What's new

[Cyprus Times] England: new scandal in maternity hospitals. "Culture of denial" by doctors-nurses killed dozens of babies

vrefos.jpg

If there had been adequate care, "of 65 infant deaths, 45 could have been avoided," concludes investigation of two large Kent maternity hospitals Expert report reveals scope of problem

Dozens of newborns ended up dead, because they did not receive adequate care, a "culture of denial" in maternity hospitals and indifference to the concerns of new mothers: A new scandal, the second since the beginning of the year in England, reveals inefficiencies in some UK maternity hospitals.

Seven months after the investigation into hospitals in the west of England was made public, Dr Bill Kirkup and other experts presented their findings on the cases of 202 people - mothers or babies born between 2009 and 2020 - at two large maternity hospitals in Kent, in south-east England.

Of the 65 infant deaths, 45 could have been avoided.

"What happened in east Kent is sad and painful," Kirkup said at his press conference. "Deaths, injuries and other harms could have had a different outcome, if care had been given based on national standards," he added."

The investigation was launched after the death in November 2017 of Harry Richford, seven days after he was born by caesarean section. A death that, according to experts, was caused by a series of "weaknesses" in the system: from the way the "inexperienced" doctor performed the delivery, to the delay in the baby's cardiopulmonary resuscitation.

Of the 17 cases of brain injury, 12 would not have occurred if proper treatment had been given. 23 maternal deaths or injuries would also have been avoided, out of a total of 32.

Bill Kirkup condemned what he called the "culture of denial" in public hospitals. An issue raised repeatedly by many of the victims: the failure of hospital staff to take mothers into account when they voiced their concerns, when they questioned their treatments and the decisions being made for them.



Experts found "glaring weaknesses in teamwork" in maternity hospitals, a "lack of mutual trust", the "huge egos" of some midwives and the "cliquey behaviour" of some midwives.

Jeremy Hunt, the new Chancellor of the Exchequer who was health secretary between 2012-18, called it a "horrific scandal" on Twitter, thanking Bill Kirkup for this "new report."

This is the second inquiry whose findings have been made public. The previous one, in March, concerned maternity hospitals in the west of England and the then Boris Johnson government was forced to apologise for what was alleged. According to that first report, more than 200 infant deaths would have been avoided over 20 years if it had not been for doctors' persistent refusal to perform caesareans and if proper treatments had been given.

Donna Ockenden, who conducted the first inquiry, undertook another in May, this time in the Nottingham area of central England, following complaints from many families.

In 2015 an inquiry into maternity hospitals in the north of England was published which also concluded that many baby deaths could have been avoided. Bill Kirkup was also its author at the time. "When I was writing that report (...) I never imagined for a minute that I would be here again seven years later (...) to talk about the same subject," he said. "This cannot go on (...) We simply cannot pretend that this was the last time this happened," he added."

Tracy Fletcher, the head of the hospital group targeted in the investigation, apologised, as did Health Minister Caroline Johnson.

"I will never be able to forgive," reacted Bex Walton, whose son, Tommy, died in 2020, to the BBC."What they are doing now is not enough because my son will never be with me again,"

Source: Cyprus Times


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top