What's new

[Cyprus Times] EU headache over seizure of Russian assets

european-union-600x411-1.jpg

The US Treasury Department said that at the end of June Western allies had frozen or blocked over $30 billion worth of Russian assets. While many in the EU say the seizure is politically and morally desirable, they worry it is illegal and would leave the bloc exposed to lawsuits

The European Union is looking for a way to seize Russian assets frozen by sanctions, from Moscow's war against Ukraine to use in the post-war reconstruction of the former Soviet republic that wants to be integrated into Western democracies.

Although many in the EU say the seizure is politically and morally desirable, they are concerned that it is illegal and would leave the bloc exposed to lawsuits it could lose in its own courts.

The EU has sanctioned more than 1,200 individuals and 100 entities on the grounds that they have destabilized Ukraine since Russia seceded Crimea in 2014. Following Russia's invasion of Ukraine on February 24, the EU blacklisted President Vladimir Putin, Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov and oligarchs, among others.

They are now banned from visiting the EU and their assets located within the bloc are frozen but not seized for sale, which in most countries requires a criminal conviction to do.

The US Treasury Department said that at the end of June Western allies had frozen or blocked Russian assets worth more than $30 billion.

The European Commission said €13.9 billion of Russian oligarchs' assets had been blocked in the EU.

But that may be only a small percentage of the blacklisted individuals' foreign wealth. Although there are no exact figures, Anders Aslund, a Swedish economist who has advised the Russian government in the past, estimates that all the assets outside Russia of the blacklisted individuals may be worth about $400 billion. It is not clear how much of that might be in Europe and how much in the US and therefore how much could be frozen or seized.



Beyond that, there are about $300-400 billion of Russian Central Bank assets in the West, of which France has reported freezing around €23 billion.

These assets could be used for Ukraine's reconstruction needs, as the country's Deputy Prime Minister estimated that it would take $700 billion just to rebuild the damaged infrastructure.

Western states first need to seize assets, which in most EU countries requires a court conviction for a criminal offence to take place.

To make this possible, the European Commission wants to expand the list of crimes recognised across the EU to include circumventing or attempting to circumvent sanctions. That plan could be adopted in the fall, but it will take time before it is implemented in all 27 member states.

In its latest sanctions package last week, theEU emphasized the need for sanctioned individuals to declare their assets for freezing in an effort to make it easier for state officials to act.

The bloc is also looking at ways of seizure without conviction, although there is little experience of this in the US, Canada, Italy and Ireland.

With property rights enshrined in the European Charter of Fundamental Rights, the bloc's top judicial official, Commissioner Didier Raiders, has been cautious.

In my view, confiscation should still be the result of a criminal conviction, he told Reuters last week.

The last thing I want is for the EU to rush into decisions and then see negative decisions coming from Luxembourg or Strasbourg, he said, referring to the EU Court of Justice (CJEU) and the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR).

The CJEU has received about 150 challenges related to EU sanctions over the unrest in Ukraine since 2014, of which about 70 are still ongoing, the court's press office said. Of these, about 50 EU decisions have been annulled, at least in part, it said.

This, however, has occasionally had little practical effect, as was the case with Ukraine's former pro-Russian President Viktor Yanukovych. He had been sanctioned for another year under a new official ruling, and had repeatedly benefited from previous such rulings.

This is, however, an important warning for those considering using frozen Russian assets to rebuild Ukraine.

Should confiscation prove impossible for legal or practical reasons, Raiders said the West could keep Russia's assets frozen as long as Moscow does not agree to help rebuild Ukraine as part of any peace talks.

The goal is not confiscation for the sake of confiscation. Rather, the goal is to ensure Russia's participation in Ukraine's reconstruction, as it is Russia's invasion that created the need, Raiders said.

Source: CNA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source
 
Back
Top