Mr President, Your Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen,
With only a few months left to complete my ten-year term of office, I stand before you to address the proceedings of this session of the General Assembly for the last time.
I would like nothing more than for this address to reflect positive developments in what humanity has faced or is facing.
Like all of you, I wish I could welcome the results of the implementation of either the provisions of the United Nations Charter or the resolutions and decisions of the General Assembly and the Security Council which would ensure that:
(i) Any threats or attempts to challenge the sovereignty and territorial integrity of any Member State of the United Nations have been completely terminated or minimized.
(ii) Long-standing conflicts and disputes have been resolved or are in the process of being resolved, in accordance with United Nations resolutions and decisions.
[III] That the need for reform of the Organization has led to the effective prevention of new threats and challenges to world peace.
(iv) That through its new role, the United Nations has implemented actions to effectively combat hunger and improve the living conditions of hundreds of millions of people in dire need.
(v) That the number of refugees and migrants forced to flee their homes because of conflict or poverty has been drastically reduced.
Further:
(vi) That we could address social and economic exclusion, lack of adequate health care standards and lack of educational opportunities.
(vii) That sustainable development would have finally become a reality for all countries and regions in need by establishing the necessary political and socio-economic conditions leading to stability, economic growth and institution building.
[VIII) THAT MEASURES TO PREVENT CLIMATE CHANGE AND ITS DEVASTATING CONSEQUENCES WOULD HAVE BEEN CONSISTENTLY IMPLEMENTED BY ALL PARTIES INVOLVED.
[IX] That terrorism and religious fundamentalism would have given way to tolerance and understanding.
(x) That the trillions of dollars spent on weapons of destruction would instead be spent on actions and programs aimed at bridging the gap between rich and poor states.
(xi) And finally, that this multilateralism would be the guiding doctrine of all states.
Excellencies, ladies and gentlemen,
Addressing the General Assembly in 2018 and referring to the inability to address the same problems, I wondered and I quote verbatim:
"So how is it that we return again and again, year after year, as a kind of ritual, to reaffirm the woeful lack of effectiveness by some and the attempted embellishment by others, for what is in fact our inability to fulfil the objectives of the UN Charter?"
Why do Security Council resolutions remain overwhelmingly just certificates attesting to violations?
Why are international law and international agreements not implemented?
Why do strategies and programmes aimed at creating better conditions for suffering people remain wishful thinking?"
Distinguished friends,
Although I am well aware that what I am about to say is known to all of you, for the sake of history I can only state some truths that lead to a declining course and a gradual loss of credibility of the United Nations.
An organization created immediately after the Second World War to prevent new disasters, to provide protection and hope to those who need effective protection and to act against all the challenges I have already mentioned.
I know that what I say may be outside the bounds of diplomatic etiquette, but I truly believe that every leader's obligation to history is not to overlook weaknesses and flaws in favor of piety or flattery.
This is why I will proceed to review not only the reasons that have turned the Organization into a repository of problems, but also what states need to do to give the Organization credibility and the ability to effectively enforce the international legal order or to consistently implement decisions and programmes for the benefit of humanity.
Ladies and gentlemen,
In my opinion, the weaknesses and ineffectiveness of the United Nations are due to the following:
1. The fact that economic or other interests of powerful member states take precedence over international law.
2. That despite the end of the Cold War, alliances based on common interests lead to tolerance of states that violate international law if the violator is within their sphere of influence.
3. The revival of hegemonic tendencies by certain states to create new empires, to the detriment of smaller states and in violation of international law.
4. Despite the stated intention of the Secretary-General of the United Nations to undertake the much needed reform and modernization of the Organization, as well as its functioning and decision-making procedures, the lack of willingness on the part of the aforementioned States has not allowed such a change to be implemented.
5. As a result of the same political considerations, the United Nations, unfortunately, adopts an attitude of equidistance, even when confronted with violations of decisions, resolutions and defined scope and competence that have been clearly reported to the Secretariat.
This has resulted in the emboldening of violating states, which not only ignore international law, but also set new precedents outside the framework of legality.
Ladies and gentlemen,
I have listed the main reasons for the lack of effectiveness and the inability of the United Nations to meet the expectations of billions of people.
I know that I may be seen as a romantic idealist, but I believe that recent events and problems affecting the world leave no choice but to take bold but necessary decisions, such as: A world order that ensures that peace, security, human rights and sustainable development remain the highest values we undertake to preserve and safeguard.
(b) Political will and determination to move forward with reform and modernization of the United Nations into a fair, effective and efficient multilevel system of governance.
And this process of reform and modernization is made all the more urgent and pressing by the imminent risk after 77 years of a "As Turkey, we want all issues in the Aegean and Eastern Mediterranean to be resolved within the framework of good neighbourly relations and in accordance with international law."
How ironic is it for the Turkish President to make such a claim when he threatens to occupy the Greek islands or when he commits thousands of violations of the airspace of a sovereign and neighbouring state in violation of international law?
How much more provocative is it to express a desire to resolve disputes "in accordance with international law" when he refuses to implement numerous UN resolutions on the Cyprus problem and creates new deadlocks?
How much more in accordance with international law is his refusal to comply with:
(a) General Assembly Resolution 3212, adopted in October 1974, calling for the speedy withdrawal of all foreign armed forces and foreign military presence and personnel from the Republic of Cyprus and the cessation of all foreign interference in its affairs.
(b) Resolution adopted by Security Council Resolution 365 in December of the same year.
