Positive image of police on pandemic controls says C. Comptroller, €5.94 million collected from out-of-court settlements At 3.21 million, police checks, at 42.672 complaints, says Odysseas Michaelides
Auditor General Odysseas Michaelides described the general picture of the Police in relation to the way it acted during the pandemic of the coronavirus and in particular during the period March 2020 to September 2021 as positive, while according to the latest police figures, the total amount collected from extrajudicial fines amounted to €5.94 million and 42 were issued.482 penalty notices were issued, of which 16,475 have been paid, while 1,388 are invalid.
"I believe that we as the Police have acted effectively" and "we have given our best in order for society and the state in general to achieve its goal", Assistant Chief Christoforos Mavrommatis stressed.
Both the Auditor General and the Assistant Chief of Police were speaking before the Parliamentary Audit Committee, which examined ex officio the special report of the Audit Service issued on June 16, 2022, in relation to the assessment of the adequacy and effectiveness of the checks carried out by the Police during the period March 2020 - September 2021, to ascertain compliance with the measures imposed to deal with the coronavirus pandemic in order to reduce the number of cases.
Regarding the general conclusions of the report, the Auditor General said that "based on the individual findings and taking into account the specific circumstances under which the Police carried out inspections and made decisions to respond to the pandemic, depending on its evolution, we conclude that, to a very satisfactory extent, the Police have taken the necessary actions to ensure compliance with the measures".
"The positive impact of the police controls in dealing with the pandemic is also evident from the fact that in the Limassol District, where the fewest controls were carried out, the most cases were recorded, while in the Paphos District, where the largest number of controls and complaints were carried out in proportion to the population, the fewest cases were recorded," he added.
However, Michaelides said the EY also found "certain weaknesses" such as the fact that from the start of the pandemic in March until November 2020, the instructions issued by the headquarters to the police directorates/departments were generalised.
He also reported that the Police conducted increased checks and complaints during the periods when stricter measures were imposed by the Government to prevent the spread of the coronavirus, such as curfew, ban on gatherings, mandatory telecommuting, distance learning and suspension of operations in businesses, however during periods of relaxation and the restart of business activity, controls were drastically reduced, with a significant reduction observed in the summer of 2021, when the highest number of cases was recorded.
He also said that the complaint investigation process is time-consuming and complex, resulting in valuable time being taken up by both members of the Police and the Legal Service officers who handle such complaints.
The Auditor General said that non-payment of bounties imposed results in many cases being taken to the Courts followed by the issuance of fine warrants.
With regard to the Auditor General's general recommendations to the Police, Mr. Michaelides said that in future cases of similar pandemics or other emergencies, "it should be ensured that controls are adequate and effective to ensure that the measures imposed by the Government to manage a pandemic or any other crisis are adhered to."
He said the agency's recommendations, "aimed at simplifying the complaint handling procedures, as well as our long-standing observations on the effectiveness of the administration of justice due to the accumulation of fine warrants over time, should be evaluated and appropriate action taken."
At 3.21 million police checks, 42,672 complaints
In relation to data gathered by the EY, the Auditor General said that during the period in question, there were 120.000 cases and the Police carried out 3.21 million checks and 42,672 complaints
He said that between 24 March 2020 and 31 October 2021, 42.208 exonerations, totalling €13,657,851, of which 16,251 or 39%, totalling €5,161,698, were paid, while 25,957 exonerations or 61% of the total number of exonerations, totalling €8, were still pending during the period covered by the Service's report.496,154.492 the payment period has expired and are on hold pending a criminal case file (RCI), for 22,127 the process of creating a criminal case file has been completed, while 1,388 are invalid either following approval by an Assistant Police Commissioner (cases of errors) or following a decision by the Attorney General.
He noted that the pending cases of extrajudicial letters that were not registered in a criminal case file had been reduced to 2.500, down from about 7,000 at the time.
He also said that during the pandemic period, the Police had full cooperation with the EY, the Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Labour, the Ministry of Energy, the Ministry of State for Tourism, the NF and other agencies and "our aim was to be transparent and to erase all the efforts of the Police in this matter," noting that the Auditor General had "gone through the motions" of the Police to establish how the Force had operated during the pandemic.
He also said the Police acted flexibly to enable it to cope with the role it had to play during the pandemic and had to suspend various routine actions (training, withdrawal of members from airports and others).
We responded well despite the difficulties and the losses we had due to the 417 cases of coronavirus in the police, Mavrommatis said, noting that there were also behaviours by citizens "outside the permissible limits".
