Clarifications on statistical sources/surveys and comparative differences between them
[/P]The Statistical Office, based on the Official Statistics Law of 2021, is designated as the competent authority responsible for the coordination of all activities in the Republic for the development, production and dissemination of official statistics, which are specified in the annual and multi-annual programme of statistical activities.
Official statistics are developed, produced and disseminated on the basis of uniform European standards and harmonised methods in order to ensure the quality of the results and, in this context, the Statistical Office applies the criteria for assessing statistical quality as defined in the Law on Statistics of 2021, namely relevance, accuracy, timeliness, punctuality, accessibility and clarity, comparability and consistency.
On the occasion of the publications and debates on the median wage/median earnings, the Statistical Office considers it imperative to provide clarifying information on the surveys it conducts and the official statistics it produces and publishes that are relevant to the subject under consideration.
At the outset, it is important to stress that the Statistical Office publishes data on average and median monthly earnings on the basis of two main sources/statistical work:
1) Earnings Survey 2) Average Monthly Earnings of Employees from data from the Social Insurance Archives
Regarding the Survey on Income and Living Conditions of Households (EU-SILC), which has been mentioned in recent publications repeatedly, is a survey conducted by the Statistical Office under a European Regulation, which is used in the calculation of statistics related to income distribution, poverty, social exclusion and living conditions. This survey does not produce official statistics on average and median earnings either at national level by the Statistical Office or at European level by the European Statistical Office (Eurostat), as it is designed to serve a completely different purpose. The figures presented in the discussions are not official statistics but are instead the result of a study based on assumptions made by private researchers.
The EU-SILC survey has been organised and conducted by Eurostat on an annual basis since 2005, on the basis of the annual Statistical Programme of Activities. The "EU-SILC" as stated in many publications is not a "European Agency", not a "European Commission", not a "methodology for determining labour market realities" nor a "School" or "Eurostat Methodology" or "ILO Methodology" for calculating median earnings. The separation of the EU-SILC Survey from other official statistics, presenting it as a "survey conducted by the European Statistical Office" as opposed to "domestically produced statistics", is a product of ignorance and misinformation.
- Source 1: Earnings Survey - Average and Median Monthly Earnings
The Earnings Survey (EA) is a recurrent survey conducted by the Statistical Office since 2002, with a frequency of every four years, on the basis of the European Regulation (EC) No. 530/1999 concerning structural statistics on earnings and labour costs. It is the main source of information on the evolution over time of the remuneration of employees in the labour market in Cyprus. The data from this survey are sent to Eurostat which subsequently publishes statistics on average and median earnings, after having carried out qualitative checks.
The aim of the survey is to provide data that are accurate and harmonised between EU Member States and acceding countries, for policy-making and research purposes. The EA provides detailed and comparable data on the relationship between the level of employees' earnings, their individual characteristics (gender, age, occupation, length of service, highest completed level of education, etc.) and their employer (economic activity, size, etc.)
It is a sample survey carried out through face-to-face interviews in enterprises. Administrative sources are also used: General Accounting Office of the Republic, Public Service Commission, Education Service Commission, Cyprus Police and Social Insurance Archives. Sampling is carried out in two stages: first a sample of enterprises is selected (stratified sampling according to size) and then a sample of employees (simple random sampling in each enterprise).
The EA covers enterprises in all economic activities except Agriculture, Fishing, Activities of Private Households and Activities of HHs (Sections B - S of the NACE Rev. 2 classification system). Enterprises with 1 or more employees are covered. The EA covers the population of employees working in the enterprise in the reference month. The statistical unit for the survey is the employee.
In Cyprus, the most recent EA was carried out for the fifth time in 2019, with the reference year 2018 and the final sample included 1,372 enterprises and 29,367 employees.
The main variables of the survey are hourly earnings, monthly earnings and annual earnings for employees by gender, type of employment (full/part-time), age, length of service in the enterprise, occupational category and highest completed level of education.
Tables with data on average and median hourly, monthly and annual earnings of employees are published. The data on hourly earnings shall include information on part-time and full-time employees, while for monthly and annual earnings, only full-time employees shall be taken into account. The data are broken down by economic activity of employers and by occupational category of employees. There is also information linking the level of earnings to the nationality of employees and to the form of financial control of the employer (public/private control).