(c) Security Council Resolution 1251 of 1999, which reaffirms its position that the settlement of the Cyprus problem should be based on a State of Cyprus with a single sovereignty and international personality and a single citizenship, with its independence and territorial integrity safeguarded, within the framework of a bizonal and bicommunal federation.
It is also stressed that such a settlement must exclude the union of all or part of it with any other country as well as any form of partition or secession. Erdoğan last year claimed that efforts should focus on reaching a settlement based on so-called "realities on the ground", while this year he spoke of the need for everyone to "see the truth" and that there are "two separate states and two separate peoples on the island today."
And I wonder what truth he is talking about?
1. The truth that 37% of the territory of the Republic of Cyprus, an EU member state, remains under military occupation?
2. The truth that after the Turkish invasion of 1974 one third of Greek Cypriots were forced to leave their ancestral homes?
3. The truth that they have implanted hundreds of thousands of Turkish nationals in the occupied areas, thus changing the demographic character of the island: turning Turkish Cypriots into a minority in the areas they illegally occupy?
4. The truth that Turkey has established an illegal entity in the occupied areas, which is under its absolute political, economic, social, cultural and religious control;
An illegal entity described by the European Court of Human Rights as a "subordinate local administration" of Turkey;
5. The truth that Turkey is trying to equate the State, the internationally recognized Republic of Cyprus, with the illegal secessionist entity;
6. The truth that the above declaration of alleged secession has been condemned by the Security Council and considered legally invalid?
7. The truth that the Security Council has called for its revocation and for all States and the international community as a whole not to accept it or assist it in any way;
8. The truth that they are trying to change the status of the walled city of Famagusta, contrary to UN Council Resolutions 550 and 789;
9. The truth that Turkey is adopting its own arbitrary interpretation of international law which reduces the Exclusive Economic Zone of Cyprus by 44%, to the detriment of both Greek Cypriots and Turkish Cypriots, contrary to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea?
Mr President,
Ladies and gentlemen,
As I have pointed out before, when decisions or resolutions based on international law are not to be implemented or enforced, then this could rightly be seen as encouraging or even rewarding arbitrariness.
This is exactly what we are witnessing today with the Cyprus problem. Turkey, which systematically violates international law, is calling on the international community to recognize its illegal achievements.
Dear friends,
Unfortunately, this has been Turkey's long-standing goal since 1956.
This is why, despite historic compromises on the part of the Greek Cypriot side, all efforts to reach a solution to the Cyprus problem have failed as a result of Turkey's intransigent attitude and unreasonable demands.
The latest example is the Conference on Cyprus held in Crans Montana in July 2017, during which, with regard to the internal aspects of the Cyprus problem, the UN Secretary General assessed in his report on 28 September 2017 that: "The key outstanding issues related to governance and power-sharing remained few" and that "by the close of the Conference, the parties had effectively resolved the key issue of effective participation".
Thus, while the Secretary-General's goal of reaching a strategic agreement was close, the reason for the unsuccessful outcome was Turkey's rigid stance and insistence on maintaining the anachronistic Treaty of Guarantee, the right of intervention and the permanent presence of troops.
And I would like to recall the UN Secretary-General's June 2017 statement in which he stressed that: "Progress on this Security and Assurances Chapter is a key element in reaching a comprehensive agreement."
After a period of stalemate and despite our frustration, we took new initiatives to resume the process from where it left off in Crans-Montana, culminating in the Joint Statement reached with the UN Secretary General and the Turkish Cypriot leader on 25 November 2019, which reaffirmed the principles for the resumption of a new round of talks.
In particular: the Joint Statement of 11 February 2014, the previous convergences and the six-point framework presented by the UN Secretary General in Crans-Montana.
Unfortunately, once again, Turkey undermined the prospect of resuming the negotiation process and instead, at the meeting held in April 2021, they presented their position to change the agreed basis for a solution from a federal solution to a two-state solution.
Nevertheless, our side took a new initiative which also led to a new joint meeting of the leaders of the two communities with the UN Secretary General in September 2021, during which it was agreed that the latter would proceed with the appointment of a Representative to consult with both sides and all stakeholders in order to reach common ground for the resumption of a new peace process.
Once again, Turkey has refused to abide by this agreement.
We also continued to take initiatives to break the deadlock, with the letter I sent to the Turkish Cypriot leader on 23 May 2022, in which I conveyed constructive proposals for the adoption of Confidence Building Measures for the benefit of both sides.
Measures which, unfortunately, were immediately rejected by the Turkish Cypriot side, which put forward its own proposals in line with its objective of a two-state solution.
In view of the above, I believe it is clear that the Greek Cypriot community has made and will continue to make every effort to resume the talks with the aim of achieving a solution based on the UN Resolutions.
And as I have stressed, the only way to achieve a resolution of disputes and peace is through unwavering commitment to international law and the UN Charter, but not arbitrarily interpreted by those who seek to disguise their aspirations for revisionism.
Ladies and gentlemen,
During my ten years in office, I may not have been fortunate enough to see what the vast majority would have wished for: much-needed reforms of the international organization, resolution of international disputes and addressing challenges affecting hundreds of millions of people, such as hunger, poverty and climate change.
I may not have been lucky enough to see my country reunited, with my Greek Cypriot and Turkish Cypriot compatriots living in peace, prosperity and stability.
But I sincerely hope that in my lifetime I will be able to see a better and more stable future for humanity.
Thank you very much for your attention.
(EF/EP/NG/EC/SX)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source