What's new

[Cyprus Times] "Inadequate and undocumented" report on passports - Nouri's response

cache_980x637_Crop_medium_513808_342596_22_08_25_122227.jpg

"Inadequate and undocumented" report on passports, says MFA says Internal audit was needed for CCPs, says Auditor General Tensions at first, lengthy meeting of the Parliamentary Audit Committee on passports All information

With counter arguments from the Auditor General (AG), Odysseus Michaelides and Interior Minister Nikos Nouris, the first, lengthy meeting of the Parliamentary Audit Committee, which is examining the Audit Service's report on the failings of the Cyprus Investment Programme (CIP), concluded at noon on Thursday.


At the meeting, which was convened extraordinarily, following the release of the report of the Audit Service (EY) on August 22, the SG had the opportunity to provide a number of examples of what was contained in the report, as well as to answer questions from Committee members. Subsequently, the DG undertook to respond in detail to the points raised in the report as problematic, stressing within the meeting that "a proper audit, without any expediency, was only carried out by the Commission of Inquiry" on the CCC.

In statements after the meeting, Nouris said that the government considers that "the report is inadequate, incomplete, undocumented and politically motivated". He even criticised the timing in which it has been made public, in the middle of an election period, saying that "the very same audit was carried out in 2016 by the Audit Office and absolutely nothing was announced."


"The control by the EY is always welcome, but we expect that suggestions, observations and any oversights found in the institutions should be given to the relevant agencies in a timely manner, in order to benefit democracy and the well-meaning public interest," the minister added, commenting that EY is coming back "regurgitating the same arguments and trying to prove that everything is flawed."

He expressed the view that the EY report does not deal with those who really have the most serious of the responsibilities, namely the providers and the supervisory authorities, who, he said, "receive absolutely no comment for their participation and action in the procedures of the CEC".

He stressed that "there should be full utilisation of the comprehensive and holistic investigation and the conclusion of the Investigation Committee", and expressed his pleasure that most of the MPs in their statements recognised that the termination of the CCC in this way was a loss for the Republic of Cyprus.

"The last thing we need at this time is for the well-meaning interest and image of the Republic of Cyprus to be hurt again by a controversy, which is about reheated food," he stressed. Nouris, noting that the common goal should be the restoration and strengthening of the country's economy.



Responding to a journalist's question on where political expediency is found, the Minister noted that the EY report deals only with findings from 2013, until 2020, while if he wanted this research to be more reliable, he should have included findings from 2008 in a similar way, as the Research Committee had done.

In response to another question, he focused on three major projects, which the EY report also deals with, the Ayia Napa Marina, the casino and the Wargaming investment. As the EY report notes, a significant number of naturalisations in excess of the law were made for investors in these projects, with the approval of the Council of Ministers. "The MoS has taken into account that the benefit to the Republic of Cyprus of the creation of these developments in the country offers much more than what the GC claims the letter of the law on naturalisations allowed," he said. Nouris and added that "since there is nothing wrong with the specific persons, the fact of the exercise of discretion by the MoC can only benefit the Republic of Cyprus, because in a short period of time Cyprus will enjoy the services of a marina worth 350 million, a casino on which more than 600 million have been spent, while our compatriots will be employed in these businesses, in addition to the other benefits."

Besides, during the meeting, Mr. Nouris said that the HC adopted the conclusion of the Investigative Committee and deprived 45 cases of citizenship, while other cases are ongoing. He added that on 31/7/21, the HC proceeded to reject 439 family members who were pending during the last examination of applications.

In turn, the Auditor General, Odysseas Michaelides, said after the meeting that he was "surprised", having realized, he said, "that the HC, in his statements outside the room, attributed to our Service political motives as to the timing of the publication of the report."

[/P]

In his turn, the Auditor General, Odysseas Michaelides, said after the meeting that he was "surprised", having realized, he said, "that the HC, in his statements outside the room, attributed to our Service political motives as to the timing of the publication of the report.

