What's new

[Cyprus Times] Lignadis was released from prison by a 2010 law. How is guilty combined with parole?

lignadis.jpg

Analysis of the legal framework governing the decision

The decision of the Mixed Jury Court to convict Dimitris Lignadis for the rape of two minors, imposing a sentence of 10 and 5 years imprisonment, and a combined 12 years - and then to be released - until his case is heard in the court of appeal, caused a storm of reaction.

Incidentally, in the appeal court, unless the verdict is overturned, the sentence is unlikely to fall below 9 to 10 years - and of those in prison the convict will spend up to 4.5 years.

On social media it became clear that there were many who could not understand the -apparently- conflicting verdict. That is, how someone can be found guilty of heinous crimes and go free until the appeal hearing - with a bail of 30,000 euros.

Criminal lawyer Panagiotis St. Balaktaris clarifies in Magazine that the answers we are all seeking will be provided when the reasoning behind the decision is heard. This is expected to happen in about a year. He agreed, however, to help explain the inexplicable, based on his experience in criminal courts and his own trials in the Mixed Jury Court, which is very different from the regular one, as most of them are civilian - lay judges, jurors.

He admitted that "understandably the decision is incomprehensible, for anyone who does not know law, but even for lawyers who do not deal with criminal law. Who are not intimately familiar with judicial practice and have not tried cases in a mixed jury. It's very different from regular courts, as most are civilian - lay judges, jurors. There are 4 lay judges (citizens) and 3 regular judges."


THE COMMON SENSE OF JUSTICE
Mr Balaktaris says that "by law, the common sense of justice and popular sovereignty are realized with the presence of more jurors than judges. The common sense of justice is not what we say in our groups or cafes, because if it were, it would not be clear whose common sense of justice should be taken into account. Mine, yours, the judge's, or the jury's - who apparently disagreed in this particular case?

Judgments are rendered in the name of the Greek people and certain rights are recognized, with more jurors than judges. In the Lignadis case, almost all of the verdicts were by a narrow majority. The presiding judge and some of the regular judges were in favour of the rights of the accused - I say it this way to make myself clear.



The accused was acquitted of two of the four acts and convicted by a majority for the other two.

As Antonia Xynou wrote after clarifying that there was no firm line at least as far as the jury was concerned, "Dimitris Lignadis was found guilty of two rapes. The first concerns a minor in Epidaurus in 2015 where the director was convicted by a majority (4-3).

A juror, the president and the left-wing judge dissented, who were of the opinion that he should be declared not guilty due to doubts.

The second concerns the rape of the minor, who resided for a long time in Dimitris Lignadis' house. The verdict came by a majority (5-2).

The minority consisted of the president and a delegate, who were of the opinion that he should be declared not guilty due to doubts.

Regarding the acquittals, the director was found not guilty by a majority (5-2) of doubt for an alleged rape in 2015 at his home, while the court was unanimous as to the fourth complainant who never appeared in court to support his claims.

Thus, marginal majorities (4-3) were formed, which left a lot of leeway in the outcome of the decision" and these were exploited by Lignadi's lawyer to seek a stay of execution of the convicted man's sentence.

Before we go there, we will deal with something else.

WHY DIDn'T LYNNADES WEAR ARROW?
"Based on what I have read, the only unanimous decision they made was the rejection of the mitigating circumstance of prior lawful life," Mr Balaktaris continues, "my guess is that it was because the Supreme Court's plenary decision on Korkoneas had come out, which defined this mitigating circumstance differently, and the court was persuaded.

They also rejected by a majority the mitigating circumstance of subsequent good behaviour. Which means that they were outvoted by the judges, who said that this mitigating factor should be granted.

After the guilty plea, the prosecutor recommended 12 years for each act of rape, so by merger it would be 18.

The court ruled 10 and 5 years - by merger 12. Then, as is customary in these cases, they withdrew to rule on whether or not to suspend the appeal. It was asked to decide whether he is a potential threat to the law (if he is suspected of committing similar offences) and how the state can ensure that he attends the appeal -and does not leave the country.

They decided to impose a 30,000 bail condition, appearance at the station and a curfew."

Why didn't they also decide to have him wear a wristband to ensure that he attends the appeal - and doesn't disappear? "Putting this on is mainly done at the interrogation stage. It is not customary in parole on appeal. As far as I know, it has never been done in suspension on appeal.

HOW THE INVESTIGATOR PRELIMINED AND THE COURT DISMISSED
The investigator had decided to remand Lignadis in custody, based on the complaint and the contents of the case for which he was acquitted on Wednesday 13/7, on the grounds that he was suspected of committing similar offences - when he was still a suspect. That is, the arrest warrant had been issued on the basis of this dangerousness. The provisional detention was the consequence of four MPs who founded it.

