What's new

[Cyprus Times] Erdogan gives Istanbul a makeover and the result is controversial

kwnstantinoupolicover.jpg
[/ATTACH]
The controversial makeover has victims or beneficiaries. Depending on who you ask
When the Atatürk Cultural Center (AKM), originally known as the Palace of Culture, opened in 1969, everyone was talking about it.

On the edge of Taksim Square, in the heart of Istanbul's entertainment district, the building was considered a temple to modernism and the man for whom it was named: Kemal Atatürk.

But in the late 1970s, part of the AKM burned down. After years of neglect, the building was demolished by order of Tayyip Erdogan. Many feared the worst when the Turkish president pledged to build a "baroque" opera house in its place.

So somehow they breathed a sigh of relief when the new $200 million center opened last year. From the outside, the building looks less like a tribute to its predecessor and more like an oversized replica (designed by the son of the architect who created the previous building). What makes it stand out is a 2,000-seat opera hall housed inside a huge sphere in the atrium; its outer shell, covered with thousands of purple ceramic tiles, shines like the sun setting over Taksim. The space surrounding it includes a theatre, a gallery, a cinema and a large number of cafes.

Modern Turkey, the state that Atatürk rescued from the ruins of the Ottoman Empire, celebrates its 100th anniversary in 2023. As the Economist points out, in order to set the stage for the celebrations, Erdogan has offered a makeover to the country's largest city, the ancient homeland of the Ottomans (and the Byzantines before that). Yet the transformation he has created has less to do with a tribute to the legacy of Istanbul or Atatürk and more to do with a consolidation of his own.

Erdogan sees himself as the founder of a "New Turkey", a more confident, more independent and more religious incarnation of the country he was elected to rule two decades ago. The term "New Turkey" means restoring the country to the position of supremacy that he believes it is its destiny to occupy. Erdogan used architecture to get everyone else to buy into this idea. He has already led several construction projects: a new $11 billion airport on the outskirts of Istanbul, which he hopes will become the largest in the world. The largest mosque in the country ($100 million), on the Asian coast of the city. And a 1,100-room palace in Ankara ($615 million), in which he resides. His most recent project is a second Bosphorus - a 45-kilometer canal connecting the Black Sea to the Sea of Marmara and turning much of Istanbul into an island.

His mark was also left on the center of Istanbul and particularly on Taksim Square. Over the past century, successive governments and other political forces have fought over Taksim in an attempt to reshape it and claim it as their own space. Erdogan did this by building a huge mosque across the street from the AKM, fulfilling a promise he made when he was mayor of Istanbul in the 1990s. A strip of concrete stretches between the two buildings and spills out to the edge of Gezi Park, the centre of the mass protests that rocked Turkey a decade ago. The park, which Erdogan wanted to replace with a replica of the Ottoman army barracks and a shopping mall, still survives. But the area surrounding it, which seems designed for pedestrians, now looks more suited for a military parade than a leisurely stroll.

Coming down the hill from Taksim, a $1.7 billion redevelopment project called Galataport has transformed the neglected port area into an upscale shopping mall and cruise ship terminal. One of the victims of the development (or beneficiaries; it depends who you ask) is the Istanbul Museum of Modern Art. The Istanbul Modern's old roof, which was used as a warehouse, was demolished. The new building, designed by architect Renzo Piano to look like stacks of shipping containers, was expected to open in time for this year's Istanbul Biennial, an art exhibition that opened on September 17. Work is still underway.



The protests at Gezi Park in 2013 began in an attempt to put a brake on the controversial projects Erdogan was preparing for the city. The protests were put down with violence. Istanbul's 'contested urban public spaces' - which were paradoxically the theme of this year's biennial - are no longer contested: 10 years later, Erdogan's vision has won.

Dozens of buildings have gone up and dozens have come down, with absolutely no public consultation and no reflection on local communities, explains Murat Guvents, head of the Istanbul Studies Center at Kadir Has University. Some say opportunities were lost. Galataport could be one of the most important and inclusive public spaces in the city, argues urban planner Yasar Adnan Antanali. "Instead they built a private cruise port and another shopping mall."

The Review

Istanbul is not aging nicely. Since 2000, its population has skyrocketed from 11 million to nearly 16 million. The city may still charm tourists. On a sunny day, Hagia Sophia and the Blue Mosque, framed by the slopes of Mount Uludag and the shimmering Sea of Marmara, still captivate. For residents, however, Istanbul has become a permanent construction site choked with traffic - it is less the city of desires and more the city of two hours on the streets.

This year the Economist Intelligence Unit, sister company of The Economist, placed Istanbul at the bottom of its list of the most liveable cities in Europe. In a separate survey of the world's greenest cities, it ranked last in a separate survey of the world's greenest cities. Erdogan's projects are not the only culprit for this - indeed some projects, such as the new AKM, are welcome.

But what Istanbul needs, far more than shopping malls and giant mosques, is some breathing room.

Source: In.gr/Eri Sfaelu


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source
 
Back
Top