The Supreme Court upheld the appeal of the Attorney General of the Republic in an ongoing case of naturalization of foreign investors.It set aside a first instance court decision, rejecting the renewal of an order issued by the police to retain a large number of documents
The Supreme Court issued a decision on Wednesday 26 October 2022 in a criminal appeal that registered by the Attorney General of the Republic against a decision of a first instance court in relation to a pending case concerning serious criminal offences relating to naturalisations of foreign investors, which had rejected an application for the renewal of a previously issued order for the retention of a large number of documents by the police.
In quashing the trial court's decision not to renew the retention of documents, the Supreme Court found that the trial court acted in excess of its powers, adding that it "did not focus on the one and only essential" issue, which was whether further retention of the documents was justified. It further ruled that not every piece of evidence should be linked "to every offence that it relates to or tends to prove" and that the process of withholding evidence should not become "an overtrial, which would likely prejudice possible future hearings where the relevance of evidence sought to be adduced is judged".
It is important to stress that this decision of the Supreme Court makes it clear that, the retention and disposal of property seized during the execution of a search warrant does not concern a civil dispute but a criminal one.
The appeal was found to be justified and the Supreme Court set aside the first instance judgment.
On behalf of the Attorney General of the Republic, the case was handled by Messrs. Polina Efthyvoulou, Senior Advocate of the Republic and Theodora Papakyriakou, Advocate of the Republic.
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source