[/QUOTE]He does not even give the finding on wiretapping and black van to the Parliament.Appeal against the acquittal of the Larnaca Criminal Court for an investment project, says Attorney General
Criminal interrogations[/B] and transparency are contradictory concepts, the Attorney General told the Parliament's Finance Committee, George Savvidis, during the examination of the Legal Service's budget, saying that the finding on the wiretapping and theblack van will not be made public, while regarding the investment program, he said that the prosecution has registered an appeal against the acquittal decision of the Larnaca Court of Appeal.
The Prosecutor General replied in the negative to a question from AKEL MP Andreas Pasiourtidis on whether the findings[/B] on the wiretapping and the black van will be made available for parliamentary scrutiny, saying that investigations and criminal proceedings must be safeguarded.
"Criminal investigation and transparency are contradictory terms," he noted. "We cannot conduct criminal investigations in the light of journalists and channels," he noted, saying that "we will face this every time a criminal investigation, especially one of public interest, gets publicity. It is not a question of gagging," he noted, but of following proper procedures. He pointed out that the Legal Service gets messages from the courts that excessive publicity was given to cases and this counts towards sentencing.
That is why, he said, the finding will not be given to Parliament. The same issue was raised by the PEGA committee, he noted, and the chairman of the committee fully understood the issue and respected it, he said.
During the presentation of the Legal Service's budget, MPs asked the Attorney General what was being done with various cases. In addition to the issue of wiretapping, he asked what was happening with the Naturalization Investment Program and the findings "on the destruction of the economy." In the same context, PPP MP Alekos Tryfonidis asked about the findings on the Co-operatism, while Alexandra Attalidou, on behalf of the Ecologists, asked about the Kalaitzidis case, the findings on prisons and the findings on the death of Thanasis Nikolaou.
The Attorney General said that with regard to the Investment Programme, the Prosecution had registered an appeal against the acquittal decision of the Larnaca Court of Cassation. With regard to other cases, he explained that the delay was due, inter alia, to lack of expertise and waiting for foreign experts. "To gather admissible testimony that can be presented in court, there are delays," he noted, adding that the Legal Service is also conveying the message to the police that the procedures must be finished. He said that large-scale meetings are often held with police and investigators so as not to perpetuate the situation.
Regarding the Arrestis finding on the Co-operative, Assistant Attorney General Savvas Angelides responded, saying that there are 1-2 pending issues that the police are investigating. He noted that no civil or criminal liability has arisen from the former Finance Minister. But there are civil claims, not from the government but from the KEDIPES, "which we brought in contact with the police to receive what is necessary and to register lawsuits for large funds," he said, adding that where small suspicions are identified, investigations are continuing.
On the prison case, the Attorney General said that the examination of the finding is being handled by the Legal Service and an announcement will be made as soon as there is an update.
On the finding on the death of Thanasis Nikolaos, the Attorney General said that many more things have happened recently than in recent years. "We allowed the exhumation. To take the remains abroad, we ordered a criminal investigation because they (the family) said they didn't want the police, we put in the people who asked us as criminal investigators, they asked for two adjournments, we gave them. The investigation was over, we found out from a newspaper before it was handed over to us and the two investigators came and told us this is as far as we could go, now it's a matter for the police. We had a meeting with the family and the lawyer, I think they were satisfied. We already have another meeting within the Legal Service, next week with the police, the lawyer and the family," he said.
Finally, on the Kalaitzidou case, the Assistant Attorney General said the case has been settled to the full satisfaction of the family. "We departed from the established compensation framework because we put other factors into the equation," he said.
DISY MP Onoufrios Koulla asked what is being done about the "false news spread by the Social Media", as well as anonymous accounts that insult public figures through them.
The Attorney General said that as far as media outlets are concerned, the legislative framework suffers, throwing the ball to the Parliament, as it has a bill before it. "You cannot do this vulgar insult to the media and not have a legal framework to take people to court" for reflection, he said, appealing to Parliament to pass the bill in question. "Insult on the street cannot be a criminal offence and on the internet cannot," he said."
Regarding the spread of false news, he said that in cases leading to limited consequences to institutions, the state, public health, etc, can, with the consent of the public prosecutor, be prosecuted, as was done, he said, in some cases during the pandemic.
