What's new

[Cyprus Times] Dr. Elpidoforos Sotiriades acquitted for attending the Open University without a Safe Pass

221725227_10225347632018591_3245691353351461201_n_0.jpg

Dr. Elpidophoros Sotiriadis acquitted three months after trial for entering the premises of the Open University of Cyprus without a Safe Pass What his lawyer tells the Cyprus Times

Dr. Elpidoforos Sotiriadis in disciplinary proceedings initiated against him by the Open University of Cyprus for entering the university premises without a Safe Pass.

Specifically, the reason for these proceedings was that the doctor entered the university premises while in possession of the result of a laboratory test against Covid-19 antibodies and without a Safe Pass.

Lawyer Giannos Georgiadis, whose law firm represented Dr. Sotiriadis, says that "it is recorded among the noteworthy facts that the doctor, since the health certificate he had with him was not accepted, left in all decency and without his behavior being contrary to the rules of the APA and the general behavior expected of university professors."

Mr Georgiadis, Dr Sotiriadis' lawyer in the proceedings, said that, "given the three-month duration of the proceedings, both time and resources were wasted on a procedure which had no basis in the first place. He also noted that, in three other cases in which, employees of the AUCY entered the university premises without possessing a Safe Pass, no disciplinary proceedings were initiated against them but only a reprimand was issued."

The whole process started in March 2022 and ended with an acquittal three months later.

Dr. Sotiriadis' lawyer said that, "apart from the unnecessary nature of the case, the whole process has been problematic, with basic rules of law blatantly violated. He explained that, any disciplinary procedure is quasi-criminal and, therefore, the procedure of the criminal courts (criminal procedure) should be followed to the greatest extent possible. Apart from this, however, the APS itself follows by analogy the Disciplinary Control Rules of the University of Cyprus, since it does not yet have its own, in which Article 5.1. explicitly states that: "The disciplinary control procedure before the EAC [DISCIPLINARY CONTROL COMMITTEE] shall be conducted in the same manner, as far as possible, as the procedure in a criminal case that is summarily adjudicated". Despite the fact that this principle is well-established and well-legislated and has as its main objective the protection of a fair trial, in the doctor's disciplinary review proceedings the APA chose not to follow it. Further, however, the principle of equality of arms which is one of the most basic principles of natural justice and closely intertwined with the principle of due process must be observed. Among the main arguments, in the written and oral arguments of the lawyer Yannos Georgiadis was that,in principle, no disciplinary offence had been committed on the part of his client and therefore any disciplinary proceedings were completely unjustified. He also made reference to the fact that the indictment served on Dr. Sotiriadis did not contain any offence known to the law."

Specifically, he stressed that Article 2.1. of the Rules for the Control of Academic and Other Educational Staff of the University of Cyprus requires that any accusation in the disciplinary control procedure must relate to a law, regulation or rule of the University. In the present case, this does not refer to any legislation of the Republic of Cyprus since the adjudication of such cases is the exclusive competence of the Cyprus Courts.



"In cases of university disciplinary proceedings, the legislation and regulations which may be relied upon are those relating to the establishment and operation of the university. Thus, even the mention in the indictment of a general category of disciplinary offence, such as, in the present case, the violation of the University's security rules, does not constitute a sufficient legal basis if no reference is made to a specific rule and/or legislation of the University."

Georgiades stated that "The Regulatory Administrative Acts issued by the Minister of Health, known as Decrees, are legislation of the State and not legislation of the University. This in itself makes the consideration of any alleged offence in this regard the jurisdiction of the Cyprus Courts, not of the University or any other organisation and/or authority.". Importantly, as Mr Georgiades suggested, the Indictment did not comply with the University's Disciplinary Control Rules, a position adopted by the EIA itself in its acquittal.

Regarding the Indictment's non-compliance with the Disciplinary Control Rules in his summation, Mr. Georgiades stated that "Article 4.3(b) of the Rules expressly states that the Investigating Officer must draft the Indictment, while Article 4.7 of the Rules requires the President of the EIA to immediately summon the person being disciplined under Appendix A of the Rules. The said Appendix also states that the Charge is attached to the Summons which is signed by the President of the EIA."

As Dr. Sotiriadis' counsel pointed out, in this disciplinary case, the Summons and the Charge coexisted in the same document and were signed by the President of the EIA. This makes the President of the EIA, a Court and an accuser. Similarly, in a criminal proceeding this would mean that the Prosecution which is the Prosecuting Authority and issues the Indictment would also be the Court which, in effect, would have already decided on the guilt of the accused once it has issued the Indictment. This blatantly violates the principle of equality of arms since the "Court", whether it is the judiciary or disciplinary, would have to balance the rights of the two sides coming before it with equal weapons. And according to its own decision, the EIA: "Nevertheless, we believe that in this case, the formula prescribed by the disciplinary regulations for the proper composition of the indictment was not followed, resulting in an antinomian situation where the EIA appears to have effectively assumed the role of prosecutor and judge at the same time." In the end, Dr. Sotiriadis was acquitted and cleared of all charges, leaving behind a great waste of time and financial resources.

Georgiades stated that it is a shame that so much time is wasted on such issues, which are not disciplinary in nature and which can be resolved in other ways. In the context of the examination of this matter, Mr Georgiades in his speech also raised the issue of possible retaliatory behaviour due to his client's positions on the management of the Covid-19 pandemic, which was intended to cause his client suffering. He recalled that, in July 2021, a few months before the indictment was issued, information had been made public that the CPS would initiate disciplinary proceedings, but without his client having been charged or found guilty of any offence, which cannot go unnoticed.


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top