"It is unheard of for the government to cause a delay in the release of the EY report, not only because we were prevented for a whole year from accessing the data, but also because we sent the draft report on 2/5/2022 and we received a reply after two months, and to now come and accuse that the timing of the release of the report has to do with the presidential election and that this has to do with political motives of the EY," he said.

Responding to the accusation of ex-post presentation of results, Michaelides said that the government had thrown the two reports published by EY in September and November 2020 "in the dustbin" and that it was "talking about them within quotation marks to show that they are not even reports."

In response to the accusation, Michaelides said that the government had thrown the two reports published by EY in September and November 2020 "in the dustbin" and that it was "talking about them within quotation marks to show that they are not even reports.

"He (the government) accused us of not releasing reports earlier, which he was obviously going to throw in the dustbin," he said. Besides, during the meeting, Michaelides, responding to a statement by DISY MP Savia Orfanidou, said that "avoiding mishaps is done by prevention, through internal control, not by external control," stressing that a satisfactory internal control service was not created for the CCC.

"Our findings were fully confirmed both by the report of the Investigation Committee and by the present report, which now had access to all the data, but the government, apart from throwing the present report in the dustbin, comes and says that if we had done the audit in 2016, all the problems would have been magically solved," he added. He also recalled that the two 2020 reports had been forwarded to the Attorney General, "who not only did not deal with them, but called us to order because we prepared reports." He assured, however, that the present report, with names listed, will be forwarded to the Attorney General in the hope that it will receive due consideration.

"We think it is useful and we will forward the report to the Anti-Corruption Authority as well," Michaelides finally noted. "We believe that it is an Authority mandated to investigate corruption issues, but also because especially the issues related to possible responsibilities of the Council of Ministers, because the Attorney General was part of the SA, we believe that it would be a good move to forward the report to the Anti-Corruption Authority as well, for possible actions of its own, without questioning the authority of the Attorney General," he explained.

Investors were changing their name in Cyprus and keeping the original name in their country of origin

During the committee meeting, reference was also made to the phenomenon of name changes by foreigners who secured Cypriot citizenship but who kept their original name in their country of origin. Particular reference was made at the meeting by the SG to a case of a Chinese businessman who was checked by the Italian authorities and appeared to have dealings with a person with a Cypriot name, who was none other than the same person.

Taking it upon himself to respond, the Minister of Foreign Affairs in his statement said that on assuming his duties at the Ministry he found that "names were being changed like shirts", as he put it. "I instructed the Department of Records and Immigration to stop this phenomenon," he said. Although the legal opinion requested by the Ministry indicates that the Department of Population is not required to request information from the country of origin, Mr. Nouris explained that the Ministry's instructions now request information for name changes of foreigners to ensure that the same name change is made in the country of origin. He noted that a bill is being prepared to finalise this change, so that there is no person with two names.

Statements by MPs

DISY MP Savia Orphanidou said that the Auditor General's report on the much-discussed issue of naturalisations comes too late and refers to an audit from 2013 onwards and not from 2007 when the naturalisation programme started. "It has however been made clear that the Auditor General's claims of possible loss of revenue and cancellation of investments are not substantiated" and "this has been clarified by the Minister of Interior," he said, adding that the issue of VAT enforcement has been settled by an almost unanimous decision of Parliament in 2016.

In any case, he continued, "it is our clear position that even now, if any new evidence arises, it should be studied and used by the competent authorities." He also said that DISY's position is that "the investment programme supported the economy in difficult times" and added that "in the process, great efforts were made to review and shield it, but without avoiding serious mistakes and omissions, for which the Government has already assumed political responsibility". Orphanidou said that any attempt at political exploitation of the issue by the opposition parties would once again fall on deaf ears.

AKEL MP Irini Charalambidou said that much of the Interior Minister's argumentation was based, for the most part, on opinions of the Attorney General "which left grey areas, in many cases, for both the Interior Ministry and the Cabinet to handle various issues as they saw fit". "You cannot be a government minister, serve the Cabinet which approved the passports and then be the one to decide on the prosecution of those involved," he added. Referring to the conflict of interest issue, Charalambidou said the Michaelides report is "particularly important", "because we have a document before us that is documented, which we can read, analyse and focus on essential details, unlike the Nicolatos report, which was given to us with blacked-out pages."

