Military experts explain to Focus, Bild and CNN why partial conscription will fail
The partial conscription declared yesterday by Russian President Vladimir Putin will not help him win in Ukraine, explains Mick Ryan , an Australian military expert, in an interview with German media.
"Putin's mobilization is not aimed at winning the war. Is his decision turning the war in favour of the Russians? No, says the Australian military expert as reported by the German magazine Focus. The former general is confident that he will only succeed in strengthening the troops already fighting in Ukraine and conquering more Ukrainian territory.
[BR]
"Russia is sending 300,000 reservists to war in Ukraine. The huge number has many people trembling that Putin's army is finally winning the battle against the Ukrainians. But experts agree: Russia will not win on the war front.That's because, "The Russians must above all replace their troops fighting on the front," writes Mick Ryan on Twitter, explaining his reasoning. In addition, many soldiers have been fighting for eight months. Normally, a soldier's strength weakens after three to four months. Therefore, the Russians must first replace the soldiers fighting on Ukrainian soil and then send reinforcements."
"By recruiting young and old men from the streets to fight on the Ukrainian front, Putin is reminiscent of Hitler," comments former US general Ben Hodges.
"Russia's partial mobilization is reminiscent of Adolf Hitler's last move in World War II," Hodges tells the German ZDF network."
A few hours earlier he had warned Moscow of retaliation: "We will destroy the military bases in Crimea if Russia uses nuclear weapons as part of the war. Provided that the Russian navy's Black Sea fleet is also attacked."
"Although he believes that the probability of a nuclear attack is extremely low, the US is ready for such actions. If they end up facing Ukrainian weapons on the front lines, they are likely to become the latest victims in Putin's invasion that began on February 24," CNN reports."
According to military experts quoted by German media, "Putin is humiliating himself with 'fake' referendums in eastern Ukraine.
"Putin could wage a real war of self-defense," says Russian policy expert Ian Garner via Twitter, noting that the referendums would put Putin on the defensive.
"Because it is expected that Ukraine will attack Luhansk and Donetsk after the fake referendums."
"Because it is expected that Ukraine will attack Luhansk and Donetsk after the fake referendums. Then Russia would try to block the attacks and the Russian military leadership could publicly claim you see, we said it was a war of self-defense," he continued.
However, given the strength and progress of the Ukrainian army in the southeast of the country , as well as the declining combat capability and falling morale of the Russians, this statement by Putin will not lead to a Ukrainian withdrawal.
"Putin and the Russian military leadership will then have to explain why the regions are now part of Russia but Ukrainian troops have the upper hand in individual areas. Moreover, Putin would then admit that he has annexed Luhansk and Donetsk, but left other occupied territories in Ukraine. This would amount to an admission that Russia has failed to occupy all of Ukraine," experts say."
"The Russian military is not currently equipped to quickly and effectively deploy 300.000 reservists," argues Alex Lord, a Europe and Eurasia specialist at the London-based strategic analysis firm Sibylline.
"Russia is already struggling to effectively equip its professional armed forces in Ukraine, following significant equipment losses during the war. The recent Ukrainian offensive, in which Kiev recaptured thousands of square metres of territory, has had a significant impact," it adds.
Earlier this week, the U.S. Institute for the Study of War reported that analysis by Western experts and Ukrainian intelligence showed that Russia has lost 50 percent to 90 percent of its strength in some units.
For the German newspaper Bild, Western countries, including Germany, oppose Putin. "Some are helping Ukraine more, others less. But all are categorically against him. This unity is our strength. And Putin wants to destroy this strength by spreading fear. We must not succumb to his threats."
Source: Proto Thema
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source