What's new

[Cyprus Times] PEGA recommends in-depth examination of Cyprus for surveillance software

pega-1-1.jpg

We need to look further into the situation in Cyprus, said the rapporteur of the EP report on surveillance What are the two most important issues identified by the PEGA Committee on Cyprus

The European Parliament's Committee of Inquiry into the use of surveillance software (PEGA) needs to delve deeper into the case of Cyprus, said, following the release of its draft, the rapporteur of the committee's report, Dutch Liberal MEP Sophie in Att Veld.

According to In 't Veld, the two issues she considers important in the case of Cyprus are the evidence that the country is an important export hub, and that there have been interceptions of citizens with such software.

"Cyprus, the last country for which we devoted a larger chapter (in the draft), should be examined much more," the MEP said.

"We have indications that spyware was used against citizens. But I think what is more worrying in Cyprus is (that it is) the main hub for spyware exports," she added.

According to In 't Veld, all countries have some role in the activities of spyware companies.

"Cyprus and Bulgaria are export hubs.[/B] Luxembourg is where spyware sellers do their financial activities. Ireland offers attractive tax conditions. Malta, and this is interesting, seems to be a comfortable home for spyware bosses with golden passports and shell companies," she said.

The rapporteur of the report referred to a proposal recorded in the draft for an immediate ban on the sale, acquisition, transfer and use of spyware throughout the EU, which could be lifted on a case-by-case basis per Member State if four conditions are met. These are the full investigation and handling by the competent authorities of all alleged abuses of such software, the proven implementation of a legislative framework in line with international standards, a commitment by Member States to agree to requests by Europol to investigate such cases, and the suspension of all export licences that do not comply with the Dual-use Regulation.



According to the proposal as set out in the draft, the Commission would be responsible for monitoring these conditions.

Among the proposals referred to by Inat Veld is the formulation of a common definition of what constitutes a national security reason, or at least an obligation for Member States to clearly define what they consider to be a national security reason.

Referring to the Member States that PEGA has dealt with so far, Inat Veld noted that in Greece, where she said there are new developments every day, there are no situations like those in Poland and Hungary where there is a targeted authoritarian policy. But she added that there is evidence that surveillance is widely used in the country as a political strategy.

Responding to journalists' questions about the case of Greece and whether the investigations into the new publications would affect PEGA's work, the MEP noted that the committee's mandate expires in March or possibly June and that so far only the evidence is included in the draft, but added that even without the completion of the investigations in Greece, the Prime Minister or the Greek Parliament could release more information to the public.


He also referred to the fact that although there have been investigations into Intellexa's actions, no servers have been seized and no parties involved have been called to give evidence.

In response to a question whether she can say with certainty that the surveillance in Greece was carried out by the government, the rapporteur said that PEGA has no proof, but pointed out that these technologies are usually sold to governments or very wealthy individuals.

With regard to Poland and Hungary, she noted that the use of surveillance software as a central element of a system for controlling citizens is observed, stressing that the Committee has found methodical use of such technologies and that this is not accidental.

With regard to Spain, she admitted that this was a sensitive case because of its political dimension (recalling that the surveillance allegations concern cases of Catalan politicians), but stressed that there were indications that surveillance had also been carried out on individuals who were not a risk to the country's national interests, and called on the authorities of the country to provide evidence so that the Committee could assess the allegations. Democracy in the US is still under pressure, she continued, but the mechanisms are there.

Democracy at EU level has not yet matured, she added, calling for a conference to strengthen the implementation of rules at the pan-European level, even without changing the treaties. She stressed that only the Parliament can pursue this issue, as governments seem to want it not to be investigated.

In response to a question about the Spanish case, the MEP noted that as far as she understands governments should be controlled by citizens, and that if in "exceptional cases" they are given additional powers, these are not a blank cheque and governments should be held accountable.

"It is time for the EU to come of age as a political union," she added, referring to the letter sent by the Council to PEGA in which member states say they believe the issue is not the responsibility of the Parliament. She said that on the one hand the Member States insist that it is a matter of national competence, but on the other hand they discuss the issue among themselves at EU level.

In 't Veld was also asked several times to comment on the fact that many conclusions in the draft are estimates, to which she replied that the estimates are based on a lot of information.

Finally, in response to a question as to why she published the draft before it was discussed in committee, the MEP said that once a draft is sent for translation it is already public and that she thought there would be questions from the press, noting that the draft was sent to MEPs first.

Asked to comment directly on whether she had concerns about political support within PEGA, Inat Veld admitted that "the committee has become politicised" and that "sometimes you feel the presence of national governments in our discussions", but stressed that cooperation among PEGA members exists.


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top