Disagreements in the Finance Committee on the new proposal for a reduced VAT rate on real estate The European Commission was informed about the revised bill but did not respondDisagreement on the separation between housing and apartments They are looking for a happy medium
Strong disagreements from representatives of stakeholders and MPs, were expressed on Monday in the Parliamentary Finance Committee on the revised bill to impose a reduced VAT rate (5%) for the purchase of first homes in the context of social policy.
Particular disagreements were expressed regarding the discrimination created between buyers of apartments and houses. The revised text provides that the reduced VAT rate of 5% may be applied to houses for the first 170 m2 with a maximum of 220 m2 and a maximum value of EUR 350 000[/B], while as regards apartments for the first 90 m2 for an area of up to 110 m2 and a total value not exceeding 200.000. So far, Symeonidou said, there has been no response.
It is noted that the European Commission launched an infringement procedure against the Republic of Cyprus, as it found that the 5% reduced VAT rate was not imposed in a targeted manner, in the context of social policy, as required by paragraph 10 of Annex III of Directive 2006/112/EC of 28 November 2006 on the common system of value added tax.
The Tax Commissioner Sotiris Makridis, expressed the desire to give through the law the clear will of Parliament as to who the beneficiaries are, so that he is not forced to make interpretations that are against the will of the body or the views of the Auditor General on the matter, but also in line with EU regulations.
On behalf of the KEBE and the OEB, disagreement was expressed on the distinction between dwellings and apartments, and the view was expressed that in the new economic context the maximum value should be raised to EUR 500,000 in both cases.
On behalf of the ETEK it was stated that the minimum square footage threshold for apartments should be increased to include triplexes and not to push families to build outside the city, resulting in anarchic development and traffic congestion. It was also requested that the upper value limit be increased for apartments as well as for houses.
The Pancyprian Association of Land Development Entrepreneurs, called for the principle of proportionality to be applied to avoid distortions, and said that Greece had decided to impose zero VAT on new housing as a measure of social policy and development.[/I]
The Cyprus Property Owners Association said it is arbitrary to separate houses and apartments and called for a smooth transition from the old to the new tax regime so that there is no disruption in the market.
On behalf of the Federation of Cyprus Building Contractors' Associations (O.S.E.O.K.), it was stated that the value cap
should be removed from the bill and that the floor area cap is sufficient to satisfy the legislation.
The Cyprus Association of Real Estate Valuers said that the procedure should be as simple as possible and there should be no discrimination between buyers of houses and flats, and said that if this proposal is implemented there will be an even greater shortage of properties in the market and there will not be the expected growth.
MPs' statements
DISY MP Harris Georgiades,
speaking to the committee, said that Cyprus as a new EU member state that joined the EU in 2004, enjoys a distinction compared to old EU member states such as Greece and cannot impose a zero VAT rate on real estate, nor can it determine VAT issues on real estate at its discretion. He also said that he does not understand the logic behind the distinction between houses and apartments.
Speaking after the end of the Commission, its President, DIKO MP Christiana Erotokritou referred to incomplete and incorrect application of the law on 5% VAT and failure to properly inform the European authorities when data on the application of this measure was requested.
At the same time, he said that DIKO will take the initiative together with all stakeholders, including the European Commission, in order to reach a conclusion on differentiations on the text of the bill, which will allow the continuation of a programme that will indeed have a social character and will end the infringement procedure initiated by the European Commission.
The aim, he said, should be to encourage and support young couples who wish to own their own home, with simple but primarily transparent and fair legislation that is indeed socially sensitive that helps society to develop and not one that helps filthy rich businessmen and "ghost buyers" of luxury properties.
AKEL MP Andreas Kavkalias said that the reason for putting this particular bill under pressure with conditions and facts negative for democracy is the wrong way the government applied the concession of the reduced 5% rate for the purpose of building or buying a house. This particular manner, he said, is a monument to institutional complexity, corruption, conflict of interest, cover-up and convenience for day labourers.
Regarding theamended bill, he said there are significant problems and issues that need to be addressed, such as the maximum floor area and total values and the transition period. He also referred to the need for this legislation to also cover the extension of housing which is included in the draft law submitted by AKEL. He finally noted that any decision cannot ignore the timing of the economic and social pressures the country is going through.
At the same time, he said that they called on the Tax Inspector and the Ministry of Finance to proceed with an investigation/examination so that there would be a procedure for the return of lost state revenues
in cases where "the reduced VAT rate should not have been granted to wealthy investors".
ELAM MP Sotiris Ioannou
said that today the Ministry of Finance "continues to insist on an unacceptable bill", which does not correct any distortion that existed in the past, but succeeds in victimizing and directly attacking Cypriot families and young couples. He added that the RS should move forward with a generous plan for Cypriot families, for young couples, to solve the big demographic problem and not stand against it with these mediocre solutions.
In a statement, EPP President Marinos Sizopoulos, said that the proposed bill will not only not solve any problem but instead will create huge complications. Specifically, he said, it will abolish equality among citizens and those who will be most wronged are young families, large families and residents of rural, semi-mountainous and mountainous areas, through the reduction of the building rate which the selected VAT will impose.
At the same time, he added, it does not take into account the uncontrolled, possibly due to international situations, increases in property prices, resulting in the need for systematic revisions with all that this implies. He also said that the adoption of such a bill would in fact lead to further strengthening of the shadow economy, with what this implies as a loss of revenue to the state, and at the same time to the reduction of social policy, which should be at the heart of our policy.
"On the part of the EPP, we responsibly declare that such a bill will not be passed," he said.
The MP of the Ecologists' Movement - Citizens' Co-operation Stavros Papapdouris said that at the moment there is not any consultation or negotiation with the European Commission, which is purely a matter for the legislative and executive powers to do, with the aim of finding the right formula to have a social policy and avoid future abuses. It seems, he said, that there seems to be a conclusion through the recommendations to a house and apartment height ceiling of close to 500, 000 thousand euros for houses and for apartments and at the same time a maximum floor area between 170-185 sq.m. He added that whatever is decided will go back to the European Commission for evaluation.
He also said that the cost of construction today has risen significantly compared to the 2000-2021 statistics on which the Ministry of Finance was based and an amount that actually covers the amount of the first home must be set in order not to lead, he said, to issues of underground economy by declaring amounts outside the contract. He also expressed the hope that the issue would be moved forward soon so that people would know exactly what the facts are and manage their finances well.
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source