'inmates (of Turkey)', statements such as 'I will build you a palace' suggest a manipulative attitude and these approaches are creating a backlash."
The future of Turkish Cypriots and the Cyprus problem
Regarding the future of the Turkish Cypriot community, Professor Sozen focuses on the deadlocks currently facing the TCs and the future of the Cyprus problem. Asked by CNA about the biggest dilemmas of the Turkish Cypriots 48 years after 1974, Professor Sozen answers by underlining that "the biggest problem of the modern Turkish Cypriot community lies in the fact that it has not managed to become one of the protagonists (of the Cyprus problem)."
"This situation has created a feeling of indignation in society. On the one hand, Greek Cypriots do not see Turkish Cypriots as an equal community. In other words, they see them as a minority. On the other hand, the guarantor country, according to some the motherland, approaches them as a big brother who is trying to make them more and more like him", says Mr. Sozen, who adds the following: "Turkish Cypriots are caught between these two sides. They look like melted cheese on toast. At the rallies in the early 2000s, the slogan 'We don't want to be a patchwork of the south and a province of Turkey. We want to be the owners of our own home'. This rhetoric does not mean that I want a separate state. But (it does mean) I want Greek Cypriots and Turkey not to interfere in my affairs. This could be achieved through a two-state solution - which I oppose - or through an honourable federal solution based on real political equality - which I choose."
"But neither seems possible at the moment," continues Mr. Sozen, who adds that "the two-state solution is not possible because of the principle of territorial integrity and the fact that the international community does not favour it and international treaties prohibit it. A bizonal bicommunal federation based on political equality is problematic because of the attitude of the Greek Cypriot side. The Turkish Cypriots today are prisoners of this deadlock."
Why at the present time the Turkish side is emphasizing the two-state solution when it is not acceptable? "This is a very good question. I am not sure about that. Is this political position a radical break with traditional Turkish foreign policy? Or is it a new tactic of imposing a federation based on political equality by foreshadowing the worst case scenario? This is not yet clear", the experienced internationalist answers the specific question of CNA, adding the following: "This issue is largely linked to how Turkey's future relations with its traditional allies, especially with the Western alliance, the United States and the European Union, will be shaped. If there is a regime change in Turkey, if the current government is replaced by a new one, and if relations with the West intensify in the medium term, then the two-state solution may fall off the agenda. In that case, a bizonal, bicommunal federation will return to the table."
Mr. Sozen goes on to say that "we have experienced a similar situation in the past. After the Luxembourg Summit in 1997, there was no discussion of a federation, and then (it) came back on the table" and adds the following: "However, if there is a question of Turkey leaving NATO and looking for different alliances, I think it would not be right to expect flexibility from Turkey. However, I would like to draw attention to another point. The two-state formula is only possible after the solution. (First) You will try the federal solution. Along the way, after the settlement of the property issue and other issues, possibly in the long run, a situation similar to the case of Czechoslovakia could come to the fore. Then you could say 'OK, we cannot cooperate. We have solved the issue of ownership. If the European Union agrees, let's put velvet partition on the agenda'."
Couldn't the supporters of the two-state solution counter the above view by raising the tension that "we tried bicommunal cooperation in practice in 1960"? "It is true that there was a functional federation in 1960. However, I would like to stress one point. I think the 1960 solution was a progressive solution for its time. Similar models were applied in Lebanon, Canada and Belgium. There are countries in which it has been successful. There are also countries where this model has failed. These are Lebanon and Cyprus. However, there is no rule that the new structure created 60 years after the failure of 1960 will necessarily fail (again)," is Mr. Sozen's answer to the specific question of CNA.
Finally, Mr. Sozen adds the following: "Both societies have changed over the last 60 years and have learned lessons from history. The old stories of Taksim and the Union are no longer on the agenda. The issue also has a geographical dimension. In 1960 there was no geographical federation. And today there is the umbrella of the European Union. I describe the creation of a federation in Cyprus as the 'Belgianisation of Cyprus'. To those who oppose this idea, I reply that I have visited Belgium many times, I have witnessed the fact that although the Dutch-speaking Flemish and the French-speaking Walloons do not like each other very much, the federation continues to exist. After recent elections in Belgium, no government was formed for more than 400 days. What happened then in Belgium? Nothing. The Belgians did not destroy the state because of their differences. That is what I wish for Cyprus: A partnership structure based on citizenship (of federation), respect for each other, respect for each other's identity, culture and language."
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source