"Each country gives its own reasons, its own explanations why it did this. They see it more as a legal issue than a political one."
The change of position of four countries, Spain, Italy, Estonia and Lithuania, has tipped the scales so that Turkey gets the desired result for it, namely the decision of the Council of Europe's Committee of Ministers' Deputies to terminate the monitoring and supervision procedure in the implementation of the ECHR's decision regarding the private appeal of Titina Loizidou against Turkey.
- The decision of the Committee of Ministers has "political implications," says Titina Loizidou
The Foreign Ministry expresses disappointment. The CoE has terminated the supervision procedure of the decision on Titina Loizidou
The result of the vote was 25 votes in favour of the termination of the procedure from Albania, the Netherlands, Montenegro, Poland, Latvia, Italy, Spain, Turkey, Switzerland, Denmark, United Kingdom, Germany, Azerbaijan, Liechtenstein, Sweden, Iceland, Estonia, Norway, Lithuania, Belgium, Belgium, Finland, North Macedonia, Croatia, Czech Republic, Portugal, 5 votes against from Cyprus, Greece, Serbia, Bulgaria, Armenia and 16 abstentions from Romania, Malta, Malta, Slovenia, Andorra, Austria, Luxembourg, Ukraine, Monaco, Hungary, Ireland, Moldova, Georgia, San Marino, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Slovakia, France[/I].
The Director General of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Cornelius Cornelius, told CYP that it is since 2018 that Turkey started trying to close this case, that is, to end the surveillance, and so far we had been able to prevent this.
"Right now the facts have changed and some people see Turkey as more important. There are also other cases in the Council of Europe that concern Turkey and I am talking mainly about the Kavala case, so they don't want to push Turkey on many issues at the same time," Corneliu added.
Certainly, he added, we are very upset by this development because the decision has not been implemented and this affects the other issues of the Cyprus problem, so that's why we wanted the surveillance to continue.
"Unfortunately, four countries which supported us last year, namely Spain, Italy, Estonia and Lithuania changed their stance and this created the majority that Turkey wanted to stop the surveillance," he said. He noted that "each country gives its own reasons, its own explanations why it did this. They see it more as a legal issue than a political one. We tried to explain to them that for us it is a political issue, it is not a legal issue because it touches on a basic aspect of the Cyprus problem, namely the property issue."
They themselves see it as a legal issue, they said, and they believe that the surveillance should have been ended, the Foreign Ministry Director General said.
At the same time, he noted, they accepted the continuation of the surveillance for the implementation of the Fourth Interstate decisions, which is something very important because it gives us the opportunity to advance this issue through the Fourth Interstate.
Asked whether the decision could possibly affect other cases pending before the ECHR concerning E/C appeals against Turkey, Korneliu replied, "not necessarily. We just see this trend in international relations that many times such decisions are influenced by political reasons. Undoubtedly, a negative precedent is being set and we will have to see how to handle it."
He noted that "we will continue our efforts through the monitoring of the decisions of the Fourth Intergovernmental Conference."
It is noted that in its decision yesterday, the Committee of Deputy Ministers stated that it strongly insists on Turkey's unconditional obligation to pay without further delay the compensation decided by the European Court of Justice in the 33 Xenides-Arestis group cases.
It also decided to revisit the issue of payment of compensation and individual measures in the remaining Xenides-Arestis group cases at its September 2023 meeting and instructed the Secretariat, if the situation remains unchanged, to prepare a draft interim resolution on the payment of just satisfaction for consideration by the Commission at that meeting.
Source: CNA
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source