What's new

[Cyprus Times] AKEL calls for taxation of energy companies' windfall profits

stefanou_akel.jpg

Two law proposals submitted by the party to the Trade Committee Taxation is applied by several European states, said AKEL Secretary General Stefanos Stefanou

With two law proposals submitted on Tuesday by AKEL Secretary General Stefanos Stefanou to the Energy Committee, Commerce, Industry and Tourism, it is proposed to tax the 2022 windfall profits of RES electricity suppliers and distributors and oil companies at a rate of 90%, as well as to impose a retaliation fee on bilateral contracts for the supply of RES electricity.

Stefanos Stefanou, in a statement within the Committee, said that the first proposal concerns an amendment to the Income Tax Act for a one-off tax on windfall profits in 2022 for RES electricity suppliers and distributors and oil companies.

As he said, the windfall profits tax is implemented by several EU member states and is also a recommendation made by the UN Secretary General, so that states can get revenue from taxing energy companies and support the lower strata of societies that are under even more pressure today due to high fuel and energy prices. It is also, he said, a position that the Commission has also taken and has been initiated and implemented in a number of EU member states.

"Our intention was to work with the government and we would like the government to come and bring it as a bill. We would avoid discussing whether they fall within the Constitution and how they can be done," he said, noting that he had sent two letters to the Finance Minister on 8/7 and at the end of August, which had gone unanswered.

He also noted that when a meeting was held at the National Council in June, the Finance Minister had expressed support and willingness to cooperate on the issue. "We saw no willingness to cooperate beyond an ironic tweet in response to the 2nd letter," he said. "That is why we went ahead to formulate these two bills. We are open to discussion and input from both parties and technocrats as soon as possible to provide tools and opportunities for the state to help households and SMEs," he added.

Regarding the second legislative proposal, he said it concerns an amendment to the law on the RES and EE Fund and has two parts: on the one hand, the introduction of a permanent counterpart fee on bilateral contracts for the supply of electricity from RES, which is set at 90% for the amount exceeding the maximum purchase price of the kilowatt-hour, which is currently set by the RAEC at 11 cents.

The second part concerns a second amendment to strengthen the objectives of the Fund to address energy poverty. "Especially now, with very high electricity and fuel prices, it will help if we include provision in the purposes of the fund," he said.



Ministry of Finance

In statements after the meeting, Mr. Stefanou noted that "on this issue we tried to open a dialogue with the Ministry of Finance in order to share the thoughts we had and for the Government to bring the issue to Parliament. Unfortunately, the Ministry of Finance diligently and persistently refused this dialogue. This forced AKEL to bring these legislative proposals and today we have opened a debate which should have taken place a long time ago."

In addition, the AKEL MP said that "the conclusion is that the government has no political will to discuss the issue rationally, with the aim of finding solutions for the benefit of consumers, households and businesses. And I say this because the various ministries involved in the debate have come up with different positions, the various competent departments have also submitted different positions and we have heard more pretexts as to why the A, B or C issue included in the issue we have submitted cannot be done."

"Still looking for them"

Asked if we know how much the excess profits are, Stefanou said government agencies are still looking for the excess profits, when Energy Minister Natasha Pilidou had said several months ago that by September we will have an assessment of how much they are. "Today the relevant agencies told us that they have not yet assessed. We heard in the discussion that it is easy to do this costing and some numbers were said. Last June, in a similar discussion at the National Council, the Minister of Finance himself said that by August the government will be able to give an orientation. We have not heard anything from the Government. It is not difficult to identify the excess profits and come up with the specific amounts," he said.

Finally, he stressed that the discussion is about excess profits. "I am sure that the government will come out to say that AKEL does not understand that companies should make a profit. We fully understand it, a business to be viable has to make a profit. We are talking about the excess profit, that is, what comes out of the pockets of citizens, households, businesses, because of accuracy."

Complicated issue, says DISY

The Chairman of the Committee, DISY MP Kyriakos Hatzigiannis said that the complexity of the issue was established through the debate. "The need for stability in the system of supervision and the investment framework was strongly raised by all those present, in order to avoid disruption and setbacks in terms of the green transition."

He added that "admittedly we need to stand more, to go much deeper into the issue of price setting. It all revolves around the issue that still the market unfortunately has not yet opened up. It is the market that will set the price at the actual levels determined by supply and demand. There should as soon as possible be an increase in the supply or production of energy in such a way that demand is also adjusted to lower prices."

He also said that any interventions of an intermittent nature, "as it wrongly stands in the proposed law, will create such a situation in the electricity market that is not within the framework of the laws and the regulatory oversight framework on the part of the RAEC."

Finally, Hatzigiannis said that all this requires a comprehensive study "to know what we are doing. It is an obligation to have a comprehensive assessment both on the part of those who propose it as a legislative proposal but much more so on the part of the state."

For his part, Marinos Mousiuttas, MP for DIPA-Cooperation, said that AKEL's proposal "finds us in principle in agreement. However, we believe that the practice is difficult and time-consuming, which was also mentioned in the session. Unfortunately, these legislative proposals are made because the competent ministries of Energy and Finance, and the competent authorities, RAEK and operators, have not shown the necessary political will to competently set a more correct framework and intervene in the electricity market in a timely manner in cases of distortions or mistakes, as they dutifully ought to do."

He added that as a faction, DPA-Cooperation proposed, in a letter from the President of the faction, dated 17/3/2022 to the Minister of Energy, among other things, a 100% subsidy for vulnerable groups of the population for the installation of photovoltaic systems and 50% for the rest of the population. "With these proposals, if the Ministry took the necessary actions in time, it could save this money to give it to the vulnerable groups of the population," he concluded.

Three principled positions from Ecologists

The MP of the Movement of Ecologists, Stavros Papadouris said that these proposals sound the alarm to trigger the state, the executive to come and do something it should have done months ago. "Let me remind you that we had the first debate on this issue six months ago and for six months the state has not done anything."

"Personally, I put forward three positions of principle. The first, whether there is confirmation that there are indeed windfall profits. The second is a matter of approach, that is, whether the state has the intention to proceed, perhaps with its own bill on the matter. And third, whether there is a possibility, i.e. whether we can proceed to tax these windfall profits. There is some confusion about how much these gains are." He added that the question arises as to how it is possible that we do not know today whether there are windfall gains and to what extent they are. "It is the first thing that both the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Energy had to calculate," he said, adding that there is a European regulation that provides, not for taxation, but for compensatory fees, "which have to be returned back to the people to reduce the cost of electricity. We are reserving until the next meeting," he concluded.


Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times

Source

 
Back
Top