What's new

[Cyprus Times] Consultation on the draft law on wiretapping in Greece. What it provides for

345543435435543.jpg

Consultation on the draft law on surveillance in Greece Dozens of provisions unfold along four main axes What it provides for

In publicity, in order to be put to public consultation, the government's legislative initiative on the operation of the NIS, the selection of its commander, the "filters" for the surveillance of political persons and the ban on malicious software.[/B]

Dozens of provisions unfold along four main axes.

The first concerns the revision of the framework of "legal connections" of the NSA to political persons, the second relates to the functioning of the NSA, the third has to do with cybersecurity (special committees and a departmental coordination mechanism are coming) and the fourth concerns the framework of sanctions for anyone who trades or simply possesses dark tools, such as Predator.

The bill will remain in consultation until 22 November and then Kyriakos Mitsotakis will present it to the Parliament, with another summit clash predicted.

The purpose of the draft law, as stated in the first chapter, is. 1 of Article 19 of the Constitution,[BRP]-optimization of the action of the National Intelligence Service,[BRP]-protection of the confidentiality of communications from interception software,[BRP]-organic and functional upgrading of the level of cybersecurity in the country, and[BRP]-more effective protection of natural persons against the processing of personal data.

The object of the law is:



-exhaustive regulation of the procedure for lifting the confidentiality of communications;
- restructuring of the National Intelligence Service;
- criminal punishment of trafficking, possession and use of prohibited surveillance software;
- establishment and operation of a Coordination Committee for Cyber Security Issues, and
-amending national provisions transposing Directive (EU) 2016/680 of the European Parliament and of the Council on the protection of individuals with regard to the processing of personal data by competent authorities for the purposes of the prevention, investigation, detection or prosecution of criminal offences or the execution of criminal penalties and on the free movement of such data.

What it provides

Together with the draft law on interception, 25 questions and answers were made public:

1. What is the purpose of the bill?

The purpose of the bill is to modernise the procedure for lifting the confidentiality of communications by ensuring all the necessary safeguards, the restructuring of the NSI to optimise its action, the criminalisation of the trade, possession and use of surveillance software, the organic and operational upgrading of the level of cybersecurity in the country and the optimal transposition into national law of the Directive on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data.

2. On what grounds can communications secrecy be lawfully lifted?

According to Article 19 of the Constitution, secrecy may be lifted for reasons of national security or for the investigation of particularly serious crimes by decision of a judicial authority.

3. What is meant by "national security" on the basis of which confidentiality may be lawfully lifted?

To date, there is no definition in the law. The Bill defines "national security reasons" as reasons related to the protection of the basic functions of the state and the fundamental interests of society as a whole, which include the prevention and suppression of activities capable of causing harm to the constitutional, political, economic or social structures of the country, such as, in particular, reasons related to national defence and security, foreign policy, energy security, cybersecurity and protection against other hybrid threats, protection of the legal Which authority can apply for lifting privacy for national security reasons?[/B]

Until now, any public authority could make a request. Under the Bill, only the National Security Service and the Anti-Terrorist Service (Directorate for the Prevention of Special Crimes of Violence of the Hellenic Police, "DASEB") can request such a request.

5. What is the procedure for lifting secrecy for reasons of national security?

A request by the NIS or the Anti-Terrorist Service, a decision by an internal prosecutor in the relevant service and a decision by a deputy prosecutor of the Supreme Court. The second prosecutorial filter was added by the 9/8/2022 PNP, which essentially reinstated a provision that SYRIZA had abolished in 2018.

6. How is the lifting of secrecy for reasons of national security for political persons?

To date, there is no special procedure for political persons and the usual procedure is followed. It turned out that there should be special safeguards. The bill sets a triple filter of safeguards: a) the procedure is expedited only by the NIA, b) the President of the Parliament must give permission before the double prosecutorial discretion, and c) the request for lifting must be based on concrete elements that make an immediate and highly probable risk to national security.

7. Who are considered political persons for the application of the law?

"Political persons" are considered the President of the Republic, members of the government and deputy ministers, members of the national and European parliaments, leaders of political parties represented in the national and European parliaments and the highest unilateral bodies of the first and second degree local authorities.

8. Can the person who has been subject to the lifting of confidentiality for reasons of national security be informed ex post?

Until 2021, it was possible to be informed at the discretion of the deciding body only if the purpose for which the lifting was ordered was not compromised. Thereafter, it was not possible to inform when it was for reasons of national security (but it was possible for waivers to investigate crimes). This issue is extremely complex because it has to reconcile rights and the effectiveness of the service when dealing with high-level risks. The Bill proposes that the subject be informed provided that the purpose for which the lifting was ordered is not compromised, even after 3 years have elapsed since the lifting ceased. The three-year period is considered a reasonable time and follows foreign practices in order to keep a distance from events of the highest national security (such as the events in Evros and the spying in Rhodes in 2020). The decision to inform is taken by a three-member body composed of the competent public prosecutor, the commander of the NIS or the director of the IAEAB and the president of the ADAE.

