Revelations, answers and clarifications to the Legal Affairs Committee on the issue of surveillance Chief denies buying services from Avni and Dilian
Revelations, answers and clarifications were given today at the meeting of the Parliament's Legal Affairs Committee during the discussion of the case of wiretapping and Cyprus' involvement in the production and distribution of software that may have been used for illegal wiretapping.
Introducing the issue for discussion, AKEL MP and rapporteur Aristos Damianou said that on the issue of wiretapping and eavesdropping, those in power are under scrutiny, as they are in relation to the activities of companies producing and exporting malicious software.
Damianou set the framework of his statement in three pillars and posed a series of questions. The first pillar, he said, concerns the events surrounding the spy van and referred to parts of the police statement before the Court on December 20, 2019. He noted that the unprecedented case was brought before Court and the accused company WS WISPEAR SYSTEMS LTD was sentenced last April to a fine of 76.000 euros, while the prosecution against the owner of the company was suspended.
- AKEL-DIKO v. Averoff over surveillance. How DISY responds[/URL]
- "Time bomb" with Cyprus as the recipient of the PEGA draft on surveillance. Kouloglou at CT
The second pillar, Damianou said, concerns the production of dual-use software in Cyprus, adding that the government's official version that no malicious software is produced and exported is a "lie and misleading". He said the Governors are aware that Tal Jonathan Dilian director of WS WISPEAR SYSTEMS LTD is related to NSO which produces Pegasus for illegal surveillance and eavesdropping and to Intellexa which produces Predator. Also, he added, there are serious police findings regarding Avraham Shahak Avni.
Damianou then said that since there was previously business activity of a close relative of Assistant Attorney General Savvas Angelides with subsequent persons and companies investigated in the case that the law firm whose Mr. Angelides was a founding partner, the Assistant AG should recuse himself from the criminal investigation.
The third pillar of Mr Damianou's positioning of the issue concerned political interlocking, with the MP stating that relentless questions arise for the Council of Ministers, the ruling party, and DISY President Averof Neophytou.
Mr Damianou's positioning of the issue concerned political interlocking, with the MP stating that relentless questions arise for the Council of Ministers, the ruling party, and DISY President Averof Neophytou.
Mr Damianou's positioning of the issue concerned political interlocking, with the MP stating that relentless questions arise for the Council of Ministers, the ruling party, and DISY President Averof Neophytou. Damianou asked, among other things, why NSO or subsidiaries were given licenses to export malicious software at a time when they knew about the construction and use of Pegasus, why it was demonstrated regarding the construction, use and export of Predator software, why the Cabinet gave Shahak Avni a license to carry weapons, why the Police and other government agencies purchased services and products from the specific companies of Shahak Avni and Jonathan Dilian, why the Office of the President of DISY acted towards the Ministry of Energy at the request of Mr. Jonathan Dilian to mediate a bid in the Netherlands and who mediated the expansion of Dilian's activities in Greece.
Savvas Angelides in his initial statement, and in response to questions, cited the Legal Service's announcement dated August 10, 2022 which answered many questions regarding the "black van".
Savvas Angelides in his initial statement, and in response to questions, cited the Legal Service's announcement dated August 10, 2022 which answered many questions regarding the "black van". He said the investigation of the "black van" case began on November 15, 2019, noting that the investigative work that the investigative team was asked to complete was extensive, complex and time-consuming precisely because of the number, type and nature of the items seized.
As he noted, all the evidence received by the Police was subjected to specialised forensic examination, both by Police experts and by a private expert specialising in telecommunications systems/networks and related security issues, while the electronic data extracted from the seized equipment was sent to a specialised section of Europol for further investigation and analysis.
Mr. Angelides stressed that from the scientific investigations that took place in Cyprus and abroad, no data tending to show that the equipment was used or operated in practice for monitoring or interception of any form of communication (verbal or written) between users or interception of electronic files from devices and according to the findings of the examinations, the operation of the systems was limited to the automated scanning, random (non-targeted) recording and storage of the International Mobile Subscriber Number (IMSI) of SIM cards and the MAC address number of electronic devices entering within the range of the system.
The Assistant Attorney General explained that, assessing the uncertainty of the outcome of a hearing, particularly when complex legal, but especially technical issues are raised, and taking into account the assumption of full responsibility by "Ws Wispear Systems Ltd.", the amount of the administrative fine which was of a punitive nature, the immediate payment of the fine by the company, the fact that the electronic systems held by the company were not used for interception or interception of electronic communications and the fact that the systems were operated in the context of trials without targeting specific persons/users, decided to discontinue the criminal proceedings against the three natural persons prosecuted, on the understanding that the accused company "Ws Wispear Systems Ltd." would admit the charges corresponding to the testimony.
As Mr. Angelides said, the accused company was fined €76,000 and, in fact, punished, in relation to its illegal conduct, with the total fine of €1,000,000. He made it clear that if there was even a shred of evidence relating to interception or interception of any form of communication content, oral or written, then the criteria for the course of the case would have been completely different.