For purposes of monitoring average and median earnings in the interim years in which the Earnings Survey is not conducted, annual data on average monthly earnings of employees reporting gross earnings are produced. They shall be based on the records of the Social Security Services and shall refer only to employees. The calculation of the data takes into account the earnings of all employees in the Social Security Institution's file (both full-time and part-time). The average monthly remuneration of employees includes basic salary, the index-linked allowance, overtime pay, the leave fund, any allowances received by employees during the reference period, as well as 13th salary and back-payments, before deducting any contributions to compulsory social security funds. Employees with earnings of less than 50% of the minimum wage according to the Minimum Wage Decree are excluded from the data, as they are considered not to be in regular employment. All economic sectors are covered except for the activities of households as employers and the activities of heteronomous organisations and institutions.
By comparing the two sources in common years, it can be seen that there is consistency and comparability in the results published.
- ) - Income distribution, Income distribution, poverty risk and social exclusion
The Household Income and Living Conditions Survey (EU-SILC) is conducted by the Statistical Office under Regulation (EU) 2019/1700 of the European Parliament and of the Council, and aims to collect synchronic and longitudinal microdata on income distribution, poverty and social exclusion. This microdata should be comparable across European Union (EU) Member States. It examines, inter alia, various EU policies on living conditions and poverty, such as child poverty, access to health care and other services, housing, household indebtedness and quality of life. It is also the main source of data for the purpose of producing flash estimates of the distribution of income and poverty risk.
It is a sample survey conducted through face-to-face and telephone interviews in households using computers. It also makes use of administrative sources: Salaries and Pensions from the General Accounting Office of the Republic, Benefit Payments from Social Security Services (through the Central Information Warehouse (CAP)), Social Benefit Payments from Various State Services (through the Central Information Warehouse (CAP)). A rotating design of 4 sub-samples is followed with the replacement of one sub-sample each year. Each year the sub-sample that has completed 4 years in the survey is removed and a new one is selected in its place. This design is suitable to cover the synchronic and longitudinal component of the survey. Stratified sampling by province and urban/rural area (9 strata) is used to select the sample. In each stratum the sample is selected by simple random sampling. EU-SILC covers households on a nationwide basis. The statistical unit for the survey is the household and its members. The final sample size is approximately 5,000 households.
In conclusion, in view of what the Statistical Office is informed by the various publications on median wages/median earnings, it is evident that, references to median wages beyond the official statistics published by the Statistical Office have caused confusion and uncertainty both at home and abroad.
The Statistical Office considers that the use of official statistics as a source of information for policy-making promotes democratic dialogue among stakeholders and leads to scientifically sound decision-making, since appropriate statistical procedures with transparency, reliability, objectivity and impartiality are used in the compilation of official statistics.
The table below summarises the main differences between the three surveys/tasks covered above:
Table: Comparative differences between the three surveys/tasks
| Source 1: Earnings Survey | Source 2: | EU-SILC | |
| Legal Framework | Regulation (EC) No. 530/1999 concerning structural statistics on earnings and labour costs | Conducted at national level for the formulation of policy on earnings. | Regulation (EU) 2019/1700 of the European Parliament and of the Council establishing a common framework for European statistics on individuals and households based on data collected from samples at individual level. |
| Coverage - Economic Activity | All economic activities except Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing, the activities of households as employers and the activities of NPISHs. |
All economic activities, except the activities of households as employers and the activities of heteronomous organisations and institutions. |
[TD]
-
[/TD] [/TD][TR] [TD]
Coverage - Enterprise size
[/TD] [/TD] [TD]Enterprises with 1+ employees
[/TD] [/TD] [TD]Enterprises with 1+ employees
[/TD] [TD]-
[/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]Coverage - Population
[/TD] [TD]Employees who worked and were paid for the reference month
[/TD] [/TD] [TD]All employees who have contributed to the Social Insurance Fund in the reference year.
[/TD] [TD]Persons 16+ in households nationwide
[/TD] [/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]
Sample size (net)
[/TD] [TD]29.367 employees [BR]
(2018 survey)
[/TD] [TD]
~ 350,000 - 400,000 employees per month
[/TD] [TD]4.188
persons employed in wage employment (FY 2016 Survey)
[/TD] [/TD] [/TR] [TR] [TD]
Data availability
[/TD] [TD]Every 4 years
[/TD] [/TD] [TD]Annual
[/TD] [TD]Annual
[/TD] [/TR]
(MB/IK)
Contents of this article including associated images are owned by PIO
Views & opinions expressed are those of the author and/or PIO
Source