What's new

[Cyprus Times] Supreme Court on naturalisations: appeal against rejection of request for retention of seized persons "justified"

anwtato-dikasthrio.jpg
[/ATTACH]
Supreme Court finds appeal against rejection of request for further retention of seized documents related to naturalization investigations justified

Justified the Supreme Court has ruled that the Police appeal against a first instance decision that had rejected the Force's request for further retention of seized items from a law firm, in connection with investigations into criminal offences relating to the naturalisation of foreign investors.

In a recent decision, the Supreme Court deemed "justified" the appeal against a first instance decision announced in December 2021 which rejected the request of the Police for further retention of seized items from ANDREAS DIMITRIADIS & Co, holding that it "is erroneous". It also deemed it "right and just that the retention of the seized documents be extended and prolonged until the conclusion of any criminal case that may have been registered in relation to them".

According to the appellate judgment, the Police's request for further retention of the seized items had been rejected because the previous order of retention of documents was for a period of one month, and the Police came back after the month had elapsed without any criminal case having been registered before the Court, as the Police investigations were continuing.

The Application for renewal of the order to withhold evidence was brought before another District Judge, as indicated, who denied most of the Police Application, specifically the portion relating to Exhibits 2-37 and 52-57, because there was no specific reference in the affidavit supporting the application as to which specific items of evidence were "connected" to each issued search warrant. He ordered the return of those documents to the other side's attorneys. He also requested that certain other documents that had been withheld as evidence be produced before him to determine "whether they were covered by the attorney-client privilege."

As stated, the Attorney General "reacted to the above approach" and, after obtaining leave to do so, filed a Petition for Writ of Summons seeking to have the Supreme Court set aside the decision of the lower court ordering the return of documents 2-37 and 52-57. The Supreme Court granted the requested writ of certiorari and annulled the decision of the lower court of the day. 20.1.2022 of the Lower Court for refund of the presumptions.

Further, the Attorney General, in this appeal, has challenged the correctness of the order dated 20.1.2022. 13.12.2021 of the High Court to reject the Police's Application for renewal of the order of detention of the items.

It is stated that the grounds of appeal were that the trial court, "erroneously and in excess of its authority, rejected the request for renewal of Object Retention Order for all the exhibits except Exhibit 1, acting as a Court of Appeal in a peer court decision" and that it "erroneously" denied the request for renewal of preservation of evidence "under an error of law" and that it "erroneously and in excess of its authority, ruled on matters relating to the execution of search warrants". It is also stated that it 'wrongly and in error of law' decided that the Documents should be brought before it to determine whether they were covered by legal professional privilege and that 'the decision of the court of first instance constitutes an irregularity of procedure and is wrong in law'.



The Supreme Court, citing the Criminal Procedure Act and related case law, held that "the Attorney General properly entered a criminal appeal" while finding "no merit" and dismissing the "preliminary issue" raised by the Respondent that this appeal should be dismissed because there is no valid appeal before the Court.

The judgment states that it had already been decided on 2.8.2021 (by another District Judge) that the retention of the seized items was necessary while the trial court in its judgment dated 2.8.2021 (by another District Judge) had ruled that the retention of the seized items was necessary while the trial court in its judgment dated 2.8.2021 (by another District Judge) had ruled that the retention of the seized items was unnecessary. 13.12.2021 dismissed the Application for renewal of retention of documents "invoking powers which it did not have by law". It did not focus on the one and essential, it added, whether on the basis of the matters before it further retention of the presumptions was justified. "While he rightly noted in his decision that not every piece of evidence should be linked 'to every offence it relates to or tends to prove', and that the process of withholding evidence should not turn 'into a super-procedure, possibly prejudging possible future hearings where the relevance of evidence sought to be adduced is decided', at the end of the day, in his decision, that is what happened," the decision said.

Source: CNA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source
 
Back
Top