What's new

[Cyprus Times] Greece buys corvettes from the Italians and tanks from the Germans

ScreenHunter-11486.jpg

The process of selecting the corvettes with which the Navy will be equipped for the surveillance of the Greek maritime space in the Aegean Sea and the safeguarding of Greek sovereignty up to the outermost point of the island territory is entering the final stretch.

Following the final evaluation of the candidate warships by the Navy and the Prime Minister's briefing, the Italian Doha corvettes are reportedly in the lead, with the French corvettes in second place and the Dutch corvettes following.

Defense Ministry officials with insight into the technical specifications of each proposal explain that the Italian corvettes have better value for money and, in addition, the Italian manufacturers are committed to delivering very quickly two of the four ships Athens will order. In parallel, the modernisation programme for about two-thirds of the 350 Leopard 1A5 and Leopard 2A4 tanks in the Land Army's force has "matured", a programme that the German manufacturers are expected to undertake.

The contracts for both the corvettes and the tanks will be finalized through a Government to Government agreement between Athens and Rome and between Athens and Berlin, as seems to have already been discussed between the Greek and German governments at the highest level by Kyriakos Mitsotakis and Wolfgang Scholz. The corvettes offered by Italy, France and the Netherlands are the three final options being considered by the Greek government, according to the assessment made by the Navy leadership and the Hellenic Navy's General Staff.

The admirals of the Supreme Naval Council scrutinized all proposals and made the final list which includes the Italian corvettes FCX-30/Doha, the French Gowind and the Dutch Sigma 10514. As the military explained to Mitsotakis, all three proposals fully meet the Navy's requirements. "We are waiting for the offer that will make the difference," a senior source at the Ministry of National Defence told THEMA, explaining that until the announcement of the final decision the French, Italians and Dutch have to improve the financial offers of the contract to buy four corvettes at an estimated total cost of 2 billion euros.

The winner of the race for the four corvettes, three of which will have to be built in Greek shipyards, has a few weeks to finalise the details of the financial part of the contract and submit a more competitive proposal than the two rival candidates for the Greek fleet. The final decision is expected to be taken by the leadership of the Greek government even in September, with the aim to have the contract completed by the end of 2022 and the programme to be activated in early 2023 with the disbursement of the advances.

For a 2 billion euro programme. euros, which will provide four powerful ships to serve the Navy for a period of 40 years, it is obvious that in addition to the critical operational criteria met by both the French and Italian corvettes, political and diplomatic balances are of great importance, as well as the financial aspect of the purchase, which will burden taxpayers and the Budget for the next 10 years. Even political changes, such as the possible departure of Mario Draghi as Prime Minister of Italy, are likely to affect the outcome of the corvette programme. It is common knowledge that Mr Draghi, who has a good interpersonal relationship with Mr Mitsotakis, has systematically lobbied for the Doha corvettes by defending the interests of Italian shipyards.

The German Leopard tanks



No one also forgets the fact that the signing of the contract to buy 3+1 Belh@rra frigates with France came after Emmanuel Macron persuaded the state-controlled Naval Group to dramatically improve its financial offer to Athens. All three candidate corvettes, Gowind, Doha and Sigma 10514, are in production line, so the military leadership knows with certainty that they function as shipboard and integrated naval weapon systems, having overcome the so-called "teething troubles" that usually present themselves in any prototype weapon system that is tested in the extreme conditions it will be called upon to operate and in the field. Operationally they are considered roughly equal, but each of the three proposals for the corvettes with which the Greek Navy will be equipped has strong advantages.

The Dutch ones carry the unshakeable reputation of the "Elli" type S frigates, which have been the backbone of the Greek Navy since the 1980s; the Italian ones are a ship with considerable development potential and are superior in terms of value for money, while for the French ones an important asset is the common support line with the three FDI or Belh@rra frigates, with the construction of the first of the three ordered by Greece having started at the shipyards of Lorian in France. The Navy will continue parallel consultations with the three companies representing the Italian, French and Dutch corvettes, with the objective of improving the terms of the offered contract.

The "Greek shipyards" equation

The Greek government has imposed an absolute condition on the potential sellers that three of the four corvettes to be ordered must be built in Greek shipyards. Simply put, the issue of the choice of corvette is directly linked to the fate of the shipyards in Elefsina and Skaramanga. The Italians are interested in acquiring the Elefsina shipyards in order to strengthen their bid for the Doha corvettes. Shipowner Giorgos Prokopiou, who is acquiring Skaramagas Shipyards, says he is available to work with any foreign consortium to build the Navy's new corvettes. Obviously, in order to complete the project of building the three corvettes in Greece, in whichever yard it is decided to build French, Italian or Dutch corvettes, investments of several tens of millions of euros will have to be made.

