41-year-old man arrested in Madrid and transferred to Cyprus for online fraud case acquitted by Pafos Court
The District Court of Pafos[/B] today found the 41-year-old man not guilty, who was arrested in Madrid and transferred to Cyprus in a cyber fraud case.
The offences the defendant faced included loss of property of another person by interfering with the operation of a computer, obtaining money by false representation, money laundering and the offence of theft.
Specifically, the offences were committed in October 2020 where, according to a complaint by a Paphos resident, the complainant had contacted a company engaged in gardening work in order for it to undertake some work at his home. As part of the agreement, the complainant sent through a bank account to the company the sum of €17,850 euros as an advance payment.
Later, the complainant received an email notification to cancel the transaction because the company was unable to receive the money, which the complainant did.
Subsequently, according to the complaint, he was given new instructions by e-mail, as well as a bank account in the Netherlands, where he was asked to send money, which the complainant did. Subsequently, as reported to the Court, after communication, it was established that the company in question did not have an account in the Netherlands and that it was a fraud.
As to the facts of the case, the Prosecution, represented by Counsel for the Republic C. Argyrou had presented to the Court five prosecution witnesses, the first of whom was a police examiner who was examining the case. The second prosecution witness was the Director of the company who entered into an agreement with the complainant in the said offences under consideration, the third witness was the employee of the Bank who testified about the transfer of the money to the accused's account, the fourth prosecution witness was the employee of the company who had a direct conversation with the complainant and the fifth witness was the complainant who testified about the fraud and misappropriation of his money.
It is noted that the accused had been arrested in Madrid and was transferred to Cyprus on August 25, 2022 for the hearing to begin. By an interim decision of the Court dated November 08, 2022, the Accused was acquitted and discharged of the charges of loss of property of another person by interfering with the operation of a computer, misappropriation of money by false representation and money laundering and the Court summoned him to enter a plea for the offence of theft.
Announcing the decision, the Paphos District Court noted that in the case under consideration, the facts that were disputed by Mr. Satolias, counsel for the defence of the Accused, were particularly limited and related mainly to whether or not there was testimony that it was the Accused who had sent the specific emails in connection with the fraud, or had interfered with the computer of the company that was communicating with the Complainant or the Complainant, or whether he knew that the money credited to his account was the result of illegal activity or money other than that which a third party informed him would be credited to his account and subsequently delivered to him.
Among other things, as submitted by the defense, for all of the offenses for which arrest warrants were sought and secured, the Defendant was acquitted at the prima facie stage. A position which was accepted by the Court.
The Court stated that the jurisprudence is clear, noting that the burden of proof is on the prosecution and the standard of proof, that of beyond reasonable doubt, stating that even if it wanted to appear that the above position of the Court was not correct, it went ahead and considered whether the Accused on the testimony put before it would be convicted or not.
Stating inter alia, "the insufficiency of the testimony presented by the Prosecution to prove its primary position that the Accused stole the disputed amount of €17,850 leads the case to failure since in the mind of the Court such assumptions and doubts are created with the result that they should be decided in favour of the Accused and he should be acquitted of the charges he faces."
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source