9. Does the authority requesting the removal on grounds of national security keep a record?

To date, the destruction of records is foreseen but without specific timeframes and specific procedures. The procedure is now being standardised. For the content of the surveillance, automatic deletion is provided in principle after 6 months from the end of the lifting. For the file containing the documentation of the lifting, the destruction of the file is foreseen in principle after 10 years from the end of the lifting. Provision is also made for the possibility of full digitisation of the archive for easy search and maximum security.

10. For the investigation of which crimes can be declassified?

Until now the list was extremely broad and included felonies and misdemeanors under the Criminal Code and special criminal laws. This list is being streamlined to include in principle all felonies and of the misdemeanors only those with special gravity (e.g. against minors, arson, criminal gang) by removing most of the special laws. For example, removal cannot be ordered for simple theft or fraud.

11. What procedure is used to order removal for the investigation of crimes?

The relevant procedure does not change. The lifting is imposed by an order of the Council of Appeal or Plenary Court on the request of the prosecutor or the investigating judge. Only in cases of extreme urgency may the prosecutor and the investigating judge, who shall then be obliged to bring the matter before the Council within a period of 3 days by means of an application.

12. Can the person who has been subjected to the lifting of secrecy for the purpose of investigating crimes be informed afterwards?

Nothing changes. After the expiry of the measure, the CPS decides to inform the subject, with the consent of the Prosecutor of the Supreme Court and provided that the purpose for which it was ordered is not compromised. The only thing that is added is that the CPS shall reply to the request within 3 months, otherwise the request shall be deemed to have been rejected.

13. Is there a maximum time limit for lifting secrecy?

To date, waivers are ordered for two months with the possibility of renewal, there is no maximum time limit for waivers on grounds of national security and there is a 10-month limit for the investigation of crimes. Now the 10-month limit also covers national security waivers, unless the request is based on specific elements that make an immediate and highly probable threat to national security.

14. Why should there be a special prosecutor in the NIS and the Counter-Terrorism Department?

The existence of special prosecutors enhances both the specialization of individuals and the sealing of information. In any case, a second prosecutor is required to lift secrecy for national security reasons so that the system does not operate institutionally. For the same reason, the terms of office of the on-site prosecutors are three-year non-renewable (whereas until now the term of office of the anti-terrorism prosecutor can be renewed).

15. What is provided for the prohibitions on possession, trafficking, distribution and use of prohibited software?

Until 2019, illegal interception was a felony punishable by up to 10 years imprisonment, while possession and trafficking of illegal software was a misdemeanor punishable by up to 2 years imprisonment. A few days before the dissolution of the Parliament for the 2019 elections and while SYRIZA was aware of the existence of illegal software in Greece, the Criminal Code was incomprehensibly changed so that interception is now punishable with imprisonment from 10 days to 5 years, while possession and trafficking was decriminalized. The proposed provisions reinstate the felony of using illegal software and devices and the misdemeanor of trafficking and possession with a sentence of 1-5 years.

16. How will one know what constitutes prohibited software and devices?

Prohibited software or surveillance devices are software or devices capable of interception, recording and any kind of extraction of content and/or communication data (traffic and location), which are defined by a decision of the Commander of the NIS to be published within 3 days from the entry into force of the law. The list of prohibited software or surveillance devices shall be updated by a decision of the Director of the NSI no later than every 6 months. In addition, a notice of the Director of the NSI, posted on the website of the Agency, shall inform the public about the prohibited software, how it works and the protection measures it can take against it.

17. Prohibitions for possession and marketing of malicious software do not already exist?

No for violation of privacy of private communications. The current Article 292A does not fully cover the provision we are bringing in. It belongs to the "Crimes against telecommunications" chapter of the Penal Code and refers to accessing a connection or network in a way that systemically compromises the physical security of the telephone communications network (EETT's responsibility). In contrast, the new bill's malware provision belongs to the "Violations of privacy and communications" chapter and refers to any software or device that interferes with private communications (EETT's responsibility). Therefore, the two provisions have a different purpose. This is also the reason why the two different provisions have long coexisted in the current Criminal Code. What we are proposing with the bill is to reintroduce with a stricter and upgraded criminal content the provision abolished by SYRIZA concerning the universal prohibition of marketing, distribution and possession of software for monitoring individual communications.

