What's new

[Cyprus Times] The 3 main scenarios for the evolution of the war in Ukraine

DonbasGenerals3.jpg

The 3 main scenarios for the evolution of the war in Ukraine Six months after the Russian invasion, there is no clear end in sight

Before the war broke out in Ukraine, many considered it unthinkable that something similar would happen on European soil in the 21st century.

When Russian President Putin finally ordered the invasion on February 24, many analysts also assumed that the war would not last long. Hitherto Western support for Kiev and Ukrainian resistance on the one hand, and the gaps in Moscow's planning to achieve the initial objectives of the invasion on the other, proved them wrong.

Six months later, the nightmare continues on the Ukrainian territories and extends beyond them hybridly and geopolitically, with multiple and most noticeable consequences: energy, socio-economic and food.

Estimates of what is to come remain up in the air. "The fighting is likely to go on for many months yet," the Economist points out."

"Russia's forces have stiffened, even as new weapons delivered to Ukraine by Western allies hit the invader hard. The scenes of destruction in Russian-controlled Crimea - which is usually far from the front line of fighting - show that the invader cannot relax."

But "the war will end only when Vladimir Putin decides that he has inflicted enough pain on his neighbour or if he judges that [RUSSIA] is paying too high a price to achieve it."

"In the short term, Russia has done relatively well - as long as oil and gas exports keep flowing," the paper stresses.



But in the coming days the question of "whether Western sanctions, six months on, have really dealt a blow to Russia's economy" will become increasingly pressing, it adds, as the West, and especially Europe, pays ever more dearly for the "marble" of a lack of strategic planning and, now, the energy crisis.

Over time, it is estimated that the price for Russia will also increase. It remains to be seen, however, who will emerge more "wounded" and destabilized from this parallel war of attrition.

Scenario 1: Deadlock

According to most analysts, this is already visible and the most likely scenario for the evolution of the war in the coming period.

"The failure to restart peace talks, combined with the West's continued military support for Ukraine, has made it impossible to predict how long the conflict could last," Gennady Gatilov, Russia's permanent representative to the UN in Geneva, told the Financial Times. "And so they [KIEV AND ITS WESTERN BACKERS]," he added, "will fight to the last Ukrainian."...

Now both camps have "realized that they have a marathon ahead of them," Bloomberg believes.

"Russia's invasion of Ukraine is at a near operational stalemate, with neither side currently in a position to launch an offensive that would materially affect the course of the conflict."

The same picture is painted by retired US Navy Admiral James Stavridis, former Supreme Commander of NATO Allied Forces in Europe.

It is "obvious" that the war in Ukraine "has stalled on both sides," he recently told Greek-American billionaire John Katsimatidis in a radio interview.

He estimated, however, that the conflict "is heading towards an end like that of the Korean War," i.e., "a ceasefire, a militarized zone between the two sides, continued hostility, a kind of frozen conflict. Expect something like that over a period of 4-6 months," he said. "Neither side can sustain it much beyond that."

But with a "frozen conflict," the US think tank Atlantic Council observed in a recent analysis, the war in Ukraine risks becoming "a multi-year burden for Europe because of the economic difficulties associated with ever-tightening sanctions."

The prospect of a re-intensified or wider European conflict on the continent will "remain," he explains, "while governments grapple with competing domestic pressures over how much to support Ukraine."

Scenario 2: Compromise

Analysts believe that the multi-layered stalemate could pave the way for some kind of negotiated settlement - although this is not currently in sight.

Ukrainian President Zelensky "is getting a lot of advice on how he can end the war in his country, and most of it is pushing in one direction: exchange some sovereignty for peace," writes former US Ambassador to Russia (under President Barack Obama) Michael McFaul in a recent opinion piece in the Washington Post.

"Newspaper pages in Europe and the United States have been flooded with opinion pieces by self-styled strategists suggesting ways for Zelensky to stop the slaughter," he says."

"Ukrainians I know have a very specific personal concern," he adds. "If Putin succeeds in fully occupying Donbass, he can declare an end to his war of occupation for the time being, quickly pushing some Western leaders to urge Zelensky to accept the loss of occupied land as the price for peace."

McFaul himself calls "not only repulsive but also highly unrealistic" similar "recommendations that only suggest Zelensky capitulate".

At the forefront, the Ukrainian president himself has repeatedly rejected any negotiations until Moscow withdraws all its forces from the Ukrainian territory it has occupied.

However, according to CNN, as early as June, US President Biden's advisers "discussed internally whether and how" Zelensky "should change his definition of Ukrainian 'victory', adapting to the possibility that his country has irrevocably shrunk."

In any case, U.S. officials stressed, "this more pessimistic assessment" does not mean pressuring Ukraine for "formal territorial concessions to Russia to end the war."

They also expressed optimism that, thanks in part to new arms deliveries, Ukrainian forces will be able to launch a counteroffensive and retake territory later this year.

Scenario 3: Escalation

"Putin legitimized his presidency by taking back Crimea, but his legitimacy is evaporating with his inability to win Ukraine," writes the award-winning Russian writer Mikhail Sishkin, who lives in Switzerland, in an article in the Guardian.

The decision to increase the size of Russia's armed forces by 137.000 soldiers, bringing the total to 2.04 million as of 1 January - under the latest presidential decree signed by Vladimir Putin - bodes well for the continuation and possibly escalation of the war.

The catalyst to such a development, the BBC stresses, could be an attack in Crimea that "would be considered very serious by Moscow."

There have already been some drone attacks on the Russian Federation-annexed peninsula.

Not coincidentally, Russian former president and current deputy chairman of the National Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev, warned that his country considers the refusal of Ukraine and NATO member states to recognize Moscow's authority in Crimea a "systemic threat."

"For the Kremlin, Crimea has an almost sacred status, as it considers it 'historically' Russian land that Moscow triumphantly 'reclaimed' in 2014," explains BBC Moscow correspondent Will Vernon.

"There are fears that if the Ukrainians start systematically attacking Russian targets inside Crimea, then the Russian response could be very serious indeed," he notes."

"Although Putin is likely to be humiliated by the performance of his army," observes the Atlantic Council, "it is possible that out of desperation or delusion (or both) he could provoke a war with NATO.

"It is possible that he believes he can keep such a conflict limited and restrained in the military sense," it considers, "using it to reinforce power at home and to sustain the propaganda narrative, which now focuses almost exclusively on war against the West."

Source: in.gr


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs to Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top