Geopolitical chaos and Elon Musk in the middle - His (clueless) involvement in three hot issues
Over the past four weeks, Elon Musk has presented a... peace plan for Russia and Ukraine that infuriated Ukrainian officials. A Twitter post about internet access in Iran left anti-government protesters vulnerable to online attacks. In addition, he argued in a newspaper interview that China could be satisfied if given partial control of Taiwan. A Taipei official demanded a retraction.
In recent months, Musk has emerged as a new, chaotic player in the realm of international politics. As the Times points out, while there is generally no shortage of billionaires who feel the need to tweet their opinions on international issues, no one can match Musk's influence as well as his ability to cause turmoil. He has sometimes taken positions on situations from which he was warned it was best to refrain and has already left many confusing situations behind him.
Geopolitical chaos and in the middle... Elon Musk
Although most of Musk's wealth comes from his shares in Tesla, the electric vehicle manufacturer, most of his influence comes from his aerospace technology company Space X, which operates the Starlink satellite network. Starlink can provide internet access in war zones and other troubled areas, making it an essential tool for the Ukrainian military.
Musk's influence will increase further should the Twitter takeover be completed on Friday, as he has promised. He has called himself an "authoritarian of free speech" and all the signs are that he will pursue a loose strategy in controlling the platform's content.
His critics - who are numerous - worry that Musk's views are not easy to separate from his business interests, especially when it comes to Tesla, which is steadily increasing its dependence on China.
"Technology has become central to geopolitics," Karen Kornblah, director at the German Marshall Fund, a geopolitical think tank, and a former adviser to then US president Barack Obama, tells the Times. "It's fascinating and complicated, and in the middle of it all is Elon Musk."
Positive moves and dangerous messages
In some cases, Musk has acted positively, the Times reports. When he provided internet access to Ukrainians through Starlink earlier this year, funding - at least in part - both the hardware and the operation of the service, he provided both civilians and soldiers with a critical means of communication during the conflict with Russia.
But his messages have also caused problems. Last week, he tweeted that he would not fund Ukraine's use of Starlink "indefinitely" before doing a 180.
Late last month, Musk attended a private event in Aspen called The Weekend. The event, hosted by, among others, former Google CEO and government adviser Eric Schmidt, was a meeting point for US political and business leaders, including US House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, former Vice President Al Gore and former chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff Joseph Dunford.
Peacemaking between peat and pear[/B][BR][/B] At lunchtime, under a gazebo on the golf course, Musk engaged in a heated discussion with billionaire businessman David Rubenstein, according to two people at the event who spoke to the Times on condition of anonymity.
At the end of the discussion, many were surprised to hear Musk propose a peace plan for the war in Ukraine that would allow Russia to annex Ukrainian territory and which seemed to align closely with the Kremlin's wishes.
The idea angered much of the event's attendees, according to the Times sources. The next day, Jake Sullivan, national security adviser to U.S. President Joe Biden, refrained from commenting on Musk's remarks at the event, according to a spokesman for the National Security Council. However, Musk revealed his plan on Twitter ten days later. The Kremlin welcomed the idea.
Ukraine's president, Volodymyr Zhelensky, and his staff vehemently rejected Musk's plan. But his shift has brought them to a standstill: Starlink is a critical means of communication for the Ukrainian military.
"Geofences" on Starlink?[BR]
In mid-September, as the Ukrainian military advanced into the southern provinces once occupied by Russia, it lost access to Starlink in some places near the front line, according to four people with knowledge of the matter who spoke to The Times. Two of them claimed that this is because Musk has created "geo-fences" for the service so that it is only available in certain areas. It is not clear the actual reasons why the satellite system did not work, while others told the Times that it was working normally.
Musk has discussed the issue with both the Ukrainian military and the U.S. government to determine which locations the Ukrainian military can access Starlink, according to Times sources. A spokesman for the National Security Council said the council, the U.S. Treasury Department's Office of Foreign Affairs and "officials from across the spectrum of the U.S. government have discussed with Starlink and have answered questions about U.S. policy, as we do with all other companies."
Truths, lies and untrustworthiness[/B][BR][/B] During the month, Musk caused even more uncertainty for Ukrainians when he warned that he would not continue to pay for the country to have access to Starlink, giving the impression that he was currently covering the costs himself. In fact, the Times points out, the US, Britain and Poland have shouldered at least part of Starlik's operating costs, according to a document outlining the costs available to the US newspaper.
"It must decide whether Starlink is a commercial service that sometimes provides its customers with life-saving technology or whether it is a service that depends on the geopolitical interests of its administration and is therefore unreliable to customers concerned about their national security."
"It must decide whether Starlink is a commercial service that sometimes provides its customers with life-saving technology or whether it is a service that depends on the geopolitical interests of its administration and is therefore unreliable to customers concerned about their national security. "I am activating Starlink," he tweeted, just as the US government moved to lift some sanctions restricting US technology companies from operating in Iran, with the aim of allowing the latter to support the protesters.
Starlink could allow Iranians to overcome the government blockade on land-based internet connections, bringing many Iranian cities back online.
But as Iranians would soon learn, Musk's promise would not be fulfilled. What the billionaire didn't say was what had to go into making Starlink operational, how long it would take, and why restrictions imposed by the Iranian government made it nearly impossible to offer the service widely within Iranian territory.
Despite the fact that Starlink was still unavailable in Iran, hackers believed to be linked to the government launched a campaign of online deception, posting messages on social media with links claiming to provide access to the satellite network, according to Amir Rashidi, an Iranian digital rights expert. Instead of offering access to Musk's network, the links installed malware that harvested information from users' mobile phones, Rashidi explains to the Times, having analyzed at least five versions of the malware.
"A guy" who doesn't understand the consequences
Now, there is little room to access Starlink from Iranian territory using equipment smuggled across its borders, the expert continues. This raises further concerns about the possibility of authorities being able to identify data transmitted through it, as the satellite signals may be detectable by people on the ground.
Rashidi, who fled Iran in 2009, congratulated Musk on his efforts to help, but said his tactics were "completely irresponsible."
"He's just a guy who wants to jump in and say he's doing something good without understanding what the consequences could be," he said.
Something's up with China
Recently, Musk has also gotten involved in possibly the hottest geopolitical issue on the planet: Taiwan.
Tensions between China and Taiwan pose a huge threat to Musk's business empire. Tesla has a facility in Shanghai, where up to 50% of all its new vehicles are produced. The Beijing government tightly controls the operation of Western businesses in the country, and observers have long expressed anxieties about how his reliance on China could affect Musk's political views.
During the month, he confirmed that he is under pressure from Beijing, telling the Financial Times that the Chinese government has made it clear to him that it does not view positively the provision of the Starlink satellite service in Ukraine. Beijing has sought assurances, Musk admitted, that it had no intention of offering the service to China.
Anger in Taiwan[BR] He then set out his proposal for easing tensions: handing over some of Taiwan's control to China.
His comment, in stark contrast to the policy of the United States and its allies, drew the ire of Taiwanese politicians.
In a telephone interview with the New York Times, Chao Tien-Lin, a Democratic Progressive Party member of Taiwan's parliamentary international affairs committee, called on Musk to recant. "If he does not, I would sincerely advise not only Taiwan but also the citizens of all liberal democratic states to boycott Tesla and all products related to it."
Some have pointed out that in the event of a military conflict between the two states, the Taiwanese, like the Ukrainians, might ask Musk for access to emergency communications via satellite internet. But given Musk's attitude to the situation and his connection to China, this may be out of the question.
Source: in.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source