A day of meetings and answers PEGA contacts on wiretapping and eavesdropping The focus is on Cyprus' possible connection with the wiretapping case in Greece - Cyprus in the spotlight for "export licenses" It is expected that they will also touch on the spy van case, although it is far ahead in time The programme of meetings in Nicosia Next stop for the committee, Athens
In Cyprus since yesterday, the delegation of the European Parliament's committee of inquiry investigating the use of the Pegasus software and corresponding spy surveillance software (PEGA), as part of a joint fact-finding visit to Cyprus and Athens.
The visit concerns the investigation of allegations of the use of Predator software against journalists and political figures in Greece, as well as possible links between the case and Cyprus due to the activity of companies in the country allegedly linked to persons and companies involved in the case in Greece. In addition, practices regarding the possible export of surveillance technologies from Cyprus. The seriousness with which the Committee takes this link is demonstrated by the fact that immediately after Nicosia, the members of the Committee travel to Athens.
For "export licenses" Cyprus in focus
The difference between Cyprus and Greece is that in the case of Greece there are media reports "about the use of spy software against journalists and politicians", while in Cyprus the issue is more about the issuing of "export licenses" and how the process works.
Speaking to the Cyprus News Agency yesterday, MEP Jeroen Lennaers, chairman of the European Parliament's committee of inquiry into the use of Pegasus and related surveillance software, said that during its visit to Cyprus the PEGA delegation will focus particularly on the legal framework for the export of spyware and related technologies and software and will seek clarification on whether NSO Group has exported products from the country.
Focus on export licenses and links with Greece and Israel
Asked about the agenda of the delegation's meetings in Cyprus, Mr. Lenaers noted that the visit combines contacts in Greece and Cyprus and lasts longer than usual after approval by the European Parliament. He noted that the investigation is set in a different context in each country, as in Greece there are media reports "about the use of spy software against journalists and politicians", while in Cyprus the issue is more about the issuing of "export licenses" and how the process works.
"There are some companies whose names have come up in the investigation that have links to Cyprus," he added, referring to the NSO Group and the question of whether export licenses were issued.
In this context, he said. Lenaers, the MEPs will meet on Wednesday with Trade Minister Natasha Pilidou and Deputy Minister of Digital Policy Kyriakos Kokkinos, as they are "responsible for parts of this legislation", adding that he believes this will be the "most important, most effective part of the visit".
Asked to comment on conflicting reports from NSO Group and the Cypriot government on the issue of export licenses, the head of the delegation said that during PEGA's visit to Israel, MEPs asked the company to comment on what it said about exports from Cyprus and Bulgaria. Their response, he continued, was that "Pegasus is not the only product they sell" and that "they have a range of products". As he understood the answer, he added, the company "may be limited to the Israeli export licensing system, but for other products that are not Pegasus they may have used Bulgaria or Cyprus."
"If the Cyprus Government says that no export license was granted for any NSO Group product, then I think there is an inconsistency between what the NSO Group says and what the Cyprus Government says."
"If the Cyprus Government says that no export license was granted for any NSO Group product, then I think there is an inconsistency between what the NSO Group says and what the Cyprus Government says. If they say that there was never an export licence for something like Pegasus, then that could be consistent with what the NSO Group is telling us," he added.
Explanations about the van?
Members of the European Parliament's PEGA committee, as part of their investigation into surveillance software, may well raise the case of the spy van.
Asked about this, Jeroen Lennaers said that the spy van case is not directly related to the PEGA investigation, as it precedes the Pegasus allegations, but that he expects MEPs to raise questions about the way surveillance issues are handled in Cyprus.
Information suggests that these will mainly concern how the case was handled and the reasons why the case was initially brought before a court and subsequently the prosecution of Tal Dillian and his associates was suspended. Details will also be sought of the findings of the investigation, which came to virtually nothing as the company was only forced to pay a fine and penalty.
"As Cyprus we fully respect and are guaranteed by our Constitution in the strongest way the protection of private communication, there are very strict rules under which any surveillance can legally take place. These will be explained to the committee," Attorney General George Savvidis, who will meet with the committee in the morning, said speaking yesterday. The Assistant Attorney General will be absent from the meeting.
George Savvidis expressed confidence that Cyprus is one of the countries that fully respects private communication.
Asked whether the conclusion delivered by the investigating officer Mr Stefanou in relation to the interceptions will be handed over at the meeting, the Attorney General questioned why there is so much talk about a particular document. "Here this committee is doing an investigation according to some terms of reference which it has received and within these terms of reference they asked me for a meeting, which I accepted immediately," he said, adding that they will discuss all the issues they want to raise and he will also refer to all the issues concerning the Republic of Cyprus' respect for private communication through the laws and procedures it follows.
Meeting schedule
As it is known, the MEPs arrived in Nicosia late yesterday afternoon, and had a meeting with lawyer Ilias Stefanou. This was followed by a separate meeting with journalists Fanis Makridis and Makarios Droussiotis.
Today, in the morning, the delegation will have a joint meeting with the Minister of Energy, Trade and Industry, Natasha Pelidi and the Deputy Minister of Research, Innovation and Digital Policy Kyriakos Kokkinos, which will take place at the Ministry of Energy. Then they will have a meeting with the Attorney General George Savvidis at the Legal Service.
At noon they will have a meeting with delegations of the Parliamentary Committee on Institutions, chaired by MP Dimitris Demetriou and the Parliamentary Committee on Legal Affairs, chaired by MP Nikos Tornaritis, at the building of the House of Representatives.
The PEGA delegation will then depart for Athens where it will arrive in the late afternoon.
The delegation includes PEGA President Jörun Lennaers (European People's Party, Netherlands), the rapporteur of the report, Sophia ind'Veld (Liberals, Netherlands) and MEPs Sylvie Guillaume (Social Democrats, France), Juan Ignacio Zoido Alvarez (EPP, Spain), Elisabeth Wozemberg Byonidi (EPP, Greece), Tisza Reutten (Social Democrats, Netherlands), Rosa Tun ud Hohenstein (Liberals, Poland), Saskia Brickmont (Greens, Belgium), Stelios Kouloglou (Left, Greece), Laura Ferrara (Non-registered, Italy) and Lydia Pereira (EPP, Portugal).
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source