[/QUOTE]Parliament finds obstacles and restrictions for abortions in Cyprus Under the "microscope" the weaknesses of the system of medical services for abortion
The barriers and restrictions faced by women who need to undergo abortion in Cyprus were examined today by the Parliamentary Committee on Human Rights, in light of recent changes to the legislative framework in the US around this issue. During the discussion developed at the meeting, weaknesses were highlighted in the system of medical services for abortion, as well as in the information provided to women on family planning issues.
Today's meeting of the Committee, which focused on the safeguarding of women's sexual and reproductive rights on the initiative of AKEL, raised the issue that all legal aspects of abortion should be covered by the GESY, as currently this does not apply in the case of the free choice of the pregnant woman during the first 12 weeks In addition, the need was raised to frame with clear protocols the management of abortions by health professionals and hospitals, as well as to ensure a supportive framework with counselling services for women. Access to contraception was also discussed, as well as the sexual education provided.
The officials of the Cyprus Family Planning Association were revealing about the limitations women face in terms of the legal right to abortion. In particular, it was reported that when some women visited clinics to have an abortion, some officials turned them away on the grounds that abortion is not legal, even though the 2018 revised legislation considers abortion as a legal medical procedure in three different cases.
Specifically, under the revised legislation, as reported at the committee meeting, abortion can be performed at up to 19 weeks pregnant women who have been victims of sexual abuse, while at 12 weeks pregnant women can choose abortion for any reason. It is provided that abortion may be performed by a pregnant woman regardless of the week of pregnancy, in agreement with the treating physician, and for medical reasons.
The officials of the Family Planning Association, however, expressed their disappointment that abortion at 12 weeks, at the free choice of the pregnant woman, is not covered by the OAS. Specifically, the OAI spokesperson explained that the Agency covers through GHS those services deemed "medically necessary for prevention and management of medical conditions." This definition, she said, has the consequence that women's contraceptive methods are not covered, and, with regard to abortions, she said that a recent decision of the Agency's Board of Directors covers abortions up to 19 weeks of gestation if the pregnancy is the consequence of sexual abuse, rape or incest, or regardless of the weeks of gestation, if there is a medical abnormality or if the pregnancy is expected to cause a medical, either physical or mental, problem.
By extension, abortions of the pregnant woman's free choice within 12 weeks' gestation, which are provided for by law, are not covered by the GHS, which is what the Parliamentary Human Rights Committee will request in a letter to the Agency. Besides, the OAS representative noted that because it is a recent decision on abortion, there are no statistics, the lack of which was highlighted during the meeting as a major obstacle to strategy formulation. A representative of the Ministry of Health nursing services, however, when addressing the meeting, indicated that there were indeed inequalities in access to abortion due to the limited financial capacity of some women, and noted that this service should be covered by the GHS.
As the Executive Director of the Family Planning Association, Maria Epaminonda, explained, if the definition of health adopted by the OAS includes mental health, then the Agency should cover all legal abortion cases, as forcing a pregnancy to continue if a pregnancy does not fall within the two categories covered by the GHS and if the woman cannot afford to cover the cost herself, may have consequences for her mental health. Concerns were also expressed about how accessible the services provided by the health system are when there are professionals who refuse to provide them, resulting in women being referred from one hospital to another through a lengthy and painful process until they can be served, while already being in a risky situation.
A spokesperson for the OCHA confirmed that there is indeed resistance from some doctors in public hospitals when called upon to provide abortion services. He cited, in particular, an example of anaesthetists refusing to provide their services in an abortion case because of their religious beliefs, as he explained, with the result that the OHCHR had to seek an alternative solution by having other professionals provide services.
Gender Equality Commissioner, Josephine Antoniou, said that "the state must ensure the health and sexual and reproductive rights of all citizens", and noted that if an organisation such as the OAS does not cover the right of free choice for abortion (at up to 12 weeks gestation), which is legally enshrined, this means that it essentially does not recognise this right. He spoke of "statistical illiteracy in Cyprus" in the absence of data on the number, frequency and type of abortions in the country, and said the figure of 90 abortions quoted is ridiculous and creates a false picture that is damaging. He particularly stressed the need for women to be informed about abortion laws and options for modern contraceptive methods. She noted that knowledge about women's rights over their own bodies can help reduce violence against women. "The abuser, through the power he thinks he has over the woman, can deny her the right to abortion or contraception," Ms. Antoniou said.
The issue of inadequate information, primarily for women but also in general, was raised by all actors and organisations. Particular reference was also made to the lack of psychological support and counselling for pregnant women, either before or after abortion, which is not characterised by an intention to manipulate. Similarly, serious shortcomings were noted with regard to information and sex education for children and young people. School health services reported to the meeting that seminars are offered on various topics related to sexual and reproductive health. However, it was pointed out at the meeting that the number of teaching hours covered by these seminars is limited (only two per class) and, especially with regard to contraception, the relevant seminars are offered when pupils reach the third grade.
Statements by MPs
AKEL MP and chairman of today's Committee meeting, George Koukumas, said that "2018 saw a big step with the adoption of the AKEL proposal to modernise abortion legislation, but we need to ensure in practice that this right is respected for all women without exception". In this context, he said, it was requested and will also be communicated in a letter from the Committee to the OAI Board that all legal cases of abortion be covered by the YESY, as well as access to modern forms of contraception and the immediate formulation of a protocol for the handling of these cases in public hospitals.
As he explained, it may be necessary for the OAI to reconsider the definition of the necessary medical procedure, while information on the protocol for the handling of these cases is expected from the OCYP, in order to ensure that counselling support is also provided, without a directive approach. "To a woman in this situation, psychological blackmail must be added," he noted."
"Never and nowhere has banning abortion reduced unwanted pregnancies or abortions," he noted, adding that when it becomes difficult to access safe abortions, then dangerous ones increase, endangering women's lives. She also raised the issue of equity, since the constraints, she explained, are even greater for middle- and low-income women if access is difficult.
Finally, she mentioned that real sex education is also needed at all levels, which is "scientifically based and pedagogically adapted to children's level of understanding.
The "dark number of abortions" was referred to in her statements after the meeting by DISY MP Rita Superman, referring to the lack of statistics around the issue of abortions. She welcomed the recommendation of the OAI to create a protocol to inform medical services in order to address the lack of homogeneity in how doctors treat abortion cases, and noted that the OAI was asked to review the criteria for including abortions in the services reimbursed by the state.
He made particular reference to the contribution of school-based medical services to education, but noted that training is limited to two teaching periods a year in different classrooms. Finally, she said that the Commission would come back to this issue "because it concerns legislation that has been passed and regulates serious human rights issues that are exclusive to women."
The MEP for the Ecologists, Alexandra Attalidou, said in her remarks that the case of the United States proves that "human rights are not guaranteed forever, but can change depending on who is in power." She said that the state should conduct campaigns to inform women about their rights. "We expect the right that was enshrined in Cyprus in 2018 to be enshrined in the services of the OAS. We expect protocols for the management of abortion from the OCYP, because it should not be left to any doctor or nurse to decide whether a woman has the right to abortion," Attalidou said, following up on what was discussed in the committee.
She stressed that education should focus on creating citizens with critical thinking and understanding to make good decisions for themselves, so that girls and women are aware of what is needed to prevent or manage an unwanted pregnancy.
Source: KYPE
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source