Police spokesmen stressed that the Police gave "the best of their resources" to meet their duties during the unprecedented conditions of the pandemic, while they also mentioned a few negative exceptions by members of the Force.
Cancelled bills of summons
According to the report read by the Auditor General, of the 1,285 bills of summons, totalling €458,971, presented in the system as cancelled, we carried out an audit in 23 cases, to find that all the bills were cancelled with the approval of either the Attorney General or the Director of Traffic.
"From the audit, we identified a case in which the Attorney General's decision was related to the approval for not imposing an additional charge, while the outlaw in question, by mistake, was cancelled," he added.
He also said that of the 1,285 outlaws, totalling €458.971, which are shown in the system as cancelled, we carried out a check in 23 cases, to find that all the bills were cancelled with the approval of either the Attorney General or the Director of Traffic.
"From the audit we identified a case in which the Attorney General's decision was related to the approval for not imposing an additional charge, while the outlaw in question, inadvertently, was cancelled," he added.
In addition, Mr. Michaelides said, citing the findings of the report, that from information obtained from the Police's electronic system for managing out-of-court complaints, we noted a weakness in the process of monitoring the progress of out-of-court complaints by members of the Police in the various Departments/Districts, since for 7.093 outlaw cases, with a total value of €2,332,667, no criminal file had been opened by the date of our audit, even though the date of payment of the outlaw had passed.
He added that in the period up to 31.10.2021, 262 bills of summons were issued, relating to amounts from €1,500 to €16,000 each, with a total value of €1,027,500, of which, up to the date of the audit, only 97, with a total value of €286,000, had been paid.
The Auditor General said that of the 42,208 bills of summons issued between 24.3.2020 and 31.10.2021, 22,984 were issued manually using the collection and revenue ledger, while the remaining 19,224 were issued electronically.
Regarding the establishment of the EY. Michaelides said that as this procedure requires additional time and bureaucracy and poses risks of incorrect entries due to the human factor, we recommended that the possibility of abolishing the issue of handwritten bills and replacing them with electronic ones be considered.
He said that the Chief of Police informed the EOI that the issuance of handwritten bills became necessary due to the fact that the number of bills issuing devices is specific and the number of members, who were deputed to work on pandemic management, was large enough that it was not feasible to provide everyone with a device.
He added that according to data maintained in the above electronic table, from 10.4.2020 to 7.12.2021, 4,005 complaints were received, out of which 3,564 were considered and the rest remained pending.
In a statement after the meeting, Commission Chairman Zacharias Coulias said that "the Auditor General expressed his thanks for the manner and handling of the management of the pandemic by the Police".
"It was an unprecedented event, the state, rightly or wrongly, rightly or wrongly, issued some decrees, which the Police were asked to implement under unprecedented and adverse conditions," he said, adding that "it was also an unprecedented situation for the people."
He said that "on the part of the Police, everything possible and impossible was done to manage this difficulty", adding that "there were some irregularities in the way the complaints were made but when you make thousands of complaints it is natural that things happen which are out of context."
"On the main axis everything was right" and the Comptroller expressed his satisfaction with the way it was handled," he concluded.
For his part, the Assistant Commissioner said with regard to the pending out-of-court fines, "they are going to be settled through the court," adding that few cases are pending for various reasons which are being looked into.
With regard to ex gratia fines for which complaints had been made, Mavrommatis said these were before a competent committee, which had been appointed to look into the complaints, either because a complaint was made in error or various other reasons.
"These cases were seen by the Committee and some were referred to the Attorney General and the complaints had been cancelled" for some reason, he added."
In addition, Mavrommatis, after thanking the Audit Committee for inviting them to attend the meeting, which "highlighted the work of the Police", also thanked the Auditor General for his report.
The work of the Police during the pandemic "was unprecedented, we expended a lot of resources" either human or financial "to achieve the general objective of the society which was to contain this pandemic phenomenon which had to do with the health of the people," he added.
"I believe that we as the Police acted effectively" and "we gave our best to achieve the objective of the society and the state in general," he stressed.
He said that they gave the Auditor General all the data because they wanted the Police through transparency to show what exactly happened because the financial resources, he said, "given by the people had to show that they were properly allocated and produced results", adding that it was shown through the report that there was a very good result and" this is shown through the ranking we had as a country in the EU in relation to the management of the pandemic".
"Our role was very dangerous because we were also exposed as Police Officers" and "we also had outbreaks", a development that "further limited the possibilities to implement the decrees", he added.
The Assistant Chief also said that the Police also had to deal with the negative climate in general as "people naturally reacted."
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source