Responding to Mr. Damianos that he should have withdrawn himself from the prosecution as there are circumstances of lack of objective impartiality, Savvas Angelides said in a strong tone that he is not corrupt. He said that he took the decision to withdraw the case on the basis of the mechanism by which the Legal Service operates and did not, he stressed, change anyone's note. Addressing the AKEL MP, he said that if they want to create such obstacles to the work of officials then no one will work.
Minister of Justice Stefi Drakou
, speaking before the Committee, stressed in relation to the PEGA Committee's visit to Cyprus that she never received a request from the Committee for a meeting and never refused to cooperate with them, noting that respect for the institutions of the Republic and the European institutions is a given.
The Chief of Police Stelios Papatheodorou said that the Police does not have a list of companies that manufacture surveillance equipment or produce dual-use software, noting that the job of the Police is when it is reported that a company is engaged in any illegal act to proceed with a criminal investigation.
Asked by Mr Damianos if the Police had purchased any products or services from the said companies of Avni and Dilian, he replied that it has not been established that the Police have purchased anything from the companies of the two. We, he said, have not found that we have purchased services or products from those persons.
In relation to Mr Avni's firearms licence, Papatheodorou said he was indeed granted a licence in 2016, which he retained until the case came up in 2020. He explained that the initial recommendation of the Police, was that he did not need to be granted a licence to carry weapons but after the submission of additional information provided to the Ministry by him, he was granted this licence.
Deputy Minister of Innovation and Research Kyriakos Kokkinos speaking after the meeting said that they are working on strengthening the legal and supervisory framework, which will be submitted to Parliament around the end of December. He said that there are companies in Cyprus dealing with these technologies, and noted that although there are around 30 registered companies, those that are active are nine. With these, he said, the Ministry of State is in constant contact and supervises them within a framework that needs to be strengthened.
He clarified that those dealing with dual-use software are four and it does not mean that all of them are involved in sales but they may be involved in a part of the development of these technologies. He noted that the structure of the companies involved in this sector is complex and that is why it is difficult to supervise them, adding that this is why the legal framework needs to be strengthened.
He explained that Cyprus, like all countries, is hospitable to high-tech companies, as long as these companies operate within the framework of national and European regulations and laws.
Commission President Nikos Tornaritis in his statements after the meeting, said that no one should sacrifice the Commission's mission to electoral expediency and that no one should involve our country in a witch hunt.
He said that first of all we have a strong legal framework for the establishment and operation of these companies and added that this framework needs strengthening as technology is evolving and for this reason the Deputy Minister of Innovation said that he will submit a specific legislative framework.
Tornaritis said that the companies operating in Cyprus are legal and noted that those who break the law should be brought to justice. He then questioned whether it is within the competence of the Parliament to ask for the findings of criminal investigations to be made public, answering at the same time that this is not within its competence. However, he noted that DISY's request is to seek an opinion from the Speaker of the Parliament on the matter, and clarified that the conclusion of a criminal investigation is one thing and the conclusion of an investigative committee is another.
He stressed that the wiretapping case had and has nothing to do with DISY, adding that his party since 1976 has fought for the protection of human rights in the country and paved the way for democracy and freedom, and "this is exactly how we will continue to operate in the future."
He said that as Chairman of the Committee, he gave a one-week deadline to provide all the answers requested by the MPs today because this case should be cleared.
The rapporteur on the issue Aristos Damianou in his own statements said that today's session on the activity of dual-use software companies as well as malicious spyware in the Republic of Cyprus was particularly revealing and confirming the allegations and concerns.
Specifically, he said, it has been confirmed that malware companies are active in Cyprus, that there has been licensing and export of such products from the Republic of Cyprus. It has been confirmed, he continued, that Departments and Services at the request of the President of DISY, in a process on behalf of Mr. Dilian's company to the Netherlands in order to clarify issues on a tender that had been awarded to it in the Netherlands, but it has mainly been confirmed that a hotbed of malware production companies is active in Cyprus, which is the result of a harbouring by the political backs of the ruling party and DISY, he said.
Alexandra Attalidou[/B] of the Ecologists in her own statements said that from the answers given today by the guests there is the impression that there was nothing illegal in the case and underlined that one of the people involved, Mr. Dilian, has around 70 companies, behind which all the activities are hidden. That is why it is difficult for people who do not have the expertise to get to where they need to be in investigations, he said. He added that if the Police and the Attorney General's Office feel that they cannot bring such cases to justice, they should ask Parliament to provide them with those tools so that they can go ahead with these investigations.
Attalidou said that this kind of action in a European state undermines democracy because, she noted, if citizens are being followed by others, this undermines democracy and "we expect that at the end of the government some people will rise to the occasion". He added that some should resign, like the Commissioner of Police as the force did not investigate properly. Also, he continued, all the officials involved in the investigation should either disclose what happened or they should resign.
He said the Commerce Minister also has a huge responsibility because she is the ministry that is mandated to give licenses, while the Ministry of Foreign Affairs should also give its own position and action. "There are certain officials of this state who have once again left Cyprus exposed and they must give answers," he concluded.
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source