"We demand accountability and practical action from the Ministry of Interior, it cannot be recorded in the report that 1.9 billion properties have had their transfer cancelled, nor that 3.9 billion properties have not yet been transferred," he added. On the VAT issue, he said that the Parliament passed a social welfare measure and under no circumstances could the subsequent opinion of the former Tax Commissioner that this measure could also be applied to investment projects be accepted.

MP Chrysis Pantelides said that in DIKO "we judged and judge that the Audit Service is the eminently competent and specialised institution to carry out this audit". He rejected the Interior Minister's comment that there is a link between the time of publication of the report and the presidential elections and noted that "if the Interior Ministry had given the files to the Audit Service in time, we would have had today's report much earlier".

During the meeting, he said, they had the opportunity to hear the Minister of Interior explain the position of his Ministry, which, he noted, along with the Ministry of Finance are the two Ministries involved and responsible for this issue. "We will continue the meeting in the coming weeks, precisely because we want to hear both the Ministry of Finance and all the relevant bodies," he added. Finally, he expressed concern that the Minister of Interior's statement indicated that "the Ministry of Interior does not seem to understand the problem that existed on this issue, they do not seem to understand the seriousness of the findings of the Audit Service, which makes us pessimistic about the willingness of the Ministry of Interior to improve practices, not only on this issue, but also on other issues, which led us to the phenomena we experienced on this issue."

The Parliamentary Representative of the DPA-Coalition of Democratic Forces, Alekos Tryfonidis, in a written statement, says that the competent authorities of the state such as the General Prosecutor's Office and the Anti-Corruption Authority, must examine the Report of the Auditor General and if any criminal offences arise from it, they must be attributed and brought to court. "The political responsibility that exists has been assumed by the Government and it is a matter for the Government to make any resignations, there have been substantial changes in the course of the programme which the Minister of Interior has analysed, but the essence remains the international report of our country," he notes.

At the same time, he says, there are serious issues that need to be answered because there is cancellation of property contracts worth 1 billion euros, 3.5 billion contracts of property that have not yet been transferred. "We are waiting for answers as to whether 200 million in VAT has indeed been lost for the reduced rate of property purchase. The reduced rate of 5% passed by Parliament in 2016 was a social policy of the Government for the acquisition of first homes and not for foreign investment," the MP concluded.

Stavros Papadouris, MP of the Ecologists-Civic Co-operation Movement, referring to the naturalisation programme, said that not only the revenues from VAT issues, taxes and so on were lost, but also revenues that the Republic of Cyprus would have had in the future, if the KEP had not been abolished.

He noted that in 2019, the then President of the Ecologist-Citizens' Movement had sent a letter to Odysseus Michaelides, asking him to launch an investigation into the issue of naturalisations. The fallacy of the Ministry of Interior, Papadouris said, "is that the well-known decision was taken to hide everything under the carpet, to take advantage of the programme for as long as it takes, to take advantage of whichever revenues the programme generates for as long as it lasts and we will see the consequences later."

He focused on the problem that the Attorney General and the Assistant Attorney General were members of the Cabinet during the period in question when the permits for the naturalizations were granted. He also expressed the position that responsibilities should be attributed and "it should not be another finding that will ultimately lead no one to jail."

Finally, the Member of Parliament for the Ecologist-Civic Coalition said that a letter is being prepared to the Director of the Land Registry, with notification to the Auditor General, requesting information on all cases of persons who applied for naturalization, those cases involving the assignment of rights to purchase and sell documents. "This is something that I believe has not been checked, perhaps not even by the Auditor General," Papadouris concluded.

In his statement, ELAM's Press Spokesman, Geadis Geadis, said that "it is patently obvious that there were mistakes, gaps and omissions, while incontestably some people took advantage of the so-called golden passports to write another black page of scandals and corruption." He added that "ELAM stands by its original position for a full investigation of the case from the start of the naturalisation programme in 2007 until today, demanding exemplary punishments."

Source: CNA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top