The upgrade of the MEKO frigates

For almost a decade, the respective naval leaders have been trying to convince their political superiors to approve the funds for the modernization of the four German "Hydra" frigates, 'Spetses', 'Psara' and 'Salamis', but the financial staff always stopped the discussions, citing the lack of funds and the Memoranda of Understanding. Since the summer of 2020 and the near-war between Greece and Turkey over the seismic surveys of the Turkish ship "Oruc Reis" in Kastelorizo, the project has matured and is now in the final stretch for its implementation.

At last week's meeting at the Prime Minister's office, senior military officers of the General Staff and the General Staff also informed Mitsotakis about the discussions with the candidates to undertake the modernization of the MEKO frigates. This is a project with a ceiling of €500 million, which is no mean feat for the foreign company that will undertake it. The upgrade of the four frigates is critical for the Navy, since after the integration of the three new Belh@rra frigates in 2028, the Dutch S-type frigates on which the fleet's firepower has been based for decades are expected to be gradually decommissioned. The upgrade of the German MEKOs is imperative and the Ministry of Defence wants to avoid a possible risk or a repetition of past mistakes.

The Italian Doha

The German consortium of KMS and the Dutch Thales Netherlands, which has a clear advantage as the group that built the ships in question, has a clear advantage to take on the modernization of the four frigates. The Americans, who have also submitted a proposal for the modernisation of the German frigates, are asking for an amount that exceeds the Navy's budget by at least €200 million and will also rely heavily on German builders. The MEKO upgrade programme is expected to be awarded to the Germans, but the work is far from easy to start before another 12 months have passed, as a detailed dialogue is needed to accurately define the modernisation and contracting.

Helicopters and torpedoes

After the Air Force, the Navy will be significantly strengthened with the three French FDI frigates scheduled to be delivered by the end of 2026 with the construction of four corvettes and the modernisation of four MEKOs. But these are not the only major projects, as the purchase of seven US Romeo anti-submarine helicopters is also underway, with deliveries expected in 2023 (the first three), 2024 (the next three) and 2025 (the seventh and final one).

The Germans have been commissioned to build new heavy-duty torpedoes for the four "Papanikolis" submarines that proved their invaluable value in the summer of 2020. These Type 214 submarines are a global best seller, even leading Turkey to acquire six similar to the "Papanikolis", except that their electronics will be "made in Turkiye", with all that this may entail. Of course, not everything is perfect, nor is everything being implemented at a rapid pace. The P-3B naval cooperation aircraft programme still has a long way to go. The first of the four naval cooperation aircraft is scheduled to be delivered in 2024 - almost a decade since Alexis Tsipras and Panos Kammenos secretly signed the contract - and the expectation is that the last one will be received by the Navy sometime in 2027...

And modernization of tanks

After a voluntary more than a decade-long "disarmament" of the Armed Forces due to the economic crisis, the Land Army is the last of the three Armed Forces where decisions on major armament projects are expected. The preparation that has long been going on in the Directorate General of Defence Equipment and Investment is to modernise a number of German Leopard tanks. Of the approximately 350 Leopard 1A5 and Leopard 2A4 tanks in the Armoured Division's force, a sufficient number, about 2/3 of the total, are expected to be modernised at a cost of about €800 million.

The agreement is expected to be a transnational one, between Greece and Germany, which offers guarantees and assurance of good execution of the complex programme. The upgrade will not only include the tanks' thermal periscope, but also their electronic systems and armouring, a senior source at the Ministry of National Defence tells THEMA, explaining that the budget for the programme will reach close to 1 billion euros. The last 170 and newest Leopard 2HEL tanks acquired in 2003 under the ministry of Giannos Papantoniou had cost the state 1.7 billion euros.

The war in Ukraine, apart from thousands of dead, refugees, disasters and a global economic, energy and food crisis, for the military provided a number of lessons in the "art of war". The fact that very expensive tanks, worth 10-15 million euros each, were dismantled by lethal sub-millimetal missiles with a maximum value of 200,000 euros has left no one indifferent, including at the General Staff of the Army, where the relevant investigation has been completed and surprising decisions are expected.

Source: protothema.gr


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top