He clarified that under the legal framework as it stands, death threats in the media are a criminal offence, saying that there were websites on which he himself received death threats. "I made some representations, I chose not to make them public," he said."
In relation to the Legal Service's budget for 2023, it amounts to approximately €33.3 million. This includes the Budget of the Independent Authority for the Investigation of Allegations and Complaints against the Police, which is €379 thousand, and the Budget of the Office of the Law Commissioner, which is €678 thousand, as presented by Savides.
He noted that the increase of €8.9 million, The increase of €8.8 million observed for 2023 is primarily due to the €6.3 million budgeted for the construction of a privately owned building for the Legal Service in Nicosia.
Furthermore, he said that the implementation of the Budget by 1 November 2022 amounted to 85% of the total budget. In the corresponding period of 2021, the implementation rate was 72%, while the total implementation of the Budget by the end of 2022 is expected to reach 95%.
Presenting the work of the Legal Service, he said that a complete reorganization, modernization and streamlining was achieved. He said that, for the first time, a mechanism for monitoring legal work was implemented, with the adoption of strict response schedules for legal officers based on the urgency and priority of the matter, which was effective, as more than 95% of the 648 tasks declared as pending at the end of March 2022 from the previous ones have been completed today.
Work logs were also created for real-time supervisory control of pending and completed legal work by Ministry/Service/Department and by Sector of Law and legal officer.
Regarding staffing, he said that 84 vacant permanent posts at all levels of the hierarchy have been filled since July 2020 to date, while 46 vacant organic posts remain and are being promoted for filling in the current period.
The Attorney General also announced the establishment of a Legal Service Academy aimed at developing and promoting basic training programmes for newly recruited officials of the Legal Service, lifelong education of the Service's officials and training of public officials in matters within the jurisdiction of the Legal Service.
He also said that a Corruption Investigation Coordination Team was set up as a specialized mechanism to provide guidance and coordination of criminal investigation of serious corruption cases, as well as cases likely to involve elements of corruption. The Team has already held its first sessions and based on decisions taken, a number of serious criminal corruption cases have been categorized and are being handled by the Team.
Finally, Savvidis said that on 16 March 2022, the Legal Service submitted to the Executive a bill on its autonomy, which is still pending before the Council of Ministers. He noted that the issue of autonomy stems from Article 112 of the Constitution of the Republic, the relevant GRECO recommendations for further strengthening the guarantee of impartiality of officials and strengthening the rule of law, and the recommendation of the European Commission in its 2022 Report on the State of the Rule of Law in Cyprus, which makes explicit reference to the need to "continue to improve the effective investigation and prosecution of high-level corruption cases, including by strengthening the Office of the Attorney General and its financial independence".
The chairman of the Commission, Chrysis Pantelides, expressed his satisfaction with the actions aimed at reforming the Legal Service. He noted that there is a feeling in society that justice is not being done or that the guilty are getting away and asked if there is a statistical record of cases in which the Legal Service is a party, with a success rate.
DISY MP Fotini Tsiridou said that the presence of the Legal Service in parliamentary committees is very important. She stressed that the Attorney General's Office should stay out of political considerations. "Democracy requires us to respect the institutions and support them. If we lose trust in them, we go from democracy to anarchy," he said.
DISY MP Nikos Tornaritis said, in relation to the issue of the bill on the MPAs, that the aim of MPs is to defend the Constitution and human rights. The bill is directly related to how to separate freedom of speech, satire with all the things that should be restricted. "Put in an institutional framework, but let's see where it stops so that it does not affect any right to freedom of speech," he said, while calling for the issue to be discussed in the last session of the Law Committee before Parliament closes.
AKEL MP Andreas Pasiourtides said on the issue that there is no difference whether someone insults you on the internet or on the street, but "we must make it clear that we are not going to bring back the criminalisation of libel, which was abolished years ago."
DPA-Cooperation MP Alekos Tryfonides said that the credibility of our state hangs in your hands. We have confidence in you and your decisions. We may disagree, but we want to keep the service colourless and high, woe betide us if it collapses." On the issue of MDCs, he said the Criminal Code needs to be amended. "We are all victims" and "those who make decisions must also be given protection."
Finally, Alexandra Attalidou asked the Attorney General whether a channel has been opened in the Legal Service so that whistleblowers can make complaints and be protected.
Source: KYPE
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source