Discussion of the EPP-DIKO proposal for quick adjudication of financial disputes, Parliamentary Legal Committee
Discussion began on Wednesday in the Parliamentary Legal Committee on a proposal for a law by the EPP and DIKO to create a special jurisdiction in the District Courts, for speedy adjudication of disputes[/B] arising out of or in connection with credit facilities or securities.
The proposal, as said at the meeting by representatives of Ministries, is almost the same as the one tabled by the Government in 2021 and withdrawn due to amendments tabled by political parties. AKEL MP Aristos Damianou said that they would reinstate the comprehensive amendment that all parties had agreed on in substantial time, since, he said, it enshrined both rights and possibilities for the benefit of borrowers and guarantors.
EPP President Marinos Sizopoulos said in a statement after the meeting that, "albeit, with a long delay", the Legal Affairs Committee began to re-discuss the proposal to set up a special division of the District Courts for the direct appeal of borrowers who disagree with the banks' over-indebtedness or with the procedure that credit institutions follow for the sale of their assets. The proposal, he said, has been co-signed by the EPP and DIKO.
"We hope and hope that the delays and expediencies that characterized the discussions in the past will be abandoned this time so that we can also offer the necessary protection to citizens against the arbitrariness that financial institutions have shown against them," Sizopoulos said.
Asked about this, he said what has been agreed is that there will be a special division in the District Courts, which will deal exclusively with such cases and borrowers who disagree either with the overcharging of financial institutions for their loans or with the procedures for the sale of their property can appeal to these divisions.
"We believe that this will greatly protect borrowers, it will greatly help in the timely and proper restructuring of loans so as to reduce the number of loans, but it will also benefit the economy and the financial institution and, above all, the citizens," Sizopoulos said.
Asked about the possibility of an issue of unconstitutionality being raised by the Legal Service, Sizopoulos said that this proposal as submitted is exactly the same proposal that was included in the Bill submitted by the Government in January 2021, as part of its commitment to the EPP to pass the 2021 budgets. "The only change in this Bill was the removal of the provision that the right to appeal to this special division of the court would be granted to citizens who come from vulnerable groups of the population as determined by a Ministerial Decree.
"So you understand that the Ministerial Decree will have a subjective character, but on the other hand, all citizens should be able to access the justice system, freely, without restrictions, so that the justice system can decide in the end whether they are right or wrong," Sizopoulos said. Therefore, he added, since the Legal Service had endorsed the bill at the time, "for us there is no question of unconstitutionality."
In his own statements, AKEL MP Aristos Damianou said that the debate that took place today "is not today". He recalled that for a two-year period, from 2019 to 2021, the Legal Affairs Committee, on the initiative of opposition parties, had drafted a comprehensive proposal "with significant amendments combining changes" to both the Courts and the Transition and Mortgage Law in order to safeguard the right of borrowers and guarantors to unhindered access to justice and create the conditions for a fair trial and restore the balance between the rights of borrowers and banks.
On the morning of the plenary session when the amended legislation was to be voted on, he said, the Government Bill "as we amended it then as the Legal Affairs Committee, defiantly and in an eccentric manner, the Government withdrew the Bill". Since then, and for three years, he added, the banks have been "institutionally disrespecting guarantors and borrowers". Damianou said he noted the fact that two parties are reintroducing the original government bill, which he said "is in the right direction" but "we believe it is not sufficient, therefore, we will reintroduce the comprehensive amendment that all parties had agreed to at the essential time which in our view enshrine both rights and opportunities for the benefit of borrowers and guarantors."
DIKO MP, Christiana Erotokritou, said in her remarks that as DIKO, they recognize the need that the State has, for everyone to have equal, quick access to securing a court decision in any financial dispute that concerns them.
"We discussed a proposal for a law to create a special service within the District Courts where all disputes of a financial nature will be heard in a quick 60-day period," she said. He added that a constituted State cannot fail to provide the right and facility to all to have quick access to justice and also give them the right and assurance of securing judicial impartial adjudication within a very short time for such matters.
He said they hope very soon they will have a conclusion in the House on the Bill. Asked about this, she said that the DIKO's aim is to do everything in their power to meet the December date when the Plenary concludes its work.
With regard to issues of constitutionality of some articles of the proposal that may arise, she said she believes that appropriate corrections can be found in a way that everyone can agree on without affecting the philosophy of the proposed law.
ELAM MP Sotiris Ioannou said that his party supports the need to create a special court regarding issues of divestment, but at the same time, there must be a change in the Transition and Mortgage Law so that there are practical and effective results for borrowers.
He also said that because there was a reference by the competent Ministry to a vulnerable group, they believe that there should be a redefinition of this definition. "For us, a vulnerable group is also a family man who receives a salary of €900, but this is not enough, not even for rent and electricity." He said he was referring to the €900 set by the Ministry of Labour as the minimum wage, "an amount which we, consider minimal in the face of current needs."
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source