What's new

[Cyprus Times] ECHR: "Yes" to possession of pornographic material in prisons, not a misdemeanour

fulaki.jpg

The ECHR ruled that the possession of pornographic material by a prisoner is not a misdemeanour, as it has a soothing effect on and is a stimulus for self-satisfaction

The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has condemned Slovakia and ordered it to pay a detained lifer the sum of 2.600 euros for moral damages, as he was disciplined for possession of pornographic material.

The possession of pornographic material by a prisoner in prison is not a disciplinary offence and if a disciplinary penalty is imposed, on the one hand, his privacy is infringed and, on the other hand, the possession of such material has a soothing and positive impact on the prisoner, as it is a stimulus for self-gratification.

On this basis, the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) condemned Slovakia and ordered it to pay a detained lifer the sum of 2.600 euros for non-material damage suffered as a result of the violation of his right to privacy, protected by Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

A 33-year-old prisoner is serving a life sentence for the crime of manslaughter. Following a routine search of the prison, a popular weekly magazine was found in his possession, inside which photographs with obscene content had been pasted.

The material was found by the competent authorities to be pornographic and therefore "morally offensive within the meaning of the Law on the Execution of Prison Sentences". It was thus confiscated and disciplinary proceedings were initiated against the prisoner.

Finally, the competent Slovak authorities found him guilty of a disciplinary offence and imposed a reprimand. However, the prisoner appealed against the disciplinary decision, but his appeal was dismissed on the grounds that the material in question was prohibited and its possession was illegal.

He then appealed to the ECtHR, claiming that the photographs had been cut from adult magazines freely available on the press distribution network in Slovakia and the Czech Republic and that they depicted "classic" heterosexual sex.



The lifer claimed that the photographs depicted heterosexual sexual intercourse and that it was in keeping with his masculine nature. Furthermore, he stated that the photographs were intended for his own use, had been pasted into a magazine he owned and were part of his private life.

At the same time, he claimed that they had a soothing and positive impact on him, especially as he was excluded from social life and, being heterosexually oriented, was discriminated against.

Now, the ECtHR underlines that "as imprisonment entailed the complete exclusion of close contact with the opposite sex, the Constitutional Court had recognised that pornography could serve as a stimulus for self-gratification" and adds: "The material had been kept in the applicant's private sphere and was intended exclusively for individual and private use within that sphere, in particular in his cell in which he was alone."

Finally, the ECtHR held that "the impugned prohibition amounted to a general and indiscriminate restriction which did not permit the required assessment of proportionality in an individual case."

Source: APE-MPA


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top