Europe's energy crisis is turning into an economic one Two ways to avoid it
The Economist assesses the picture of Europe's energy crisis so far and sets out the ways in which it might not turn into an economic one.
As disruptions to Russian gas, French nuclear power and Norwegian hydropower wreak havoc on Europe's energy markets, prices are approaching surreal levels.Benchmark gas prices rose 30% last week.
Last summer, electricity contracts in France and Germany for the coming year were hovering around 100 euros per megawatt-hour, and recently rose above 1,000 euros.
Since then, prices have fallen, but gas still hovers around $400 per barrel of oil. Shell's boss has warned that the crisis will last more than a winter.
The burden on citizens will be heavy and extended as existing household and business energy contracts expire and new ones are taken out. This will intensify pressure on the economy as the European Central Bank raises interest rates to fight inflation.
Many economists predict a recession in the coming months and the single currency is flirting with its lowest level in two decades against the dollar. The prospect of turmoil and bickering among member states appears to be on the rise.
Commission's response to the energy crisis
So far, the European Commission's response has been less than ambitious. Its latest proposal is to cap the price of gas used to generate electricity, a possibility that will be discussed at the summit of European energy ministers on 9 September.
The commission may also seek to overhaul the electricity market so that spot prices are no longer determined by the marginal cost of each producer, many of whom often use gas.
A price cap sounds right, but it could be counterproductive. This is because caps will not curb demand for the - now expensive - energy.
According to one study, the cap implemented in Spain has led to a 42% increase in gas-fired generation since June. A comprehensive EU-wide policy would increase demand for gas even further, increasing the chances of it being rationed in winter.
It is true that the current set-up allows some renewable energy companies, which produce at almost zero marginal cost, to make a profit. If gas prices remained high for years, such windfall profits could be called unjustified. But this same price system ensures that gas-fired plants produce energy when wind turbines are not operating and provides incentives for more investment in renewables.
The two priorities that Europe's governments should focus on
So instead of "fighting" with each other, governments should focus on two bigger issues. The first is to allow the market mechanism to constrain demand while supporting the most vulnerable. It will need a lot of support, but targeted help can contain costs.
According to the IMF, policies that offer discounts and cash transfers to the poorest 40 per cent of people would be cheaper than the current policy mix, which largely involves tax cuts on fuel or caps on retail prices.
The second priority is to increase supply, which is not just up to Vladimir Putin. Other sources of gas can be found: this is one reason why French President Emmanuel Macron visited Algeria.
Within Europe, countries can help "alleviate" bottlenecks, such as inadequate cross-border gas interconnections.
Today, insufficient investment and differences in standards block the flow from Spain and France to Germany and Eastern Europe. The EU must ensure that in the case of rationing, there is a continent-wide agreement on which users are cut off first: without this, the risk of a build-up of supplies from specific countries is real.
All this will cost money. So far, Greece, Italy and Spain, among the most indebted eurozone members, have spent 2%-4% of their GDP on fiscal support to mitigate the energy shock. Fortunately, the EU has the power to help.
The €807 billion pandemic recovery fund is being administered in the form of loans and grants. However, so far less than 15% of the amount has been disbursed. Payments for energy projects could be accelerated and the Commission could offer cheap loans to help finance targeted budget support.
The EU has been working together to deal with the financial consequences of the pandemic lockdown. Make no mistake: the energy crisis requires a similarly bold response.
Source: iefimerida.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source