Recommendations on PIC and corruption prosecutions in the Commission's Rule of Law Report What it says in the third annual Rule of Law Report
The modernisation of the legislation on the governance of the Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation, especially as regards the procedures for the appointment and removal of the members of the Board of Directors, is among the recommendations made by the Commission in the chapter on Cyprus in its third annual Rule of Law Report published on Wednesday.
Also, the Commission calls for ensuring that the appointment of judges and the composition of the Supreme Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court are in line with the Venice Commission's standards.
In addition, improvements are called for in the investigation and adjudication of high-level corruption cases, including through the strengthening of the institution of the Attorney General and the independence of the budget of the Legal Service.
The report, as every year, focuses on four aspects of the rule of law in all EU Member States: judicial reform, the anti-corruption framework, media freedom and pluralism, and institutional checks and balances.
In statements at the presentation of the report's findings, Values and Transparency Commissioner Vera Yurova said that this year's report focuses in particular on the protection of public service broadcast media, while Justice Commissioner Didier Raiders recalled that corruption cases must be effectively and fully investigated and prosecuted.
The recommendations, as recorded in the chapter on Cyprus, in addition to the commitments already made by the country under the National Recovery and Resilience Plan in relation to specific parameters of the judicial system and the anti-corruption framework, are as follows:
Ensure that the reform regarding the appointment of judges of the Supreme Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court takes into account European standards for the appointment of judges and the opinion of the Venice Commission.
Ensure that the reform of the composition of the Supreme Judicial Council takes into account European standards for judicial councils and the opinion of the Venice Commission.
Continue to improve the effective investigation and prosecution of high-level corruption cases, including by strengthening the Office of the Prosecutor General and its financial independence.
Introduce rules for the disclosure of assets of elected officials to establish regular and comprehensive reporting, together with effective, regular and comprehensive verification procedures.
Strengthen rules and mechanisms to strengthen the independent governance of public SMEs, taking into account European standards relating to public SMEs.
Establish a framework for effective and timely consultation of stakeholders in the legislative process.
In particular, the summary analysis with regard to the four pillars of the rule of law in the chapter on Cyprus are as follows:
Reform of the judiciary
The report notes that "the structural reforms of the Cypriot justice system that the government is working on are progressing, albeit with delays".
The bill splitting the current Supreme Court in two, which was reportedly passed into law on 7 July 2022, "raises some concerns about the process of appointing judges to the future Supreme Constitutional Court and Supreme Court and the composition of the Supreme Judicial Council", issues on which the Venice Commission has issued recommendations.
It is also noted that there is a delay in the planned strengthening of the financial independence of the Legal Service, and that the judicial system still faces serious challenges in terms of efficiency, although digital solutions have started to be implemented and are planned.
The new rules of civil procedure are being implemented and are expected to have a positive impact on the overall efficiency of the justice system, it is added. Still, further reforms are aimed at addressing challenges to the efficiency and quality of the justice system, particularly through digitisation, it said.
Finally, it is reported, the bill establishing the Commercial and Maritime Court was approved by the House of Representatives on 12 May 2022.
Anti-corruption framework
Cyprus has enacted into law the protection of whistleblowers and transparency in the lobbying sector, it is reported.
At the same time, "legislation on the disclosure of assets of elected officials continues to be pending before Parliament."
It is further noted that progress has been made in terms of the institutional framework with the establishment by law of the National Authority for the Fight against Corruption, while the implementation of anti-corruption plans continues.
However, it noted, "despite the increased resources allocated to the Office of the Attorney General, there are no results in terms of investigating and prosecuting high-level corruption cases".
Results are also recorded regarding the implementation of integrity standards for specific areas of the public administration, although no progress is reported for the general public administration.
Finally, it is reported that the plan to grant citizenship to investors has been phased out on the basis of the recommendations of the Commission of Inquiry.
Media freedom and pluralism
As acknowledged in the report, freedom of expression and the right of access to information enjoy legal and formal protection under the Constitution, while secondary legislation explicitly ensures the protection of journalists' sources, promotes media pluralism in the radio and television sector and establishes the framework and conditions for public access to information. Also, it adds, the legislation adopted in 2021 explicitly enshrines the independence of the Broadcasting Authority and transparency in media ownership.
Specific to the Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation, the report says that although the relevant legislation establishes rules for the governance and financing of public media, "certain weaknesses have been identified regarding the appointment and dismissal of the members of the board of directors" of RBC.
The authorities, it added, "are considering the possibility of modernising the legislation on the Cyprus Broadcasting Corporation as well as the rules regulating the conditions of employment of the organisation".
Institutional checks and balances
According to the report, consultation procedures on legislative proposals remain limited, with the Commission citing concerns about public access to draft legislation and in relation to civil society participation in the early stages of the process.
In September 2021, the government adopted an action plan to simplify legislation in general and reduce bureaucracy.
The government "has also taken steps to better support civil society and improve communication with public authorities by creating a dedicated online platform", it added. At the same time, judicial proceedings are ongoing regarding the registration and operation of civil society organisations.
The strengthening of staff in the Office of the Commissioner for Administration is also noted, as well as concerns regarding selection and appointment procedures and pluralism in the composition of the Commissioner's office.
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source