Putin is safe for now, but the risks are ahead The Russian President is holding out, but for how long?
Vladimir Putin's power in Russia remains stable despite military failures in Ukraine, a failed draft and political infighting, eight well-informed Western sources said, but some said that could change quickly if total defeat occurs.
Most of them, Reuters noted, said the Russian president is in one of the most difficult periods of his 20-plus years in power as far as Ukraine is concerned, where his own invading forces have been pushed back in places by a Western-armed Kiev.
But the same sources, which include current and former Western diplomats and government officials, say there appears to be no immediate threat from his entourage, the military or intelligence agencies.
Putin is holding out, but for how long?
"For now, Putin is holding out," said Anthony Brenton, Britain's former ambassador to Russia.
He said he believes the Russian leader hopes to negotiate on Ukraine, possibly with the Americans, and hopes Moscow, after losses on the battlefield, will recover despite what the West says is a shortage of manpower, materiel and even missiles.
Some of his allies, from "Putin's soldier", as the Kremlin-backed Chechen leader calls himself, to "Putin's chef", the nickname for the head of a once shadowy mercenary group, have accused the military leadership of mishandling the war.
Brenton, who had contacts with Putin during his second term, said there was no public criticism of him from the political or business elite or any sign of a move against him, but that may not last.
"If they continue to retreat in the spring, in March/April next year, then my instinct is that at that point things will get really problematic for Putin - not at the popular level, but at the elite level."
"There is a group of people there who are fundamentally self-interested and who do not want to be part of a potential debacle."
A senior Western official who is closely monitoring the situation and who did not want to be named because of the sensitivity of the issue said that so far there have been no significant defections.
There were signs of internal strife, discontent and slow decision-making, the official said. "But there are no signs that he has lost control."
A U.S. official, who declined to be named for the same reason, said Washington and its allies assumed Putin's position was secure. "That said, many of his recent actions - including the draft - clearly indicate that Putin is retreating."
With powerful intelligence agencies supporting a political system staffed by closely watched regime loyalists, it would be difficult and dangerous for anyone to move against Putin.
Andrew Weiss, a Putin expert at the Carnegie Endowment, said that while "anything is possible" in Russia, public opinion is less important there than in the West, while real opponents have fled or been jailed and Putin is surrounded by loyalists to his regime.
"Show me the man who will talk to Putin's office and say you're done. Who would have the audacity to do that?" said Weiss, who has held various strategic roles on the U.S. National Security Council and has written a book about Putin.
The Russian leader could be overthrown through a coup in the Kremlin, an elite uprising or a popular "assault on the Bastille," he said, noting that the Iraqi leader, Saddam Hussein, ruled for more than a decade after his invasion of Kuwait was thwarted in 1990.
"Fear rules in Russia"
Tatiana Stanovaya, founder of the analytics firm R. Politik, said Vladimir Putin would be in trouble if he ran out of options for escalating the conflict.
In that case, the elite would try to persuade Putin to resign, she predicted, adding that there is still no evidence of the kind of coups that overthrew Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev in 1964 or targeted Mikhail Gorbachev in August 1991.
"If he is able to fulfill his promises before the elite and the people - stability, peace, pensions and salaries - then nothing will threaten him," Stanovaya said."
She added: "But if the Russian army is pushed back to the old borders of Russia before the annexation, if the Ukrainian army goes further on the offensive, and if the budget cannot cope and there are delays in pensions, then the elite will gradually mobilise."
Although polls in Russia show growing public concern, a French diplomatic source said Putin, who dominates influential state media, could maintain his control.
"Let's not forget that fear prevails," the source said. "I still believe that the majority of Russians will support Putin whatever he decides."
A senior European official, for his part, said Putin would have to ostentatiously lose the war to be overturned.
If and when that time comes, noted former British Ambassador Brendon, his successor is unlikely to be a friend of the West.
"The people who will make the decisions are hard safe keepers. We are not going to get a... sweet liberal!"
Source: in.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs to Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source