Chinese spies watching Europe Alarm in the West Chinese agents have evolved and almost surpassed the Russians
It was like an episode of the TV spy thriller "The Bureau". A senior French intelligence officer, known as Henri M, is posted to Beijing, where he falls in love with the ambassador's interpreter and begins passing secret information to the enemy.
Immediately recalled to France, he is tried in 2020 and sentenced to eight years in prison for "detrimental transmission of information" to a foreign power - even though the offence was committed two decades earlier.
Another agent, known as Pierre-Marie H, continued to spy for China until his arrest in 2017, when he was sentenced in the same trial to 12 years in prison.
On par with the Russian agents
The heavy sentences handed down to the agents and France's decision to highlight their activity during the trial reflect growing European concern that China's spying operations are expanding and pose a greater threat than those of Russia, the West's traditional adversary, a Financial Times article noted.
"Chinese secret agents are on the same level as the Russians," said a former station chief of the US CIA's intelligence service in Europe. "China's best operations are now as good as Russia's best," a current Western intelligence official confirmed. Some of them are "extraordinary ... for their patience," another added."
China is already recognized for advanced cyberattacks, such as the 2021 Microsoft hack that resulted in 30 hacks.000 organisations worldwide, which the US, EU and Britain said was carried out by criminal groups working at Beijing's behest.
China has denied the allegations, calling them "baseless and irresponsible."
China has denied the claims, calling them "baseless and irresponsible.
Alarm in the West
However, its skills in extracting information from humans (human intelligence or "humint") have reached a level of sophistication commonly associated with Russian espionage, according to eight current and former Western intelligence officials, raising a sense of alarm in the West.
"The Russians have been into espionage since the time of the tsar (before the Soviet Union), they just love it," said Alex Younger, former head of MI6, Britain's secret intelligence agency. "Traditionally, the Chinese have a significantly weaker humint, but they are leaps and bounds up the learning curve."
The increase in covert activity by China's ruling Communist Party was described as a "game-changing" challenge by Ken McCallum, head of Britain's domestic intelligence agency MI5, and Christopher Wray, director of the FBI, at a joint conference in London in July.
"We are not being alarmist," McCallum said, and his warning rang louder as it came amid Russia's attack on Ukraine, the biggest threat to European security in a generation.
With China's spying techniques very different from Russia's, Western agencies need to reshape their approach to intelligence.
Christine Lee, a lawyer and British citizen, was named this year by MI5 in an unusual public warning that she was an "agent of influence" for China, even though her perceived transgressions on behalf of Beijing were not criminal.
Wider Chinese spying targets than Russian
"Chinese espionage is not even a variant of the Russian (approach)," the second intelligence official said. "It can be difficult to even agree on what a Chinese agent means."
Officials said Russia's overseas operations still typically rely on a tradition of elite officers trained in high-level espionage techniques, such as coded communications, to achieve a specific security objective.
China, however, has broader goals, ranging from political influence to obtaining commercial or technological secrets.
"Russian espionage tends to be narrowly focused, while China uses a 'whole of society' approach," said a third intelligence officer.
He cited China's 2017 intelligence law, which requires "all organizations and citizens to support, assist and cooperate with national intelligence efforts."
Russian espionage also tends to be high-risk, even "violent," a fourth official said, citing the attempted poisoning of Russian double agent Sergei Skripal in England in 2018.
More... diplomatic Chinese
"The Russians can be shoddy, quite arrogant and sometimes seem to have a 'catch me if you can' mentality, (on the other hand) the Chinese prefer to avoid any kind of spying scandal because they want to maintain good bilateral relations," the former CIA officer added.
The difference in style between the two countries is captured in a saying often quoted by Western officials. If we imagine intelligence targets as grains of sand, Russian agents would surface a submarine at night and send a small detachment to the beach to bring back a bucket of sand, while the Chinese would send thousands of people swimming in broad daylight to bring back the maximum load with just one grain each.
The result, according to Nicholas Eftimiades, a former CIA officer specializing in China, is "a new example of the path intelligence activities are taking."
Such tactics can lead to ineffective and uncoordinated spying, Western officials said, with several Chinese officers sometimes approaching the same target. Even so, they are often effective."
FBI: "The scope of China's efforts is breathtaking."
According to a U.S. estimate, Chinese commercial espionage stole up to $600 billion of U.S. intellectual property each year. China has denied the claims.
The EU has estimated that total IP theft costs it €50 billion in sales each year, with a loss of 671,000 jobs.
"Efficiency is more important to China's security services than effectiveness," said Nigel Inkster, former director of operations at MI6 and now a senior adviser at the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS).
An additional challenge, officials said, is to find out who the Chinese spy is without resorting to profiling potential suspects based on racial characteristics.
Again, the difference with Russia is striking. European capitals have expelled more than 600 Russian diplomats and alleged spies since Moscow launched its invasion of Ukraine.
However, "a similar situation with Beijing would be more difficult," Inkster said, as the relationship between the Chinese state and its actors can be delicate and fluid.
Some intelligence officials also believe the "grains of sand" analogy is misleading because it conceals China's more recent and sophisticated work.
Whatever the approach, Western agencies are struggling to cope with the volume of cases. The FBI said it opens a new investigation into Chinese espionage every 12 hours, while MI5's case load has increased sevenfold since 2018.
Wray, head of the FBI, said: "The scale of China's efforts is breathtaking."
Source: in.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source