What's new

[Cyprus Times] Much of the TC community neither welcomed nor condemned the invasion, says Moudouros. The goal then and now

moudourosisvoli.jpg

A large part of the Turkish Cypriot community neither welcomed nor condemned the Turkish invasion, says N. Moudouros What he tells the Cyprus News Agency

A large grey area was created in the TC community immediately after the 1974 Turkish military invasion in terms of the imprint it left on the TCs and continues to do so, with Nikos Moudouros explaining to the Cyprus News Agency that the transformation of the TC community by Turkey began in 1975 with the main feature being the alteration of identity and the removal of TCs from the productive process.

The lecturer at the Department of Turkish and Middle Eastern Studies of the University of Cyprus said that the biggest impasse today for the TC community is its relations with Turkey, an "evil stepmother" that imposes through financial aid the change of not only the socio-economic model. Next to us, he said, we do not have a T/C community, but Turkish state structures that no longer need legitimacy from T/C politicians, they implement them directly. There are, he noted, daily de facto changes.

The goal then and now

Nikos Moudouros said that we need to separate the issue of self-government of the T/C community from the acquisition of a separate state entity, noting also the ideological division within the T/C community. The goal of the T/C right, he said, was clear, as early as 1950 and especially since 1960, that the T/Cs should have a separate state organization from the E/Cs. On the other hand, there was a very large current within the T/C left that claimed self-government without this being antagonistic to the E/C community.

Their separation from the E/C community was not done in a way that ensured their political equality or their prosperity and development in a self-government framework because it made them completely dependent on Turkey, he added.

On the issue of state-building there is a total failure, but the issue of their self-governance is still alive, he said, saying that in the programme of the left and centre-left it is listed as an issue of transforming the TCs into subjects with autonomy in their internal affairs, in cooperation with the E/C community, and as far as possible independent of Turkey. "This part was not achieved."

It is true, he continued, that the military invasion on July 20, 1974 offered a very large part of the T/C community a sense of relief, but we must underline "relief" as he said, because it was neither a joy nor a condemnation of the events. Moudouros noted that there was a big grey area in how the T/Cs accepted the military invasion because it was preceded by the bad experience of 1964-1974. "The relief that the act of the Turkish invasion may have provided in the context of the situation disappeared in the next 24 hours."



Because, he added, when it began to become clear from August 1974 onwards what the deeper goal of transformation in the T/C community was, the first strong reactions were created. Turkey tried to impose a certain identity at the ideological and socio-economic level, which was completely alien to the TCs, he added.

Since 1975, the more organized voices of reaction to what, for example, was called 'an attempt at a new T/q homeland' began to exist, Nikos Moudouros said, giving examples, the change of place names to Turkish, the denaturalization of the public landscape, colonization, etc., which showed the T/q that "the relief of 1974 was the beginning of a new regime of guardianship".

With the establishment of the T/C federal state in 1976, the official opposition was also created, he noted, but T/C reactions became organized, acquired a political program and a more massive expression from the late 1980s onwards.

The "evil stepmother"

On the question of whether Turkey is a "mother country" or "mother oppressor", Moudouros said that the T/C right still maintains the doctrine of the "mother country," to which all competences, powers of "protection of the T/Cs" should be granted. At the same time, he added, there are reactions from social movements of the left and the broader left, human rights organizations, platforms such as "This country is ours," for whom Turkey has the concept of colonialism, "it is a bad stepmother."

In all the models of communal-economic change that Turkey has followed since 1974, there was one common invariable element and it was the almost total marginalization of TCs from the productive process, he said. The transformation, he explained, of the TC community into a parasitic market, a market of consumers rather than producers. "This is extremely important in understanding the role of Turkey because it does not only dominate economically because there are some Turkish companies and big Turkish capital in the occupied territories."

The production process, he said, historically generates demands for autonomy, independence, more proper political and economic organization, more powerful trade unions and these in the T/C community have been strong,. But with the changes that Turkey has made to the financial or economic model of development, it has succeeded in wearing them down and demassifying them, he noted.

What was a turning point in changing the T/C view of Turkey was that the financial relationship is purely a disciplining relationship. "The lending is about the deficits that are created in the 'public service' and the conditions that Turkey sets to give this money are colonial disciplining of the TC community and how it will develop in a certain socio-economic model."

The deadlock of the T/C community

According to Nikos Moudouros, the big deadlock that has been created in the last 10 years for the T/C community is the new relationship that this government of Turkey is trying to impose. He explained that Turkey, in order to achieve its policy more easily and painlessly by assimilating reactions, was using local TC factors. In recent years, however, with the relations between Akinci and Erdogan as a prime example, Turkey does not even enter the process of legitimizing its presence through TC political forces, it appears itself, overtly, as a Turkish state, he noted. He cited Varosha as an example, where when Turkey decided to "transform" it, it did not deal with which T/C structures could contribute to it, the Turkish state itself came and did it.

"So, it means that the Greek Cypriot community next to it does not have some forces that disagree on the resolution of the Cyprus problem, the balance of power in the occupied territories changes, the Turkish 'embassy' gains more power. It seems that a larger part of settlers are being politicized than in previous years. In the balance of power, if the situation continues as it is, it means that the Greek Cypriot organised community that will take over the negotiations on the Cyprus problem will be confronted with institutions of the Turkish state and power, which are not much needed by the TCs."

The blacklist of TCs who cannot enter Turkey is a very serious case at the level of social confrontation. Moudouros said that Ankara seeks to leave out of the political process the TCs who continue to remind that Cyprus must be reunited and that the TC identity is more Cypriot than Turkish. Moudouros replied that much will be decided by the context in which a new effort on the Cyprus problem will be launched and what conditions Turkey perceives that it has to promote the position it considers to be correct at the diplomatic level. But until then, he noted, there is a de facto annexation of the occupied territories on a daily basis with the daily management model. "It (Turkey) does not even remind us that these are two states. It is trying to remind that it is a Turkish prefecture. This is even more intransigent."

The two-state solution position may survive in circumstances where there are no negotiations or where there is diminished interest from the international actor, but Turkey is taking advantage of the international actor's increased interest in it on other issues, such as Ukraine or NATO, he said. After the Cyprus settlement, he asked, will it be possible to abolish the water infrastructure that Turkey has built in recent years in the occupied territories? If it builds military infrastructure in the occupied territories for its navy, in the Cyprus solution this will be discussed since it has already been implemented on the ground, he also questioned. The question, he said, is what happens on the ground every day.


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs to Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source
 
Back
Top