The deadly sinking of the passenger ferry "Express Samina" was the second biggest post-war maritime tragedy to hit the Greek shipping industry. It was preceded by that of the passenger ferry "Heraklion" in Falconera, on 8 December 1966, with 224 dead.
The wreck occurred at 22:15 on 26 September 2000 off Paros, when the "Express Samina" struck the rocky islet "Portes", causing it to suffer a large rupture and sink. The outcome of the tragedy was sad, as 81 people were recovered dead, while the number of survivors rose to 457. Among the dead was the deputy mayor of Paros, Dimitris Malamas, who suffered a heart attack during the rescue operation. The ship belonged to the company "Minoan Flying Dolphins" (now Hellenic Seaways) and had sailed from Piraeus to run the route Paros - Naxos - Ikaria - Samos - Patmos - Lipsi.
At the time of the tragedy, winds of eight Beaufort were blowing in the area, which made the rescue of the shipwreck victims difficult. Fishermen from Paros and Antiparos, Greek ships and two British warships, the "Liverpool" and the "Elizabeth", participated in the rescue efforts.
According to the testimonies of those rescued, the crew was not in place at the time of the shipwreck, while there were also complaints about the age of the vessel, defective life-saving equipment and the attitude of the crew in organising the evacuation process.
The "Express Samina" was 34 years old and by law was due to be withdrawn in three months, while according to a complaint by the ship's former chief engineer Anastasiou Soroka, who had been dismissed, the ship was sailing with many "patents" that made it dangerous for its occupants.
Criminal prosecutions
The following day, the Syros prosecutor's office brought criminal charges of manslaughter with possible malice against the master, the mate, the helmsman and the cadet master, as well as against all those responsible. The investigation also targeted the shipowning company, whose representatives have been charged with a felony for endangering passengers, and the state authorities responsible for rescuing the shipwreck victims.
On 3 October, the captain and the lieutenant of the "Express Samina", Vassilios Giannakis and Anastasios Psychogios, were remanded in custody by a unanimous decision of the investigator and the public prosecutor, while the helmsman Panagiotis Kasdaglis and the cadet Giorgos Patilas were released on bail.
Political controversies
From the very first moment, the then Prime Minister Konstantinos Simitis ordered that the causes of the shipwreck be fully investigated and that responsibility be attributed, while Merchant Shipping Minister Christos Papoutsis assured that the tragedy would be brought to light, saying that the knife would go to the bone.
The case also involved the Commission of the European Union, which in a letter to the competent Greek authorities asked for clarifications on the causes of the shipwreck, but also on compliance with Community maritime safety rules. It also asked for the file on the maritime tragedy to be handed over to the Commission and for clear guarantees as to the seaworthiness of all coastal vessels. In its reply, the Ministry of Merchant Shipping pointed out that the ship met all the terms and conditions laid down in the EU directives, The opposition's reflexes were immediate, calling for responsibility for the causes and circumstances of the shipwreck to be attributed, while placing enormous responsibility on the government and the Ministry of Merchant Shipping for the delay in rescuing the shipwreck victims.
The opposition's reflexes were immediate, calling for responsibility to be attributed for the causes and circumstances of the shipwreck, while placing enormous responsibility on the government and the Ministry of Merchant Shipping for the delay in rescuing the shipwreck victims.
On 2 October, in questions submitted to the Prime Minister in Parliament, the leaders of the opposition parties blamed the government and the shipowner. In addition, the leader of the opposition, Kostas Karamanlis, in a letter to the Prime Minister, asked for a debate to be held in Parliament at the level of political leaders on the shipwreck and the government's shipping policy, while Miltiades Evert called for the setting up of a preliminary investigation committee for the impeachment of former Merchant Marine Minister Stavros Soumakis (Christos Papoutsis had taken office in April 2000), in accordance with the law on ministerial responsibility.
Two days later, the Prime Minister, responding from Parliament to opposition criticisms, after admitting that there are problems in the shipping industry because operators provide a low level of quality, stressed that Greek ships are safe and that the fleet has been significantly renewed in recent years. Regarding the shipwreck, he said that accountability will proceed as the government is not covering up for anyone. Kostas Karamanlis accused Costas Simitis of lack of decency and philanthropy, spoke of rotten ships and favourable treatment of the Minoan Lines company and argued that there are political responsibilities. The secretary general of the KKE, Aleka Papariga, said that the government bears criminal responsibility for the shipwreck, while the president of the Coalition, Nikos Konstantopoulos, accused the government of turning public transport into a stock market gamble.
"No" to the establishment of a Commission of Inquiry
On 2 November, the House of Representatives, with 146 votes against, 121 in favour and one present from independent MP Vassilis Kedikoglou, rejected the New Democracy's proposal to set up a Commission of Inquiry into the safety of coastal shipping. PASOK and Synaspismos voted against the proposal, while ND and KKE voted for it.
On 29 November, the vice-president of "Minoan Flying Dolphins" and managing director of the company Pantelis Spinias ended his life by falling from the 6th floor of the company's offices in Piraeus.
On 29 November, the vice-president of "Minoan Flying Dolphins" and managing director of the company Pantelis Spinias ended his life by falling from the 6th floor of the company's offices in Piraeus. The reasons that led him to commit suicide remain unclear, while according to statements made by his colleagues after the tragic shipwreck of the "Express Samina", Sfinias was living under the suffocating pressure of media, political and financial problems.
The conclusion and the trial of the case
On 21 July 2003 the conclusion of the Supreme Council for Maritime Accidents was issued, which brought heavy charges against Captain Vasilios Giannakis, Lieutenant Anastasios Psychogios, Vice-Captain Georgios Triantafyllou and Chief Engineer Gerasimos Skiadaresis. The conclusion stressed that the ship would not have sunk if the watertight doors of the engine room had not been open and the rescue would have been more successful if the passengers had been informed in time.
Two years later, on 7 May 2005, the trial of the defendants in the "Express Samina" shipwreck began at the Piraeus Criminal Court of Appeal and on 27 February 2006 the decision was issued, according to which Captain Vassilios Giannakis was sentenced to 16 years' imprisonment and Lieutenant Anastasios Psychogios to 19 years' imprisonment. Eight years were imposed on XO Georgios Triantafyllou, 8.5 years on chief engineer Gerasimos Skiadaresis and 15 months on radio operator Dimitrios Tsumas. The company's representatives Nikolaos Vikatos and Konstantinos Klironomos were sentenced to four years' imprisonment each. The convicted persons, except the master and the second lieutenant, appealed and were released.
The trial in the second instance took place in 2007 at the Piraeus Criminal Court of Appeal. On 25 June the decision was issued, according to which the captain of the "Express Samina", Vassilis Giannakis Giannakis, was sentenced to 11 years and 14 months imprisonment and Lieutenant Anastasios Psychogios to 12 years and 9 months imprisonment. The court imposed three years' imprisonment on XO Georgios Triantafyllou, one year on chief engineer Georgios Skiadaressis and 10 months on radio operator Dimitrios Tsumas. The company's representatives Nikolaos Vikatos and Konstantinos Klironomos were sentenced to two years' imprisonment each. Giannakis and Psychogios were sent to prison and the others were released on probation or on bail. On 17 June 2010, the Supreme Court reduced the sentence of Captain Giannakis to 5.5 years.
Source: sansimera.gr
Contents of this article including associated images are belongs Cyprus Times
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or Cyprus Times
Source