What's new

[PIO] Written statement by the Assistant Attorney General of the Republic Mr.Savvas Angelides regarding the "black van" case and the allegations about

29565.jpg





From the outset I report that the events of the investigated case of the "black van" in no way seem to be linked to the use of any software system abroad and what came to light in Greece is unrelated to the whole issue concerning the case of the "black van" in Cyprus.

In order to formulate the correct dimension of the facts of the case and to correct any erroneous impressions that have been created, intentionally or not, I note the following:

1. The investigation of the "black van" case began on 15 November 2019 with a police investigation and shortly afterwards, an independent criminal investigator was appointed by the former Attorney General of the Republic, to assist the work of the Police.

2. The investigative work that the above investigative team was called upon to complete was extensive, complex and time-consuming precisely because of the number, type and nature of the items seized. All the evidence received by the Police was subjected to specialised forensic examination, both by Police experts and by a private expert specialising in telecommunications systems/networks and related security issues.

3. In addition, the electronic data extracted from the seized equipment was sent to a specialised Europol department for further investigation and analysis.

4. From the thorough scientific investigations carried out in Cyprus and abroad, no data tending to show that the equipment was used or functioned in practice for monitoring or interception of any form of communication (verbal or written) between users or interception of electronic files from devices were identified.

5. According to the findings of the tests, the operation of the systems was limited to the automated scanning, random (non-targeted) recording and storage of the International Mobile Subscriber Number (IMSI) of SIM cards and the MAC address number of electronic devices entering within the range of the system.

6. In addition to registering the criminal case against the company and three individuals for offences supported by the collected evidence, we informed the Privacy Commissioner of the personal data aspect of the case

7. The Privacy Commissioner, on 4 November 2021, exercising the powers conferred by the Act, imposed on "Ws Wispear Systems Ltd." an administrative fine of €925,000 in respect of the unlawful processing of personal data, as established during the police investigation. As stated in a statement by the Commissioner, the company fully accepted its responsibility and paid the fine to the Republic of Cyprus.

8. In conclusion, assessing, on the one hand, the uncertainty of the outcome of a hearing - especially when complex legal, but especially technical issues are raised - and, on the other hand, taking into account the assumption of full responsibility by "Ws Wispear Systems Ltd." before the Commissioner, the amount of the administrative fine imposed, which was punitive in nature, the immediate payment of the fine by the company, the fact that the electronic systems possessed by the company were not used for interception or interception of electronic communications (verbal or written) and the fact that the systems were operated as demos without targeting specific persons/users, we decided to discontinue the criminal proceedings against the three natural persons prosecuted, provided that the accused company "Ws Wispear Systems Ltd." would admit the charges corresponding to the collected evidence. Such a practice has been followed over time by the Prosecuting Authorities, where and when circumstances dictate.

9. Before the Court of Cassation, the accused company pleaded guilty to 42 charges and on 22 February 2022, it was fined €76,000. The accused company was, in essence, punished, in relation to its illegal conduct, with a total fine of €1,000,000, a penalty unprecedented in Cypriot judicial history.

10. I want to make it clear that if there was even a trace of testimony concerning interception or interception of any form of communication content (verbal or written), then the criteria for the course of the case would have been completely different.

As to the repeatedly raised allegations against me about my connection with Mr. Tal Dillian, I clearly state that these are unsubstantiated allegations that touch on slander and their ultimate purpose is to harm the Legal Service of the Republic and my person.

I clearly state that I am not aware of any connection between myself or my relatives and Mr. Tal Dillian and that there has never been any connection between me or my relatives and Mr. Tal Dillian. The fact that a relative of mine, a decade ago, intended to do business with Mr. Sahak Aviny, but there was no professional cooperation in the end, since it had failed from the beginning, as well as the fact that the company registered by my former law firm, on the instructions of my relative, was never activated, leaves no room for even the most disbelieving person to claim that there was a cover-up of the case or an obstacle to my participation in the decision making process of the "black van" case.

I am obliged to make the above clarifications without any intention of getting involved in controversies and political debates, both because of my position as Assistant Attorney General of the Republic and because of my character.

(BL)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO

Source

 
Back
Top