The delegation of the EP's PEGA committee is investigating Cyprus-Israel relations and the possibility of investigating and controlling the Parliament for surveillance
Why Cyprus is an attractive destination for companies selling software and surveillance services from Israel and what the Cypriot Parliament can do to investigate and control these allegations, were some of the questions raised by the delegation of the PEGA Committee of Inquiry of the European Parliament in its meeting with Members of the Parliamentary Committees on Institutions and Legal Affairs. Wider Cyprus-Israel relations were also brought to the fore.
- The spy van and "corrupt Cyprus" sparked the atmosphere in the joint session with PEGA
- "The van affair is over". Savvidis responded to PEGA and clarified
The chairman of the committee of inquiry, Gerun Lennars, said the meeting with the Cypriot MPs was the highlight of their visit to Cyprus and said they had many questions in relation to the spy van. He questioned the ability of the Cypriot parliament to investigate the issue and exercise control.
Sophie in t Veld, in charge of the committee's report, noted that the problem is European and Cyprus has an important role to play in its investigation. The issues, she said, are on the one hand the abuse of surveillance software by European governments against their citizens, but also the issue of the export of this software.
He asked for the documents presented by the MPs to be submitted to the committee immediately, as the first draft of its report is expected to be available next week.
- In parliament, PEGA members. "We got answers" Lennaers' comment after meeting with Savvidis (pics-video)[/B]
- PEGA members meet with Savvidis and go to Parliament (pics)[/URL]
"We were told that you have very strict rules on the use and export of surveillance software. Cyprus is a very attractive destination for "hacking for hire" companies. They come to Cyprus. Six companies in Cyprus were founded by former employees or board members of NSO and are headquartered here. And I ask myself: if you come from Israel, why would you go to Cyprus to have your company's management there? It doesn't make sense," he said.
In addition, he said further clarification is needed regarding the spy van and its equipment and whether it was returned to the owners, as the key is in the details, he said.
He also noted that from what they were told, there was no official surveillance of journalists or civilians. "What if the surveillance was done by a third party, not the government? The software and technology is here, the technology is available," he said."
[/P]- Series of meetings for PEGA, seeks answers on surveillance software[/B]
- New AKEL fire and questions about surveillance and spy van. "At some point they cease to be coincidences"
Finally, with regard to Israel, he noted that when they visited it they saw that they have a very strict permit system, but at the same time the export of permits is a matter of political currency and international relations. "Today we learned that Cyprus is thinking of following Israel's licensing model," he said, advising that this should be avoided.
MEP Thijs Reuten asked MEPs whether they intend to pass a new legal framework and whether in it they are thinking of including parliamentary scrutiny for cases of surveillance by the authorities. Furthermore, he asked whether the attractiveness of Cyprus for spy software companies was due to circumstances or whether the Cypriot government got something in return for facilitating these companies.
Roza Thun Und Hohenstein asked whether there is an institution to which citizens can turn to protect themselves in case they are being monitored. She noted that the legal framework seems very good, but wondered whether it is enforced, as it seems that so far no one has been punished for using these systems.
MEP Jean Bricmont wondered why the charges against Dillian had not been pursued. He said the Attorney General is not aware of any formal complaints and wondered if there would be a parliamentary scrutiny. "Is the majority of parliament willing to find answers and share them with us?" he said. She also noted a gap between the legal framework and its implementation and that Cyprus is an attractive destination for the establishment of such companies. He finally asked if Cyprus is willing to end this practice.
Greek MEP Stelios Kouloglou said that there are problems in the Republic of Cyprus that have created phenomena of corruption. Referring to the Anti-Corruption Authority, he said it was an important step, but questioned why it was given investigative powers so that it could effectively move forward with its work. The aim, he said, is "not to criticise and point out the negatives, but to help Cyprus become better, to reduce corruption, to improve transparency, to make the findings public. Only in this way can the country be truly fortified against the enemy."