As a convicted person (for two rapes of minors) he was not suspected of committing similar offences. How did this happen?

"The role - the mission - of pre-trial detention is different from that of parole (of the appellate court). It raises an issue that has not been raised by a lawyer from those who have spoken since yesterday. Until a few years ago, Greece and France were competing to see which was first in Europe in pre-trial detainees (they are on trial until they are tried in the first instance.)

We had reached the point that towards the end of the 2000s, the then President of the Union of Judges and Prosecutors and now MP for Mytilene, Charalambos Athanasiou, had issued a statement saying that there should be no abuse of imprisonment until the Court of Appeal." That is, not everyone should go to jail after the first court decision and before the appeals court.

So, in the issue of Lignadis, another issue arises, apart from why he is free while he was convicted. It is why he was remanded - was he not remanded properly? In my opinion, he was rightly released with a stay pending appeal.

This is something that happens a lot in courts around the country in the context of a stay pending appeal, as all criminal lawyers can assure you. I have defended a manslaughter defendant in a mixed jury trial. He was sentenced to 15 years and was released pending appeal. By that I mean that what happened didn't happen because of Lignades. It became something that happens in most cases, but people don't learn about them.

If you ask those who deal with criminal law on a daily basis, you will be struck by how often it happens - in cases where judges find that the law is not broken."

HOW THE LAW IS NOT BEING BREAKED - AT THE DEBATE OF APPEAL

"The law provides that it is now the rule that a stay until the appellate court is granted unless the court finds that the defendant

a) is a suspected fugitive -which must be proven, present, say, reservations he has made, for a flight

b) has violated restraints in the past

c) has attempted to escape himself or has assisted another to escape .

Then there is a criterion that is checked after all the above have been checked: it is the possibility that he has caused excessive and irreparable harm - to himself or his family - while in prison.

Finally, an assessment is made of whether he is likely to commit similar offences if released.

THE CONVICTED IS PRESUMED DEAD UNTIL THE Trial


Here it would be useful to clarify that what you have read and what you will read next refutes the narrative that the "Paraskevopoulos Law" bears responsibility for what happened. For the record, as Nikos Paraskevopoulos clarified - and all the criminal lawyers we spoke to agreed - it is completely irrelevant to the release of Lignadis, as it is not based on prison decongestion, but on the Code of Criminal Procedure, as it has been in force for a long time.

The key takeaway for Mr. Balaktaris regarding the Lignadis decision, which is not widely known, is what follows.

"In 2010, with Law 3904, the legislature (i.e., Parliament) addressed the granting of parole after a first trial conviction. The explanatory memorandum to the law stated that it had been abused - in terms of imprisoning defendants after the first conviction and while they had appealed.

This was contrary to the European Convention on Human Rights and its accompanying protocols.

This was contrary to the European Convention on Human Rights and its accompanying protocols. It stipulated the following:

"Once a person is convicted at first instance and not at last instance, there is still a presumption of innocence and he must be treated as innocent and until the appeal court he must not have served the sentence imposed on him."

In application of this issue, the law was passed. Cases were reduced and rightly so, as many cases were overturned in the second instance - and I'm talking about homicide, extortion, criminal organizations, etc.

In this case, Lignadis appealed. It will be determined more than a year from today-maybe more than two years if you factor in all the postponements that can be requested. So the appeal will be heard four to five years from today. The 12 years of Lignadi's sentence would have been served in the same period."

What the criminal lawyer is wont to say to help understand reality is that "the common sense of justice-every opportunity we seek for ourselves-is the reverse form of collective responsibility-which always weighs on others and not on us. The same is true of the presumption of innocence: we want it for ourselves, but not for others. People must learn that if a decision is sound, correct and just, it is completely irrelevant whether it displeases or pleases public opinion. There will always be some who will say it was wrongly handed down."

WHAT COULD HAVE CHANGED THE DEVELOPMENTS
As you have already read, in criminal law there is a presumption of innocence also on appeal. Those in charge of the trial decisions found that Lignadis is not suspected of committing crimes similar to those for which he was convicted. Previously, the court prosecutor twice emphasized the special characteristics of the crime and the possible commission of new offences. But he was not listened to.

Information (belonging to people who were involved in the trial) says that a very big role was played by the fact that the president of the court did not allow the material from his mobile phone to be brought into the reading (to be read in court). As the prosecution argues, this would have made it clear that he had been communicating with underage children on social media until some time before he was arrested.

It is clarified that the decision on whether or not there is suspicion of committing similar offences is at the discretion of the court.

It does not arise under the law.

Source: news247


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top