18. Will the public be able to procure spying software?

The public will be able to procure spying software under conditions determined by a presidential decree of the competent ministers, which will have been processed by the Council of State.

19. Why do we say that for the first time in Greece a universal ban on the possession and marketing of malicious software is being introduced, since there were some provisions in the past?

The provision abolished by SYRIZA indeed concerned the possession and marketing of malicious software, but it was limited in scope and inapplicable in practice. First, it referred to possession and use "without right", without specifying who had the right. Second, it required possession and trafficking to be for the "purpose" of committing the crime of interception, which was impossible to prove in practice. Third, the provision did not specify what the prohibited software and devices actually were. Under the new provision, anyone who possesses or trades in the listed software and devices is punishable by heavy penalties without the need for any other condition, hence universally.

20. What changes in the management of the NSI?

Until now, the commander and deputy commanders can come from the public or private sector. Under the proposed bill, the Commander will be a person from the diplomatic corps or a retired senior officer. Vice-Governors may be any of the above, as well as public and private sector employees and officials. In addition, the number of deputy governors is reduced from the current 3 to 2.

21. What changes in the organisation of the NSI?

3 new structures are added. a) The Intelligence and Counterintelligence Academy with the mission of training, education and specialization of the NIS staff for the more effective performance of their duties. b) The Internal Audit Unit, which is responsible, inter alia, for the internal audit of the NIS. c) The Press and Communication Office, which is responsible for the promotion of the work of the service and for informing society about its actions and any risks to national security.

22. What changes in the functioning of the NSI?

First, the Information Security Authority (INFOSEC) of the NSI becomes responsible for drafting security policies and guidelines for the management of classified information in all networks and premises of the Presidency of the Government and the Ministries in cooperation with them, as well as for keeping them informed on security issues. Second, the possibility of secret contracts in the Centre for Technology Support, Development and Innovation (K.T.Y.A.K.)

23. How is the level of cybersecurity in the country being improved?

The most important problem is the fragmentation of cybersecurity structures in the country. For this reason, a Cyber Security Coordination Committee is being set up to act as a coordinating body between: (a) the General Directorate of Cybersecurity of the General Secretariat of Telecommunications and Post of the Ministry of Digital Governance, which has been designated as the National Authority of Cybersecurity; (b) the Cyber Defence Directorate of the National Defence Forces, which has been designated as the competent response team for computer security incidents, c) the Cyber Directorate of the National Cyber Security Directorate of the National Security Agency (National CERT) and d) the Hellenic Police. The responsibilities of the Commission are.(e) to resolve any disagreements regarding the responsibilities and roles of the Cybersecurity actors.

24. Is there a cybersecurity risk study and early warning system in place?

According to the bill, the National Cybersecurity Authority, in cooperation with the Cyberspace Directorate of the National Security Service, the Cyber Defence Directorate of the General Staff, the Hellenic Police and any other competent body, shall prepare a National Information and Communication Technology Systems Risk Assessment Plan, which shall be classified in accordance with the National Security Regulation. The Plan shall include the identification, analysis and assessment of risks and their impact on the security of information and communication technology systems at national level. The Plan shall take into account each category of potential threat, and in particular threats related to malicious acts, natural phenomena, technical failures, malfunctions or human errors, in order to assess the extent and criticality of the impact of these threats at national level. In addition, the National Cybersecurity Authority and the Cyber Directorate shall ensure the monitoring of known threats and vulnerabilities of information and communication systems and provide information on them.

25. How is the protection of personal data further ensured?

By Law No. 4624/2019 (only the fourth law passed by the new Parliament resulting from the 2019 elections), Regulation 2016/679 and Directive 2016/680 were incorporated into the Greek legal order. This package was long overdue due to SYRIZA's inaction towards this EU obligation. During the time that has passed since the publication of the law on 29.08.2019, certain issues have been identified in practice and by the European Commission to improve the existing framework in Greece. The proposed bill and specifically 12 interventions cover gaps and remove relevant ambiguities in the direction of strengthening the basic right to personal data protection. In addition, in order to monitor the relevant policies, a Permanent Scientific Committee on Personal Data Protection is established at the Ministry of Justice with the mission: a) to monitor scientific and legislative developments and the national and EU legal framework for the protection of personal data, b) to submit well-founded proposals for legislative action in this area, c) to perform legislative drafting tasks and d) to represent the Ministry of Justice in international bodies. Finally, it is provided that by order of the Public Prosecutor, the Hellenic Police shall announce or make public the details of the identity, image and criminal prosecution of a person accused or convicted of a felony, a misdemeanour against sexual freedom and a misdemeanour punishable by at least two 2 years' imprisonment.

Source: in.gr


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top