In her turn, Elisa Wozemberg raised the question of whether there is a safety net in Cyprus through the legislative framework for legal interceptions. Furthermore, she said that in a meeting of the committee with a journalist yesterday, he said in no uncertain terms that "Cyprus is corrupt, the institutions do not work, the parliament takes orders and votes unanimously on the orders of the President, who is all-powerful." Asked by the committee if there is corruption by MPs, the journalist told them that "they are all corrupt". He noted that if this is reflected in a report it affects Cyprus very negatively in many factors and it involves packages, funds etc,
The joint meeting of the Institutions and Legal Affairs Committees was chaired by DISY MP and Chairman of the Legal Affairs, Justice and Public Order Committee, Nikos Tornaritis, who in his address presented the constitutional and legislative framework of the Republic of Cyprus on the issue of wiretapping. As he said, the Legal Affairs Committee has registered the issue of the production and distribution of software that may be used for illegal surveillance, which will be discussed at its next meeting.
For his part, DISY MP Demetris Demetriou, Chairman of the Institutions Committee, said that the belief in freedom, human rights and privacy is absolute and inviolable. He referred to responsibility on the part of the Parliament, where, although there is no party majority, laws related to the issue are passed.
On behalf of the Democratic Rally, Fotini Tsiridou said that it is a matter of principle for the Democratic Rally that everything is clear and transparent. "We demand that we improve our procedures," she said, stressing that a broader debate must be opened on the issue of cybersecurity and that security and confidentiality of conversations are fundamental human rights.
Aristos Damianou, on behalf of AKEL, said he would submit documents with specific facts to the committee of inquiry. He referred to the spy van, the production of dual-use software in the Republic of Cyprus and the political intrigue surrounding the issue. He elaborated on the events surrounding the spy van and Tal Jonathan Dilian and on equipment found in Larnaca related to that van.
As Mr Damianou said, from the above activities there seems to have been illegal access to more than 9.5 million devices. When the case went to court, the accused company was fined €76,000 and the prosecution against the owner and officer of the convicted company was suspended. "And the Court ordered the return of all the equipment, including the van to the defendants! If the authorities of the Republic did their job properly, possibly the activities of the persons in question and their companies (some of which were renamed) would not be transferred and would not affect Greece," he concluded.
Christiana Erotokritou, on behalf of the Democratic Party, said that it is the legal and moral obligation of the Cyprus State to investigate and draw conclusions about possible misconduct on the territory of the Republic of Cyprus, while a balance must be struck between national security and the safeguarding of human rights. He said there were questions that were not answered in the framework of the Republic of Cyprus' investigation, following the revelation about the spy van, with possible involvement of politicians. "What raises questions is whether export licences have been issued by the Republic of Cyprus for these products. The company states that it exports the products from the Republic of Cyprus, while the Republic of Cyprus denies it and says that not a single license has been issued."
On behalf of the EPP, Costas Efstathiou said that in a rule of law, such behavior cannot be tolerated, whether licensed or not, and it is a big scandal to export such software, a bomb to the foundations of the rule of law.
Efstathiou referred to his own testimony, when three years ago he denounced information about the behaviour of political parties in Cyprus, who had asked for bids for such software. He also said that he had information that there was a surveillance system in the basements of another party. "No one asked me, no one was interested, nothing happened."
From the Ecologists, Haralambos Theopeptou said the "unacceptable way" in which the government is handling the issue is a serious matter. "We expected the Attorney General's Office to take drastic legal measures, to order investigations into what happened and how the system ended up in Cyprus," he said, as, under the law, the dual-use system had to be given a special licence, signed by a person who takes responsibility that the software exists. "It is clear that the procedure was violated," he said. Referring to the committee of inquiry, he said that "based on what is happening in Cyprus, you are the only source of information for reliable data in Cyprus."
Marinos Mousiuttas, on behalf of the Democratic Party, said he hoped that the committee's visit to Cyprus would provide the information needed so that the report would be as comprehensive and objective as possible. "We look forward to your report so that we too can see what exactly is happening."
Finally, independent MP Andreas Themistocleous said that surveillance has a cost for democracy, which is threatened when surveillance is carried out, either under the pretext of state security or to tackle organised crime. "We have to find a balance between protecting the state and protecting human rights," he said."
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source