What's new

[Cyprus Times] Politico: Why Germany will not react if China invades Taiwan

2022-08-11T041738Z_1276106340_RC21UV97VZ2Y_RTRMADP_5_TAIWAN-DEFENCE-DRILLS.jpg

As Politico points out in its analysis, such a stance would severely damage the credibility of Germany itself and the entire EU

For months now, Berlin has irritated - if not angered - many of its allies with its approach towards Russia on the Ukraine issue. As Politico points out, however, this situation is but a prologue to simmering developments in Asia, as tensions over Taiwan force Berlin to work out its strategy should Beijing attempt to annex the island nation, which it considers a breakaway part of China.

If that happens, the U.S. and other Western allies could push for tough sanctions against China. Germany, Politico notes, is unlikely to agree to such a move in order to protect its export-based economy. But doing so would damage both its own and Europe's international credibility.

Schultz's evasiveness

When asked on Thursday whether Germany would be able to support sanctions in the event of a Chinese invasion, Chancellor Olaf Schultz avoided answering, while criticizing German industry for "putting all its eggs in one basket."

"The question is whether our country's dependence in critical areas, involving supply chains, raw materials and other issues, is a necessary element of our national security strategy, which we are currently working on," he added, without referring directly to China.

Others have been clearer.

Others have been clearer. The fact that German industry relies on exports "has created a dependency that makes us helpless," argued the centre-right German MP Norbert Retgen, speaking on television recently.

Could Germany support sanctions against China?



"At the moment, actually no," warned Röttgen, a former minister and experienced member of Germany's parliamentary foreign policy committee.

Although similar problems arose in relation to Germany's attitude towards Russia, this time there was more at stake.

Germany's big concern with Moscow was that it would lose access to cheap energy. With Beijing, the fears are about the loss of its own economic prosperity. In recent years, China has replaced the US as Germany's largest trading partner, accounting for 10% of the country's foreign trade that reached €2.6 trillion last year. Moreover, China, which has boosted the German economy for decades, remains a key driver of the country's growth.

This is why it is not easy to reduce German industry's dependence on it.

"The extent to which our prosperity relies on China is underestimated to an extreme degree at home," Volkswagen chief Herbert Diss said in a recent interview. "Germany would change a lot if we disconnected."

Cars and jobs

Indeed, no German industry is as dependent on China as the one to which Diss belongs. One in three cars produced by the German car industry is sold in China. German automakers also have an extensive network of factories in mainland China, which produced 4.3 million cars during 2021.

"The German automotive industry, like the rest of the world, is anxiously watching the tensions between China and Taiwan," noted a spokesman for the industry lobby, known as the VDA.

Politico argues that "panic" would be a more accurate word to describe the situation.

Diss called China "irreplaceable" for the future of his company, from which he is expected to withdraw within the month.

A similar picture holds for other critical export sectors in Germany, from chemicals to machinery. Some 1.1 million jobs in the country - or alternatively 2.4% of the total - are directly dependent on Chinese consumption, according to a June survey by the German Economic Institute in Cologne.

Although Germany, like the rest of the EU, is also important markets for China itself, the study notes that the Chinese are reducing their dependence on the region, while Europeans are following the opposite path.

Urgent call to reduce dependence

Making an urgent appeal, the study's author, Jurgen Mattes, said it is "imperative" that Europe and Germany change course and reduce their economic dependence on China.

"It is not a question of disconnecting markets, but of reducing dependencies, especially through diversification," he writes."

But just as it took decades for German industry to establish itself in China, withdrawal cannot happen overnight - especially at a time when few regions on the planet promise as much reliable growth as China's.

"In the event of a Chinese invasion of Taiwan followed by extensive Western sanctions, export and revenue reductions, as well as the suspension of deliveries from China, the EU would suffer significant economic losses and Germany even more," Mattes concluded.

Lessons from Ukraine

Given these facts, it is doubtful that Germany would support meaningful Western sanctions on China. Berlin may have participated in the harsh measures against Moscow after the invasion of Ukraine, but the potential economic impact on Germany was limited.

Even the suspension of the controversial Nord Stream 2 pipeline, for example, was accompanied by attempts by Scholz to protect Germany's most critical energy interests by rejecting a full gas embargo.

The strategy did not work to the extent he had hoped, but that was because the Russians themselves reduced the flow of gas to Europe. The ongoing gas shortages in Germany, which threaten to create huge problems in critical industrial sectors, will inevitably affect the German government's response to a possible Chinese invasion of Taiwan. With inflation remaining high and energy prices giving no downward signs, Germany cannot afford another blow to its economy.

Berlin officials, according to Politico, admit in private conversations that they may prove unable to support anything beyond symbolic sanctions against China. That doesn't mean there won't be dramatic disagreements in Berlin over such a moral dilemma. Political talk shows will devote hours upon hours to this question, while newspaper columnists will pour barrels of ink to analyze every aspect of the issue. As for the substance of the issue, however, Politico mockingly notes that the Germans will do what they always do: nothing.

Source: in.gr


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source[/URL]

 
Back
Top