Researchers are now turning their attention to clarifying whether smallpox in monkeys is contagious even with mild or no symptoms, leading to the development of antibody tests, specific for this type of virus
Two recent European studies on smallpox in monkeys, leave room for some infections from the disease to remain asymptomatic.
The problem that arises is the potential for transmission of the virus by individuals infected with the virus while they remain asymptomatic.
A potential solution could be provided by serological testing, but there is not yet a specific test to distinguish between viruses belonging to the smallpox virus family, although a diagnostic is currently being researched and developed by the US Center for Disease Control.
As noted in an article in JAMA, whether the infections recorded were indeed asymptomatic or whether mild symptoms were simply not given attention remains to be seen, as relevant studies point out to treating physicians and high-risk individuals that monkeypox can go undetected, possibly even when it is contagious.
The two studies from Belgium and France used molecular analysis tests on retrospective samples of men who have sex with men as part of routine screening for chlamydia and gonorrhea in hospital sexual health units.
In the Belgian study, which included 224 patient samples from May, 3 of the 4 men who tested positive for simian pox virus reported being asymptomatic at the time of testing and were also symptom-free in the 2 months before the test and for 3 to 5 weeks afterwards. The fourth patient had a periorbital rash that had been misdiagnosed as a herpes outbreak. Clinical examination at the subsequent follow-up visits found no signs of monkeypox on the skin, neck or genital areas of the 3 patients. In the French study of 200 samples collected over 5 weeks from early June, 13 asymptomatic men had positive test results, but only 2 of them later presented to the clinic with symptoms.
"These studies show that contrary to what was known about monkeypox in Africa, not all patients present with symptoms," Marjan Van Esbroeck, a clinical microbiologist at the Institute of Tropical Medicine in Antwerp and senior author of the Belgian study, noted in an email to JAMA.
Asymptomatic or subtle?
Van Esbroeck noted that she believes monkey smallpox infections can be asymptomatic. However, she acknowledged that subtle, unrecognizable symptoms could not be completely ruled out. He explained that the 3 asymptomatic individuals with positive test results were not clinically examined on the day their specimens were obtained because, according to clinic policy, only patients who complain about their health are referred to a clinician.
Therefore, Van Esbroek wrote in her email, "We cannot rule out that minor skin lesions have been overlooked or that general symptoms such as mild fever or malaise were not reported by the subjects."
In an interview, Boguma Kabisen Titanji, an assistant professor of medicine in the Department of Infectious Diseases at Emory University, said certain factors lead her to believe that the latter scenario is more likely.
Titangi, who was not involved in any of the new studies, pointed to the "remarkable spectrum" of monkeypox manifestations in the current outbreak, ranging from cold-like symptoms and isolated pustules mistaken for pimples to diffuse skin rashes and painful anogenital or oropharyngeal lesions.
A study of 528 monkeypox infections occurring in 16 countries up to the end of June found that 95% of patients had a rash. However, Titangi said, "very mild findings are possible, very severe findings are possible, and everything in between."
She also added that "there is evidence that monkeypox has been circulating undetected for some time in non-endemic countries before cases were first detected in England in early May. (In fact, a positive sample from 1 of the asymptomatic patients in Belgium was collected several days before the first case was detected there.) Meanwhile, it is unknown how long the virus may continue to be detected in patient samples collected from different parts of the body such as the mouth, nose, anus and genitals.
Titangi said that although the new studies are important, the allegedly asymptomatic patients may have missed subtle symptoms or remembered them later because they presented before monkeypox showed up on their "radar".
Sarah Ann Galiardo, chief health scientist in the CDC's Division of Global Migration and Quarantine, wrote in an email that the reports "certainly suggest that asymptomatic monkeypox infections could exist." but that "it's not really clear what percentage of cases are truly asymptomatic or simply exist with very subtle symptoms and are therefore not recognized by patients or clinicians."
The more important question that arises, however, is whether patients with asymptomatic or very mild disease can infect others, Galiardo said.
An incredible meme
Galiardo investigated possible asymptomatic monkey smallpox in Cameroon in 2017 as an Epidemic Intelligence Service officer in the CDC's smallpox and rabies virus division and is now involved in the response to the monkey smallpox outbreak.
He said it is alarming that low cycle threshold values, indicating high viral load, were found in asymptomatic individuals in recent European studies. However, he added that this alone does not answer the question of transmission.
There was, however, additional evidence in the Belgian study that asymptomatic transmission may be possible. When Van Esbroeck's team analyzed positive samples from asymptomatic patients and found virus capable of replicating in 2 of 3 genital swabs. According to the researchers, these 2 individuals could potentially transmit the virus before they knew they were infected. All 3 asymptomatic patients reported having sexual intercourse during testing, but the researchers could not confirm whether further transmission occurred. In the French study, the researchers did not attempt to isolate the reproducible virus in the samples and therefore could not comment on the possibility of transmission.
In Van Esbroeck's view, the difference between completely asymptomatic patients and patients with unrecognized mild symptoms is theoretical. "Both will result in individuals not being isolated and potentially continuing to have high-risk behaviours," she noted.
She and Titangi stressed that clinicians and high-risk individuals need to be aware of the range of clinical manifestations so that patients with even very subtle symptoms can visit their physicians for early screening, diagnosis, and information to reduce the chances of transmitting the virus to other people, including pets.
At the HIV clinic where Titangi provides outpatient care, about 50% of monkey smallpox tests are positive. "That just says we're not doing enough testing," he said. She has provided treatment to several patients whose only symptoms were severe pain when swallowing. In some cases, the lesions are not visible, but can be spotted by experts, in the larynx or rectum. Titangi points out to clinicians that monkeypox infection "can look like a lot of things we see in clinical practice. It's an incredible mimic."
She further emphasizes, however, that not every patient with high-risk behaviors can be screened, as the test costs about $200 without insurance.
For his part, Abraar Karan, an infectious disease specialist and postdoctoral researcher at Stanford University, suggested using a lateral flow test to reduce the interval between contagiousness and detection, since "with asymptomatic transmission, this is particularly important."
New test
According to Karan, the unprecedented extent of transmission in the current outbreak suggests that shedding infectious virus from people who are asymptomatic or mildly symptomatic is very likely to be underestimated. "If only those with clinical symptoms transmitted the virus, we probably would not have had as large an epidemic, as few sexual partners would be willing to have high-risk sex with someone if they were visibly ill or had visible lesions," he noted.
He pointed out that asymptomatic cases exist even for more serious viral diseases such as Ebola, so it's not surprising that this would be the case for monkey pox.
Karan said that possibly serological testing of the population could reveal the extent of undetectable transmission.
But this is not possible because there are still no antibody tests specifically for the virus, explained Daniel Duek, an immunologist at the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID). At present, serological testing can only identify exposure to general smallpox viruses, the family of orthopoxviruses that includes all of the monkeypox, smallpox and damalitis viruses. People who have been vaccinated against smallpox with the damalitis virus will be positive in a general antibody test for the orthopoxvirus, blurring the results.
Dueke, head of the Immunology Division at NIAID's Vaccine Research Center, studies HIV. When monkey pox infections started making headlines, he was getting a series of questions from homosexuals, such as how long had it been spreading?
So he decided to create a test that could diagnose monkey pox from tamalitis. It is now producing the test in collaboration with smallpox virus experts at the CDC.
If it works, which will be known around mid-September, it could be applied by this fall to vulnerable groups such as men who have sex with men, sex workers and people in nations where monkeypox is historically endemic, although the disease can affect anyone who comes into close contact with the virus.
Source: in.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs to Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source